Blue eyes: a window into the cyclical nature of trends
For centuries blue eyes have been revered for their intense colour and icy character. Be it the cold splendour of Paul Newman or the piercing youthfulness of Zooey Deschanel, blue eyes have always lent their owners an air of isolation – of dispassionate mystique.
So the news of a new surgical technique, a procedure that changes eye colour from brown to blue, may come as good news to those who lust after these sapphire tones.
Currently in the second phase of human clinical trials, the surgery has been patented by the California-based Stroma-Medical, and it might not be long before the treatment is available to any brown-eyed individuals with a few thousand dollars to spare.
The method is quite similar to laser eye surgery, only instead of using a laser beam to alter the cornea – the surface of the eye – the beam is instead directed into the iris. The intense ray kills off cells that produce a pigment called melanin, which is responsible for turning eyes brown.
The technique’s premise is surprisingly simple. It rests on the knowledge that everyone’s eyes are, in fact, blue. However, in brown eyes this is not visible due to the masking layer of melanin. Get rid of the melanin, and the underlying blue colour is easily visible.
The blue colour itself is not a result of pigmentation, but of an effect known as Tyndall scattering, whereby only high frequency (blue) light leaves the eye, due to the iris’ absorptive effects.
This technique is irreversible. Pigment cells can be destroyed, but not rebuilt. We are still a long way off being able to give brown eyes to natural blues, at least without the aid of coloured contact lenses.
This raises a very interesting scenario. Imagine a future where the procedure is widely available: thousands flock to change their eye colour, to share in the exclusivity of ‘club blue.’
But with each new patient, the proportion of blue eyes in the world increases. Just a little. Over time, the fraction of blue-eyed individuals in the world – which current estimates place at about 8% – will keep rising with every new operation that takes place. Suddenly the allure of blue eyes has faded – are they no longer so exclusive after all?
Fashion is, in many ways, just a numbers game. The more exclusive something appears to be, the more highly sought after it is.
When enough people have their hands on whatever is deemed to be ‘in’, that exclusivity is lost, and something new moves in to take its place.
Take a recent study by the University of New South Wales. In this, participants were asked to rank men with varying degrees of facial hair in order of attractiveness, after they had already been shown numerous images of men with or without beards, against which they drew subconscious comparisons.
The results were clear: the rarer beards were in the samples, the more attractive they were perceived to be. Likewise, in a sea of facial fuzz, clean-shaven arose as the victor.
The study led Dr Rob Brooks, one of the study’s coordinators, to announce that we as a society may have reached ‘Peak Beard’.
“Big thick beards are back with an absolute vengeance; one of the dynamics that might be important is this idea of negative frequency dependence,” Brooks recently told the BBC.
This concept has been the subject of much study. In a paper published in the Journal of Evolution and Human Behaviour, Alex Bentley of Durham University used a mathematical model to show that when people copy each other randomly, with only occasional, sporadic deviation away from the top trend, fashions still follow cyclical, predictable patterns.
This model can accurately predict the nature of many trends and fashions – from favoured baby names to pop music chart-toppers.
Dr Bentley said, “It doesn’t necessarily have to involve any rational decisions to get all the way to the top.”
A final, interesting point to raise is one in defence of brown eyes. They are, in fact, very attractive – and it’s due, again, to subconscious perception.
We find people sexier when their pupils are dilated – it’s a subliminal sign of attraction – and a dark brown colour manages to trick us into perceiving someone’s pupils as bigger, and therefore more attractive.
This explains the romance of a dim candle-lit dinner, where pupils dilate automatically in the low light. Why would any straight-thinking brown-eyed person ever want to rid themselves of such useful assets?
Like a lean physique or a winning smile, it appears that some things are immune to the nature of fashion trends and popularity stats- we are simply programmed to adore them. And in this case it’s not the azure depths of blue eyes, but the dark allure of brown eyes that wins out.
Illustration: Patrick Brennan

