Beyond native vs. non-native species: the future of conservation

By Blythe Sharman

In ecology and conservation today, the status of species as either native or non-native has become an important classification, with much focus on the eradication of invasive species.  The term ‘native species’ is widely understood to mean a species that occurs in a given location without human influence. However, this seemingly straightforward definition doesn’t capture the full complexity of what defines a native species. The distribution of plants and animals has been subjected to changes due to both environmental and human influence for tens of millennia; therefore, what baseline do we use to define a native species? Understanding this complexity is crucial for modern conservation, as it directly influences which species are prioritised for protection or removal. 

Today, many of us are aware of the ecological havoc wreaked by invasive species, which are considered one of the greatest threats to global biodiversity loss. An invasive species is defined as a non-native organism that has been introduced into a new environment by human activity and causes harm to this environment. However, it’s important to note that not all non-native species are invasive, as some species introduced through human influence have provided important ecological functions. For example, dingoes were introduced to Australia approximately 5000 years ago by ancient humans and are now considered an important apex predator which keeps the ecosystem in balance. There are also examples of species that are ‘recent natives’, such as the collared dove, a south Asian species that spread naturally to Europe in the 1930s, where they are now abundant. Examples like these highlight that, alone, whether a species is native or not, is not the best measure of whether a species belongs. Instead, conservation must consider both the timescale of a species’ arrival and the ecological roles it plays when deciding how to manage ecosystems.

Traditional conservation methods are being re-thought due to newly established non-native species

Modern ecosystems are dynamic and have changed significantly over time. Ecologists are noticing an increase in ‘novel ecosystems’, which ecologist Jens-Christian Svenning explains to be “autonomous, wild ecosystems that deviate from natural baselines because of human activities”.  These ecosystems are complex and functional, containing combinations of native and non-native species. For example, the forests of O‘ahu, Hawaii, have been vastly changed by human activity over time, leading to the introduction of several non-native flora and fauna. These non-native and native species interact with each other and have created an ecosystem that has never been seen before. In this case, non-native birds have adapted and contribute important ecosystem functions such as seed dispersal of both of native and non-native plants. 

Ecosystems like the forests of O‘ahu have sparked debate regarding how they should be managed. The functionality of such ecosystems depends upon the complex interactions of native and non-native species, and deciding which aspects of said ecosystems should be conserved is a problem that’s hard to address with traditional conservation methods. Traditionally, conservation has focused on the recovery of damaged landscapes back to a reference point in earth’s history, usually to restore ecosystems to a time of pre-disturbance from humans. However, today, many native species are extinct, while non-native species have spread widely and become firmly established. This therefore makes classical restoration of such ecosystems very difficult, and has led ecologists to question traditional conservation strategies, such as eradicating non-native species. Ecologist Corey Tarwater captures this dilemma: “It’s complex and depends on the goals of restoration. A conservationist focusing on native plants may eradicate as many non-native competitors as possible. But if you’re interested in conserving a native snail or some of these other species, that [non-native plant] might be the habitat that they currently rely upon.” These cases suggest that in some scenarios, conservation cannot fully replicate the past, and therefore deciding how to manage present ecosystems may prove difficult.

Many conservationists argue strongly for native species focused restoration where possible, due to the ecological and historical value of native species. With aims to return ecosystems to a pre-disturbance state, native biodiversity and historical baselines will be maintained. The challenges posed by climate change mean that it is not always clear whether this approach is effective alone. More research is needed to understand how different conservation strategies affect ecosystems in practice, and how we can best protect biodiversity under rapidly changing conditions.

Overall, traditional approaches to conservation are being increasingly challenged, and focusing on protecting native species in today’s shifting ecosystems has sparked ongoing debate about the best strategies for the future. The planet’s species are being forced to adapt to our changing climate, which in some cases creates interactions that have not occurred in the past. Conservationists are now being faced with new complexities, which make protecting the planet’s biodiversity very difficult. To develop the most effective strategies to best protect biodiversity, further research will be essential to determine which conservation strategies are most effective in maintaining resilient, functioning ecosystems in the face of ongoing global change.

Image: Giles Laurent via Wikimedia Commons