A fashionable hypocrisy

By Hannah Withey

There exists a significant hypocrisy in modern Britain, which is best exemplified by the reaction to the recent investigation into Boohoo, where it was revealed that they were seriously underpaying staff in Leicester. The company was found to be paying wages of as little as £3.50 an hour and forcing employees to continue work in unsafe conditions during the coronavirus lockdown. Boohoo have since been dropped by retailers such as Next and ASOS, with a public outcry over the appalling standards that the garment workers in Leicester have endured.

At the same time, forcing poor working conditions upon its employees is nothing new to the world of fast fashion, and a similar environment has been maintained for staff abroad for years. In countries such as Bangladesh, India and Taiwan, fewer labour protection laws and a lower minimum wage attracts giants like Primark and other cheap fashion brands for these exact reasons.

By examining the price of their clothes alone, it seems blatantly obvious that they will not have been producible without several hundred workers in a factory somewhere, working long hours for far less than the living wage. You only need to look to the collapse of the textile factory in Dhaka, Bangladesh in 2013 which killed over 1,100 people to realise that unsafe and unethical conditions are a continuing problem for the fashion industry.

Unfair treatment, unsafe and unethical working conditions should be condemned in all their forms regardless of their country of origin

The hypocrisy is that while condemning similar practices at home, there has been a substantial effort by consumers to ignore the plight of workers in developing countries. This suggests that morality has its geographical limits and serves to demonstrate that many maintain an ‘it can’t happen here’ mentality about labour abuses. It is almost akin to a colonial-era chauvinism, as though poor working conditions abroad are to be naturally expected and so they are accepted. More so than this, by continuing to pump money into fashion brands such as Boohoo with a poor record of workers’ treatment, we as customers are complicit in the poverty and suffering faced by garment workers globally.

Brands who sourced goods from the factory in Dhaka, such as Primark and H&M, have since attempted to clean up their image, with H&M recently pledging to use 100% recycled or sustainably sourced materials by 2030 (note how this doesn’t also imply their clothes will be ethically produced). The more cynical among us will suggest that this is a marketing ploy to redeem brands in the eyes of consumers. Considering the increasing environmental awareness in Britain and demand for more sustainable options, combined with the profit-driven nature of business and continuing low pay of machinists, these critics could well be right.

We as customers are complicit in the poverty and suffering faced by garment workers globally

This level of hypocrisy can be equally applied to the media we consume, and the varying availability of information on other human rights abuses. Media outlets serve to amplify the incidences of abuse which occur closer to home, and in doing so perpetuate a euro-centric approach to news coverage. Cases such as the continuing crisis in Yemen, human rights abuses in Iran and unlawful internment of Uighur Muslims in China; it only takes a quick look at the BBC news headlines to see that there is a clear information gap that the media is unwilling to fill. Some news outlets do endeavour to cover these and similar stories from developing countries, but it should demonstrate that the blame doesn’t lie solely with Britons who are simply unaware of the questionable origins of their clothes.

This devalues people’s lives in developing countries in Asia, Africa and South America, where there is an implicit assumption that similar stories to Boohoo’s are less worth covering when they are in India. Without an unbiased and thorough dispersal of information concerning other countries, there remains the troubling question of what is happening that we don’t know about?

Unfair treatment, unsafe and unethical working conditions should be condemned in all their forms regardless of their country of origin. Comparing against two different standards of morality is ultimately short-sighted and encourages a blind ignorance which enables parts of the fashion industry to continue in the exploitation of garment workers globally. So of course, boycott Boohoo, but not before considering the rest of your wardrobe too.

Illustration: Morning Brew via Unsplash