Bi-erasure as Passing Privilege
By Hannah Withey
A single letter, the humble B in LGBTQ, exists to encapsulate a community of people who identify themselves as being attracted to more than one gender. Of course, the nuances within this identity should demonstrate that there exists a vast variety of lived experiences for people in this group. More so than this however, there exists a silently-acknowledged thought within the wider queer community; that people who identify as bisexual all possess a privilege that others don’t: they can pass.
‘Passing privilege’ describes the ability of a member of an oppressed group to pass as a member of the dominant one. This can be applied to numerous identity groups in terms of class, race and sexuality for instance. It can be exemplified by so-called ‘lighter skinned privilege’ in racial terms, but it is often appropriated for use regarding bisexuality.
If, for example, a bisexual man is in a relationship with a woman, they must commit themselves to a state of assumed heterosexuality. Consequently, they may possess a passing privilege, by avoiding the oppression and homophobia that other more overtly queer people cannot. It is argued, that in a heteronormative society, bisexuals can toe the line of assumed (and sometimes compulsory) heterosexuality and, particularly in countries where LGBTQ rights are restricted, remain relatively better off as a result.
Similarly, many bisexuals encounter another option when coming out; to not do so, but still be open about any relationships which appear straight. As a bisexual woman, I initially saw the appeal to this situation, and being able to present half of my sexuality by default is admittedly still a more privileged position than those who are only attracted to the same gender may occupy.
The exhausting duality which bisexuality often involves leaves many feeling that they are neither straight nor queer enough.
But this apparent advantage comes with an implicit denial of the other part of my sexuality, and all that encompasses being able to identify as bisexual. This is not so much a freedom as a constraint, as escaping potential external oppression would require an internal repression of any bisexuals’ true identity. Equating bisexuality to ‘practically straight’ suggests that the complexities of sexuality can be simplified or dismissed in an act of bisexual erasure.
Bisexual erasure (or bi-erasure for short) acts to silence and make invisible those who identify themselves as bisexual. The phenomenon has been described as the removal, falsification or re-explanation of incidences of bisexuality, and can be demonstrated by instances when its suggested that bisexuality is ‘just a phase’, or worse, that it does not exist at all. Passing privilege promotes all of these practices by both denying the persecution of bisexuals and not acknowledging that their experiences of attraction extend beyond the label of straight. This illuminates the exhausting duality which bisexuality often involves, leaving many with a feeling that they are not straight enough and nor are they queer enough.
Even after the Stonewall riots and the gay rights movements starting in the 1960’s, society maintains a reductionist thinking which suggests that people are either gay or straight. Confusion remains about the grey areas of identity which naturally don’t fit into boxes; pansexuality, gender non-conformity, asexuality, the list goes on. Passing privilege works to undermine these experiences and erase their struggle, in a misplaced effort to demonstrate that other members of the LGBTQ community are more oppressed than they are.
To ascribe a passing privilege to hetero-appearing individuals is to recognise an assortment of different experiences within the LGBTQ community, but at the same time denies them inclusion and overlooks their ability to still be oppressed in terms of homophobia. By releasing bisexuals and other hetero-appearing LGBTQ people from guilt over supposed privilege, we may disregard the rhetoric which poses identity in terms of denial, and instead accept it as one of affirmation.
Image: Fotos de Camisetas de SANTI OCHOA via Flickr
