Booker Prize 2026 reviews – Elizabeth Strout’s ‘The Things We Never Say’
By Stephanie Mackey
At the time of writing this, America has just delivered a political rebuke to Donald Trump. The Democrats’ sweeping victories in the midterm elections suggest a country eager, at least partly, to turn away from the politics that have defined the past two years. Yet, the anger that fuelled Trump’s return to the White House in January 2025 has hardly disappeared. Political divisions seem to have found their way into even the most ordinary encounters. It is against this unsettled backdrop that Elizabeth Strout’s The Things We Never Say feels so achingly contemporary. Set within a small Massachusetts community, it reflects a country struggling to make sense of itself. Though, more than anything, it is concerned with how little we really know about the people around us.
At the novel’s centre is Artie Dam, a high-school history teacher whose life appears, from the outside, entirely unremarkable. He has a family and a job he loves, yet beneath this lies a profound sense of isolation. Artie is a lost man, unable to articulate the loneliness that has taken hold of him, even to those closest to him. At school, he encounters similarly troubled students, carrying fears they cannot quite put into words. “Why can’t anybody talk about what’s really happening?” he wonders; it is a question that extends well beyond the classroom.
Strout does not give us a fully conventional or tightly plotted narrative. Instead, we move between Artie’s family, colleagues, students, and wider circle of acquaintances, with the story unfolding through a series of episodes. These episodes may seem minor at times, but they demonstrate how little in human life is truly disconnected. A passing remark, a small act of kindness, or a seemingly insignificant moment of cruelty can reverberate far beyond its immediate setting. This was a particular strength of the novel, how Strout gradually brings these lives together to show how even the smallest interactions can leave a mark on the wider community. Knowingly or otherwise, we are all implicated in one another’s stories.
The novel’s shifting chronology is especially impactful. Strout moves backwards in memories and forwards, occasionally revealing a character’s fate before we have fully understood even the present moment. These glimpses into the future grant the narrative a heaviness, as we watch events unfold with the knowledge that their consequences may be greater than anyone involved can comprehend. Even the seemingly mundane administrative actions of the school principal, Hoover Lakeland, are given an ominous significance. In the America Strout constructs, we are made to consider how much can be concealed within an apparently insignificant moment.
There is, of course, a political undercurrent beneath these personal stories. Set in the aftermath of the pandemic and against the backdrop of the 2024 presidential election, the novel captures America exhausted by its own divisions. “There is a lot of anger out there these days, even more than I had known,” Artie observes. The national mood seeps into the domestic sphere and the classroom. The upheaval in Artie’s own life unfolds alongside that of the election, and the parallels are hard to ignore. Both expose the fragility of things that had previously appeared secure; yet, Strout never allows the wider political picture to overshadow the people living through it.
At the novel’s midpoint, a long-held secret comes to light, fundamentally changing Artie’s understanding of his family. Strout reveals this with a striking matter-of-factness. There is little great theatrical build-up and no immediate explosion of emotion, a sense of restraint which at first can feel slightly disconcerting. But perhaps it is also one of the novels most perceptive qualities. The events that change our lives do not announce themselves as such in every situation. Sometimes the devastation creeps in on an otherwise ordinary Wednesday, taking its time to settle in before we understand quite how much has changed. Artie’s experience feels all the more convincing for it.
At just over two hundred pages, The Things We Never Say is a deceptive book. It is tempting to read it quickly, but doing so would miss so much of its pleasure and depth. This is not a novel to devour so much as one to sit with its observations long after you have turned the page. In a world so overwhelmed by the noise of competing voices and anger, Strout reminds us how much goes unsaid even between those who know each other best. As Strout writes, “All of us live with a huge blind spot before our eyes, meaning that no matter what we think we know we can never fully understand how we appear to others.” We might never fully understand one another, but that is no reason to stop trying.
Image Credit: Nina R (Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons)

