Behind the glass: the ethics and reality of orca captivity
By Blythe Sharman
The Orca (Orcinus orca) is one of our planet’s most powerful and intelligent species. These apex predators hunt alongside their powerful pod, taking down anything from fish to large marine mammals, earning them the ominous title of the killer whale.
These charismatic cetaceans have captivated the public with their striking appearance, cunning hunting styles, familial bonds and intelligence. This fascination first sprouted in the 1970s, when orcas first began to be captured from the wild and displayed in captivity. While orca captivity can help inform the public about their biology and conservation status, it also raises an important question: are orcas truly suited for life in captivity?
Today, a handful of orcas today are kept in substandard tanks, where these cetaceans may spend their whole listless lives. A wild orca can swim up to 40 miles a day and dive 100 to 500 feet, several times a day, activities that are simply not possible in concrete tanks.
Many orcas in captivity are affected by the condition known as ‘zoochosis’, which refers to repetitive patterns of activity that have no obvious function. In orcas, this includes lethargic floating, gnawing on tank walls, and swaying. Zoochosis in orcas has even been seen to manifest into fatal self-harming behaviours. For example, according to World Animal Protection US, in 1980, an orca named Hugo died after having suffered a brain aneurysm, which was likely due to his repeated head bashing against the sides of his tank. He died at just age 15, an incredibly premature death compared to his wild counterparts, who are known to live up to 40 years old. Such cases highlight the profound mental toll that captivity can have on these highly intelligent and social animals.
Orcas have complex social and language systems distinct from the orcas’ pod. Different pods interact with different prey and climates, which shape their dialects and vocalisations. Analysis of orca vocalisations has shown substantial differences between the dialects of different pods; for example, studies of Icelandic and Norwegian killer whale populations revealed that the two populations did not share any of the same calls. Therefore, when captive orcas are deposited into artificially created pods, this can create problems when orcas with incompatible dialects are forced together. This can lead to aggression between orcas, which is only exacerbated by the lack of space the orcas in captivity have to swim. There have been several instances of orcas killing other orcas that they are housed with. These fatal encounters show the marine entertainment industries’ poor planning and lack of understanding of orca social dynamics.
The captivity of orcas is not only detrimental to their well-being but also to human safety. There have been 4 recorded deaths caused by captive orcas. Three were caused by Tilikum, an orca who spent most of his life at Seaworld. It’s virtually unheard of to find orcas attacking humans in the wild. Therefore, it’s clear that these creatures, without any outlet for their frustration, made to perform in shows to earn food, can turn to violence and aggression, which can be fatal.

Left Image: James Hills via Wikimedia Commons
Right Image: Robert Pittman via Wikimedia Commons
What’s the solution?
If orcas are not suited to captivity, the question remains: what should be done with those who still live in captive environments?
One solution is the release of these orcas into the wild. However, this has sparked debates and remains controversial, as many argue that captive orcas do not have the survival skills needed to live a fulfilled life in the wild. Previous release efforts have seen limited success. Many consider the release of Keiko — a killer whale released from captivity in 2002 — a happy story because he spent his final years swimming freely. However, reports indicate that Keiko never successfully hunted wild fish and frequently approached boats in search of human interaction. He died shortly after his release, likely due to hunger and pneumonia. As well this, the release of orcas into the wild can cost millions of dollars and requires extensive planning, health screening, and post-release support.
Orcas are not here for our entertainment, they belong in the wild, free to roam the oceans where they truly thrive
Another option is the construction of sea pens and enclosed coastal sanctuaries so orcas can live the rest of their life in the ocean but under the monitoring and care of humans. Although this approach offers a valuable balance between freedom and safety, the costs of building, maintaining, and staffing such facilities are extremely high.
Some marine entertainment companies, such as Seaworld, have ended their orca breeding programs, mainly due to public pressure. Therefore, it could be argued that no form of release for currently captive orcas is needed, as the era of orca performances is expected to phase out within a few decades, with no new generations being bred to take their place.
Overall, the future for captive orcas offers a glimmer of hope as public attitudes have shifted significantly over the past few decades. Growing pressure on marine parks, corporations, and governments has sparked efforts to end orca captivity and develop coastal sanctuaries. It is crucial that we remain aware of the needs of these remarkable creatures and reflect on our responsibility toward all life on this planet. Orcas are not here for our entertainment, they belong in the wild, free to roam the oceans where they truly thrive.
Image: Milan Boers via Wikimedia Commons

