Backstage with Dear Evan Hansen: Can the set industry survive screens?

By Anna Pile

As many did during the exam season, a few weeks ago I found myself taking a very productive doom-scroll through TikTok as a respite from revising. Scrolling through, I found a video about each production currently on Broadway — the perfect distraction. That was, until I saw a comment: ‘the death of sets on Broadway in favor of screens is hell’. It made me pause to think. With over 5,000 likes, this certainly touched a chord in the online theatre space — but is Broadway trading sets for screens, and, if they are, is that a sign of modern theatre’s downfall?

Is Broadway trading sets for screens, and, if they are, is that a sign of modern theatre’s downfall?

New, fancy technology is certainly taking up space on Broadway — physically and in the language of how productions tell their stories. Beaches, for example, is an original show that hit the famous street of New York this April. According to The Guardian‘s review, the only physical pieces of the set are two lonely piles of sand on each corner of the stage — the rest of the titular ‘beaches’ were digital projections. There is certainly an argument that projections could create a certain technological tone; useful if it matches the feeling the setting should elicit, but awful if you are trying to capture the essence of nature — for example, a beach.

However, there was a time during this never-ending rise of new technology that was not purely focused on the spectacle: just a decade or so ago, a show opened on Broadway that integrated this new technological era in a way that heightened both the meanings and emotions embedded in the narrative. Dear Evan Hansen began its six-year run in New York in 2016, instantly becoming a sensation and winning Best New Musical at that year’s Tony awards. Following a high schooler suffering from social anxiety, the musical captures the struggles of mental health in the modern age, while also highlighting the power and pitfalls of social media.

For those unaware, Durham’s own Tone Deaf Theatre Company is putting on their own interpretation of the hit musical in the Assembly Rooms Theatre this week. Knowing the extensive and unique tech used in most productions, I reached out to one of the production manager, Alex McCalmont, to ask her about how they were going to approach it.

‘One really important aspect of the show for us was to integrate as much multimedia as possible because the show is very much set in an online space and [about] how made up worlds can start to become a reality’, McCalmont explained. In the original production, screens and projectors were utilized mainly to display specific moments of the online space to the audience (emails, Instagram, etc.), with flat screens hanging from the ceiling in a maze of sorts as Evan tries to navigate his way through his own mind. Instead, TDTC has made the projections arguably even more prominent, using them not only to create the set, but to blur the line between reality and fantasy — bringing the audience into Evan’s mind and his struggles.

It’s not simply for the spectacle, nor an easy replacement for a physical set — it’s to go even deeper thematically.

I later interviewed directors Lauren Williams and Estelle Pollard-Cox, and Williams explained this decision, mentioning how one of the major themes they focused on was ‘disconnect versus connection, and how a lot of these characters start the show very disconnected from one another’ and that’s ‘something that projections really help externalize — we wanted to take the window, the online space, the screen, and [put] it right by the forefront’. Unlike Beaches, TDTC is exploring new and exciting technology by building off the original foundations. It’s not simply for the spectacle, nor an easy replacement for a physical set — it’s to go oven deeper thematically.

In fact, there is still a large amount of physical set in the production — it has just been transformed to work alongside the projections. ‘I think we currently have eight projectors [to be] used across the entire space’ McCalmont told me, and ‘the set is all white so that projection screens can be absolutely anywhere’, including projecting the recordings of videos taken by a film and editing crew.

Technology of this scale, especially this much novel equipment, undoubtedly comes with its difficulties: ‘it’s been quite a challenge’ McCalmont said, ‘especially in a university environment trying to source [projectors] from a lot of different suppliers, all with different terms and pricing — it’s been an interesting challenge, but one I’ve definitely really enjoyed’. The amount of time, effort, and communication between the production and creative team has also been an interesting challenge to tackle, as McCalmont explains: ‘the set hinges on how the projections are going to look on it, and then the lights hinge on how much light is emanating from the projections, and then the sound has to match with the videos that are being presented. It brings all the departments together in a way that’s not usually seen within DST’ (Durham Student Theatre).

‘there’s this stage direction that says Heidi stands there, for a moment, lost at sea. And we decided [there’s] no need for projection’

There are also moments the spectacle is taken away to enhance rather than distract, with Pollard-Cox explaining ‘there’s this stage direction that says Heidi stands there, for a moment, lost at sea. And we decided [there’s] no need for projection — when it comes to Evan and his mental health, I think a lot of it is externalized, and it needs to be for the show. But when it comes to other characters — they are struggling to be externalized.’ There is not only power in this new technology, but also in its absence. It is a shame that this sentiment seems lost on many of the successful contemporary theatrical productions today.

With that said, hope is not lost if the creatives and technicians of DST are our future. In our interview, I explained to McCalmont how I thought DST was the best stepping stone into the theatrical world, and a great opportunity people should take. She agreed, adding ‘it’s never too early or too late in your university career to get started — and DST, particularly technical, has such a lovely, welcoming environment, and care for each other. We want to be able to support each other and those in more senior positions are very willing to teach and offer shadowing opportunities’. When I asked her advice for people wanting to get their foot in the technical side of DST she said ‘just give it a go — it’s challenging, but really rewarding’.

‘it’s never too early or too late in your university career to get started — and DST, particularly technical, has such a lovely, welcoming environment

In other words, the ‘death of sets’ is not what is making theatre-lovers upset when complaining about projections or screens on stage — it’s the loss of intent and creativity. As Dear Evan Hansen has proved, screens and projections can be a welcome addition when tied to the overlying commentary of the show — and TDTC has pushed this idea even further. They have shown that by treating projections as any other technological craft, with care, control, and intention, it can be just as impactful as methods of storytelling in the past. The future is not doomed, but will instead be reliant on the incoming creatives and technicians of theatre to work together, become inventive teams striving to create the best in their field, and understanding when a bare stage can hold more weight than any projection can fill.

Image Credit: Ajay Suresh via Wikimedia Commons