Are unpaid internships exploitation?

image by Tax Credits (Flickr)

By Rory Tingle

A Labour MP has called on the government to “prohibit the advertising of long-term unpaid internships” and to regulate conditions of employment for paid placements.

Hazel Blears wants to close the loophole that allows companies to advertise unpaid internships, which are illegal under English law. The MP for Salford and Eccles thinks unpaid internships disadvantage young people from poorer backgrounds, because only those with “money behind them” can afford to work for free.

Young people should not have to endure the crippling financial cost of working for long periods without pay. However I would urge campaigners to push for further reform, as by simply clamping down on unpaid internships we ignore a wider issue that can only be addressed by other changes in legislation.

At a time when £1 million young people are out of work and struggling financially, it is vital for the government to build a sustainable model for internship programmes in Britain. This requires MPs and business leaders alike to ensure that young people get a fair deal, whilst also acknowledging the need to keep the wage bill down.

Currently apprentices in the UK are guaranteed a minimum ‘training’ wage of £2.65, a right that I argue should be extended to interns. Many companies would pay their interns more, and all would earn enough to support themselves temporarily. Vitally though, this would not cause a high financial burden on businesses.

This action, supported by the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD), represents the best way to balance the needs of interns with that of businesses. The implementation of a formal training wage for those on work placements would also boost productivity by increasing motivation among interns.

I would also argue in favour of a formal distinction between internships and work experience, similar to that in France. In this case work experience is limited to eight weeks, after which there is a trigger and a person automatically becomes an intern and is paid accordingly.

Refusing to pay interns is illegal. It is vital that we note that. The long-term practical solution to prevent the exploitation of interns would be the implementation of the minimum ‘training’ wage and the introduction of a trigger system for work experience, but perhaps after a shorter period than in France.

This will prevent the exploitation of youthful ambition without reducing the number of internships available on the market.