Black out or pay out for the EFL?

By Rob White

There are many quirks of English football. Included are Bovril, Match of the Day and the Boxing Day fixtures. But one peculiarity that arguably shapes weekly football more than any other is the 3pm blackout: a period of two and a half hours every Saturday where live football cannot be shown on television screens. In replacement, many tune in to the various programmes updating viewers of the progress in the 3pm scores, such as Gillette Labs Soccer Saturday.

On the face of it, it is a bizarre phenomenon, so much so that it is only England, Scotland and Montenegro that make use of UEFA’s Article 48 – the statute which allows the blackout to take place. But the tradition is nonetheless one which is a staple of the English footballing weekend, having been present since the 1960s.

However, the EFL has now started the process of ending this tradition by opening itself up to broadcast offers for the 2024-2025 season onwards. This will concern the rights to show all 1,891 matches across the lower professional leagues, EFL Cup, EFL Trophy and all end of season play-off matches. There is huge debate about this move.

The conversation surrounding whether there will be a drop off in attendances for both home and away fans, whether clubs lower down the football pyramid will be affected and, if a TV deal were to be struck, whether the money can be efficiently and fairly distributed amongst the affected clubs are all important debates to be had.

But in reality, nobody knows the current efficacy of the blackout and nobody knows exactly what will happen if all games were to be broadcast live. However, although intimately linked to these financial points, something that is being neglected in the conversation is the cultural argument. Not everything should be judged on the basis of whether there is more money to be made by expanding audiences.

There is huge debate about this move

In fact, that has been football’s downfall recently – particularly when you look at the proposed European Super League and the expansion of the number of teams in the 2026 World Cup onwards. Whilst it would be wrong to ignore the potential financial impact across the entire pyramid, this economics-obsessed outlook is problematic in football generally, not least in the case of the 3pm blackout.

In the United Kingdom, football clubs are often the social hub of towns and cities. They are so important for local communities, whether that be the pubs who survive because of matchdays, or people who sell scarves and programmes at the ground, or those who merely look forward to their team playing and soaking in the atmosphere at the weekend.

Even though there is an implicit economic argument, it is the culture and community that risks being threatened most of all by the removal of the 3pm blackout. This is particularly so in the EFL, where clubs tend to be less sanitised and are closer to their roots.

There are plenty of fans who are more casual and are encouraged to go to games in person because of the blackout, which is integral to communities up and down the country. Many point to the fact that barely any other European nations enforce this rule.

However, none of these other countries quite have the same depth of quality and support as the clubs in the EFL. It is this uniqueness of English football culture that sets it apart from its European counterparts, and thus the comparisons become redundant. European countries typically do not share the same Saturday 3pm culture, meaning a blackout would not have the same effect as it does in the English football eco-system.

Football is first and foremost for those with nothing but their emotions invested

Others suggest that the move would help the little viewer: those who want to watch their own team in England on television who cannot otherwise, whilst those abroad thousands of miles away are able to. But, unfortunately, it is the comfort of watching your team on television which damages the association football tradition that is so strong in England.

The counterargument is that people just watch an illegal stream anyway. This significantly overestimates how many everyday football fans will actually go out of their way to find a dodgy stream to watch on their laptop on a Saturday afternoon. Most people are not that digitally savvy, nor are they patient enough to do so.

Nevertheless, if the games were legally shown on television, it is the EFL and grassroots football clubs and their communities who would feel the repercussions. It is also crucial to remember that the broadcasters and many of those involved financially with football clubs do not care so much for the communities where the football club is the heart and soul.

Instead, they care more about potential profit. Whilst perhaps they feign solidarity with the average television viewer, in essence this proposal ultimately aims to expand television audiences for corporations to increase their profits. Association football culture is much more important to the beautiful game than the lucrative financial benefit that can be drawn from it by a select few.

History tells us that when it comes down to money in football, the media men and big clubs tend to win in the end. It is paramount that, in the face of this, football is first and foremost for those with nothing but their emotions invested.

Image: Joe Harston