Are degrees getting easier?

graduation

by Charlotte Bransgrove

Statistics published by the Durham Student Registry have highlighted that the classification of degrees awarded to graduating finalists has been increasing over the past thirteen years.

In 1999, 65.5% of graduates were awarded a 2:1 or above by the University, whilst by 2012 this figure had increased to 84%. This means the vast majority of students are now leaving university with a ‘good’ degree: either a first or an upper second classification.

Correspondingly, the number of students obtaining a 2:2 has more than halved from 27.6% in 1999 to 13.85% in 2012, whilst those receiving a third dropped from 5.3% to just 1.01%.

Moreover, the amount of first class honours degrees awarded to Durham graduates nearly doubled from 11.2% to 21.26%.

This is consistent with a nation-wide trend in the United Kingdom, with Higher Education Statistics Agency (HESA) reporting that 40,670 graduates left university with a first in 2012, accounting for 16.7%, or around 1/6 of total graduates.

The extent of grade inflation in UK universities has led to allegations that university is becoming easier, and that the value of a good degree is now diminishing because of the number of students attaining higher marks.

Speaking to Palatinate, Sam Dale, Deputy Academic Registrar for the University, commented: “Since the late 1990s, the number of students leaving with first class degrees has increased at universities across the country.

“Research indicates that this may be due to a number of factors, such as improvements to the quality and structure of teaching nationwide, use of a broader range of assessment methods that test different graduate skills, and a rise in entry criteria, particularly at highly selective universities such as Durham.

“everyone ends up with similar results, so having a good degree does not make you stand out”

“The rise in the number of firsts should accordingly not be interpreted as a decline in academic standards.

“We have a long history of producing sought-after graduates and an ambitious Employability and Enterprise Skills Strategy, committing us to producing graduates who are in high demand and stand the best chance of securing the employment they want.”

David Morris, Academic Affairs Officer for Durham Students’ Union, branded the subject of assessment processes as “an incredibly complex issue, difficult to break down.”

He added that further research is required to fully understand such issues, stating: “Both in Durham and nationally we need far more hard evidence, particularly in the form of student feedback and student engagement, to ascertain whether grades really are rising in line with better student learning, or if there is something else at work.”

Many students will however take comfort in the fact that it is highly likely they will leave university with a good degree, particularly when entering into extremely competitive job markets in which many graduate schemes require a minimum of a 2:1 degree to even submit an application.

Dan, a third year reading Mathematics, said: “I work really hard to get high marks because I’m aware of how tough the job situation is. It’s encouraging to see that it’s likely all my efforts will be paid off when I come to graduate.”

Others, however, believe grade inflation only adds to the problem because employers cannot distinguish between applicants.

Joe, a second year Natural Sciences student, commented: “Grade inflation does little to benefit students because nearly everyone ends up with similar results, so having a good degree does not make you stand out.

“It’s high time we started distinguishing between students just scraping 70% to those reaching above 80% in first class honours so that employers can separate exceptional candidates. The current degree classification system is severely outdated.”

Furthermore, the statistics also demonstrate that the number of firsts and upper seconds awarded varies greatly for different departments.

In 2012 for example, 41.48% of English graduates obtained a first class honours degree, while in Government and International Affairs only 9.54% of graduates received a first.

This raises further concerns about whether marking is consistent across departments and whether it is easier to get higher marks in certain subjects.

Sam, a finalist in International Relations, reacted to the statistics, noting: “Even within the arts faculty, it appears that there is disparity with marking between departments.

“Most humanities subjects require similar skills such as essay writing and extracting information from sources, and many people choose joint honours degrees or opt to take elective modules in different departments.

“it seems strange that students may or may not get a first depending on what subject they choose to specialise in”

“The entrance requirements across Durham are very high, and so it seems strange that students with similar applications and skills may or may not get a first depending on what subject they choose to specialise in.”

Responding to concerns over marking, Dale added: “The University has a rigorous quality management framework which maintains the integrity of our academic standards.

“The classification of students’ performance is overseen by Boards of Examiners comprised of academic staff and verified by external examiners, who consistently confirm that our standards are appropriate and comparable to other leading institutions.

“Classification data is reviewed annually at department, faculty and University level to ensure that this mechanism remains robust.”

Further information and all statistics can be found at Durham Student Registry on the University website.

Photograph: Durham University Images