Are schools to blame for Britain’s Covid-19 numbers?

By Eli Rasmussen

It’s a classic whodunnit. The crime? 30,000+ Covid-19 cases a week.

Covid-19 numbers remain steadily high across the United Kingdom despite strong vaccination rates. As many implicate schools for acting as breeding grounds for disease, it is worth examining the truth of these assessments, the health policies already in place and the consequences that would follow if schools were to do more.

While the country led the charge for the world vaccination rollout in 2020, a different story entirely will be told of 2021; as the most in need of protection across Europe and the world have largely been accounted for, other nations have smoothly progressed onto vaccinations of children (those at little risk) while the UK has dragged its feet. While only a month or two behind many of its European counterparts, the recommendation for 12- to 15-year-olds to receive the Pfizer vaccine was announced in mid-September, missing a pivotal deadline at which hundreds of thousands of children would return to in-person teaching. In France, meanwhile, 66% of children aged 12 and up had received one dose of the vaccine and 52% had received both by mid-September. Denmark and Spain share similar stories.

Britain’s comparably high Covid-19 cases are not because of low immunisation rates alone, however. In fact, in terms of general population, they remain ahead of other major European countries such as Germany, Switzerland, Austria and Poland. In schools, despite a slow start, they are making quick progress on account of health teams visiting and administering jabs.

Ventilation has become a primary obstacle in disease prevention

It is with regard to other regulations such as face coverings and health passes where discrepancies in consistency across these countries can really be spotted. Since the UK’s memorable ‘Freedom Day’, masks have not been compulsory in English and Welsh schools and all business has reopened without checks for Covid-19 immunity. The effects of these mandates (or lack thereof) are evident in student absence. In the month of October, students isolating at home due to Covid-19-related reasons lingered at about 2.5% (204,000 students), according to Department of Education data. It is reasonable to wonder, then: should more be done to limit disruption?

As we reach the cold of winter and move primarily into indoor socialising, ventilation has become a primary obstacle in disease prevention and one that the Government would like to get ahead of. In England, Scotland and Wales, hundreds of thousands of carbon dioxide monitors have been distributed to schools to uncover areas of CO2 build-up and potentially increased infection. Vaccinations are not mandatory in schools but are highly advised and if against the will of a child’s parents, can be overridden by the child if deemed knowledgeable about what they are doing. In some US and Canadian school districts, vaccinations (barring any medical exemptions) have been announced as obligatory to attend classes. Unappealing to some, this sort of drastic action might be exactly what is necessary to prevent the same lower standard of ‘online-offline’ education dealt with the past two years, particularly of frustration to exam-taking students.

Schools must not become complacent

Then again, it could be the case that schools are offered an unfair portion of the blame in unchanging pandemic numbers. The UK’s early jump in the vaccination effort may in fact be costing the country now and a possible indication of what is to come for others, the worry long set in for scientists of the waning effectiveness of inoculations and the possible need for boosters. A study from Public Health England found, regarding the Delta variant of Covid-19, a drop of 20 percentage points “in vaccine effectiveness against hospitalisation and death more than 20 weeks post-vaccination” in comparison to two weeks post- vaccination.

Regardless, schools must not become complacent. While cases have dropped a little in recent days, many, the Labour Party in the spotlight, have demanded a “Covid Plan B” for the winter, including mandatory vaccine passports and face coverings in public places. Of course, if this plan is waiting for the rekindling of a pandemic while a fire still burns brightly, it might be wise to stray on the side of caution and act now.

Image: Spencerbdavis via Wikimedia Commons

Support Palatinate