Booker Prize 2026 reviews – Douglas Stuart’s ‘John of John’
By Phoebe Johnstone
For such a successful author, the blurb of Douglas Stuart’s latest book, John of John, does not set it up to be a riveting, up-till-the-early-hours read. What could be exciting about a broke, textiles graduate (John-Calum Macleod) returning to his family home? Does the mention of sheep farming, weaving and the Presbyterian Church get other people hot under the collar? Get people piling into bookshops? If anything, I thought that the most intriguing revelation of the blurb was that Cal’s father, John, had been living with his mother-in-law for decades. I’m still convinced there is a great murder mystery in that…
But contrary to what the blurb might suggest, when reading Stuart, you are in safe hands. Since entering the literary fray at the age of forty-four, he has hardly put a foot wrong; his debut novel “Shuggie Baine” won the 2020 Booker Prize, ‘Book of the Year’ and ‘Debut of the Year’ at the British Book Awards. His second book ‘Young Mungo’ was a Sunday Times Best Seller. And although, as observed by The Guardian, Stuart’s work does have an “occasionally miserabilist tenor” and his characters a tendency for “frequent self-pity” this doesn’t seem to be detracting from his popular and critical success, not when John of John has just been shortlisted for The Booker Prize 2026.
John-Calum Macleod (Cal) left Harris for the Scottish capital to study textiles. But a few years down the line he is a struggling graduate working as a cleaner, couch-surfing and scrounging for scraps of food in his mate’s cupboards. It’s at this point that Cal gets the news that his Grandma Ella’s feet are “as purple as calf liver” and he is recalledto Falabay where he must face up to the family and community he left behind.
Waiting by the bus shelter in anxious anticipation of Cal’s arrival is his father, John Macleod; a precentor of the Presbyterian church, sheep farmer, weaver, general handyman and all-round pillar of society. Perhaps because of his active role in the community, John is all the more alarmed by his son’s new look, his charity shop clothing and long, hacked-at hair. John can’t help but remark that Cal “look[s] like a cross-dresser that’s thrown on a coat because he’s run out of milk.” Not exactly charm personified. And with this, Stuart draws you into the excruciating politics of the Macleod household.
Stuart does not shy away from big questions and heavy hitting themes, the sort which qualify a novel for Oprah’s Book Club. (Spoiler – this has been one of book club picks for 2026.) Class, masculinity and sexuality are all through lines of Shuggie Baine, Young Mungo and John of John are no exception. Both John and Cal are gay but are dogged by the fierce conservatism of their community. Being a younger man, and having sampled life on the mainland, Cal is somewhat more comfortable with his sexuality and Cal continues to pursue companionship in Falabay by whatever fleeting means possible. At one point, in a very original scene, Cal puts his hard-earned, textiles degree to use by replying to a personal ad in the newspaper with a knitted dick pick. Unfortunately, John is not even close to creating phallic art. Instead, he must perform an elaborate pantomime to hide his sexuality, a devastating double act that leaves him “caught between his lover, his son and his maker” and ultimately feeling “a disappointment to all.”
Though these two characters are the beating heart of the novel, it has so much else to offer. There is a wider cast of fascinating characters waiting to be met including formidable Grandmothers, benevolent lovers and wayward childhood friends. It is also a four-hundred page homage to Scotland, to the cutting Hebridean landscape and to the traditional practices of crofting and weaving, as Stuart draws on his own experience in fashion to poetically detail “all the romantic colours of Scotland.”
So, on the one hand, the blurb of John of John is a perfect reflection of what lies between the covers – it really is a meandering, character driven tale that talks quite a bit about sheep farming, weaving and the Presbyterian church. But on the other, it underplays just how thoughtful, intelligent and consuming Stuart’s writing is, so much so that, if you’re anything like me, your copy will be left black and blue from underlining.
Image Credit: Colin (Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons)

