Biden picks Jackson

By Joe Rossiter

On Friday 25th February, President Joe Biden officially nominated Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson to the Supreme Court, fulfilling his campaign commitment to add the first black woman to the bench. If confirmed, Jackson will replace retiring liberal Justice Stephen Breyer — nominated by Bill Clinton in 1994 — but would do little to dilute the Court’s conservative majority.

Raised in Miami, Florida, Jackson’s parents were initially public school teachers before her father became chief attorney for the Miami-Dade County School Board and her mother a principal. She attended Harvard University before progressing to Harvard Law School, which, with Yale Law School, was attended by eight of the nine current Justices.

After graduating in 1996, Jackson performed a series of clerkships, including for Justice Breyer, whom she is set to replace, from 1999 to 2000. The period before her first judicial appointment also includes two years spent as a federal public defender, which the White House has stressed would make her the first Supreme Court Justice with such experience. Not since Thurgood Marshall, the Court’s first African-American Justice, has the bench seen an individual with such extensive experience as a defence lawyer.

Biden’s nominee understands the law in more than simply the abstract

Like Marshall, Jackson has experience with social justice issues. While at university, her uncle was sentenced to life in prison for a non-violent drug offence on the basis of the ‘three strikes’ law. Jackson persuaded a law firm to take the case pro bono, eventually leading to then-President Barack Obama commuting the sentence.

Jackson also has a track record of bipartisan Senate support. She has been confirmed to three different positions by the chamber: unanimously to Vice-Chair of the US Sentencing Commission in 2009, by unanimous voice vote to the DC district court in 2012 and most recently to the DC appellate court in 2021.

That most recent appointment was key in so many reporting Jackson as the favourite to replace Breyer. She was confirmed by a narrow margin (53 to 44) but crucially with three Republican votes. Senators Lindsey Graham, Susan Collins and Lisa Murkowski all supported Jackson’s elevation to the position vacated by Merrick Garland on his move to the Department of Justice. Garland’s 2016 Supreme Court nomination was famously throttled by then-Senate majority leader Mitch McConnell, leading to the ultimate confirmation of Neil Gorsuch, laying the foundations for the current 6-3 conservative majority on the Court. If Democrats feel some poetic justice, it is limited.

Most importantly, it seems as though Jackson will be confirmed without much obstruction from Republicans, however any bipartisan cooperation will be limited. Within hours of Jackson’s nomination, Graham tweeted that it was a sign that the ‘radical Left has won President Biden over yet again’. The Senator has spoken highly of Michelle Childs, another figure believed to have been on Biden’s shortlist. Childs also secured the endorsement of House Majority Whip Jim Clyburn, hugely influential in Biden’s turning point South Carolina primary victory in 2020, but ultimately lost out to Jackson.

Jackson’s nomination will do little to change the ideological composition of the court, which will seemingly long outlast the Biden presidency

Biden’s pick should prevail in any confirmation vote, with 50 Democratic Senators presumably convinced in advance of her nomination, however the fragility of that majority has rarely been clearer. It was reported last month that Senator Ben Ray Luján of New Mexico had suffered a stroke, though is expected to make a full recovery and will have some weeks before a final vote is called on Jackson.

This fine margin is the reason for the increasing calls over recent years for Breyer to retire and allow the Democratic president to nominate his successor. Ruth Bader Ginsburg resisted such calls when Democrats last held Congress and the White House under Obama, leading to her replacement by Amy Coney Barrett just days before the 2020 presidential election and the current conservative majority that looks to be safe for a generation.

As it stands, Jackson will become the Supreme Court’s first African-American female Justice, whether along a party line or bipartisan vote. Undoubtedly a historic milestone, it will provide short-term positivity for Biden, giving his base a much-needed tangible result. However, it will do little to change the ideological composition of the Court, which will seemingly long outlast the Biden presidency.

Illustration: Verity Laycock

Support Palatinate