Beyond ‘flying rats’: the case for humane pigeon control

By Jasmine Davey

Anyone who has visited a big city will be familiar with the small grey creatures that seem to infest the streets, waddling from one potential food source to the next. Their constant and extensive presence has afforded them a poor reputation, often being dubbed as ‘vermin’ or ‘rats with wings’. However, this reputation is largely unfounded, and based more on cultural prejudices than science. 

The ‘pigeon issue’ is most prevalent in London, where both Westminster and the Mayor have taken action against the pigeon population. In 2003, former Mayor Ken Livingstone made it illegal to feed pigeons in Trafalgar Square, despite the location’s fame and attraction for the activity. This ban was only semi-effective as it could not be enforced in the North Terrace of the Square, which falls under Westminster jurisdiction. To close this loophole, Westminster enacted a complete ban in 2012. Today, if you are caught feeding a pigeon in Trafalgar Square (or any of the surrounding areas), you can be fined up to £500 or face prosecution. 

The primary justification for such restrictions is the ‘unpleasant environment’ that pigeons create. Not only do they like to harass you for food and get in your way, but their faeces are acidic and can cause significant structural damage to buildings and statues. For instance, Nelson’s Column in Trafalgar Square had to undergo £140,000 worth of repairs due to damage caused by pigeon excrement, despite architects trying their best to ward off the pigeons in a modern-day Battle of Trafalgar. This is obviously not ideal – it seems fair to say that Nelson was bombarded with enough pellets (faecal or not) during his lifetime. 

The diseases that can be contracted from feral city pigeons, such as E.coli and Candidiasis (caused by Candida), do not help their reputation. Although it is very rare to catch a disease from a pigeon, their droppings do pose a slight risk to immunocompromised people who come into contact with the substance. Most famously, in 2016 a child being treated at Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow died after contracting an infection called cryptococcus, which he/she obtained when their hospital room became contaminated with pigeon droppings. However, such an occurrence is incredibly rare, with it being almost impossible for a healthy individual to catch a disease from a pigeon on the street. 

However, it is no surprise that pigeons have gained themselves a rather poor reputation. But does this really serve as justification for the cruel methods of pest control which have been employed against them? Post mortems conducted on Trafalgar Square pigeons after the 2012 ban found that up to 2,000 birds died from starvation, with little to no food being present in their stomachs. ‘Pigeon culling’ has also become a popular method of control, despite its relative ineffectiveness: the reduction of pigeon populations only encourages further breeding. 

Despite these cruel methods of pest control, it appears that efforts are being made to regulate pigeon populations with more humane methods. York University is currently trialling ‘pigeon birth control’, where pigeons are fed a ‘breakfast’ each morning containing contraception. This method has already proven to be effective in other countries, such as Portugal. Suggestions are also being made to remove pigeon eggs from building nests, which would not have a negative emotional impact on the pigeons concerned. There is also support for a gradual method of food withdrawal, which would prevent pigeons from reproducing (one pigeon pair can do so up to 12 times a year) rather than simply starving them to death. Most creatively, the British Library has recently partnered with the London Falconry to employ a falcon named Weatherby, whose job it is to fly around and scare pigeons away from the building. Although the latter is not a permanent or fully effective solution, the progression towards cruelty-free pigeon control is a welcome change. 

There is no scientific evidence supporting inhumane methods of pigeon control, such as culling or cold-turkey feeding bans. If anything, there is evidence to suggest the contrary: more gradual, humane methods of pigeon control are more effective in the long-term as they discourage further pigeon reproduction. Not only are certain pigeon regulations cruel and uncalled for, but they are ineffective and counter-productive. This is why local councils should look to science, rather than embellished rumours spread by pest control companies, to solve the ‘pigeon problem’. After all, these once domestic war heroes deserve a little bit more love and compassion.

Image: oatsey40 via Flickr