Analysis: Where does your college rent go?
By Elizabeth McBride
Concerns about rising accommodation prices have been present at Durham University for years.
For example, in 2017 Durham Students’ Union launched their Ripped-Off campaign after the rent for a standard catered room rose to £7,422. At the time the DSU President said, “These above-inflation increases to college accommodation fees have made the make the cost of living in college too high for returning students, meaning less do so, resulting in the loss of the college as a true student community.
“The University has been unable to identify why accommodation rates are set so high or where the money from accommodation fees is distributed within the University budget”.
The Pro-Vice-Chancellor pushed back on these assertions in 2017, claiming: “The cost of providing our college residences rises year on year and we have to review prices on an annual basis to ensure we can continue to provide a high standard of accommodation and services. When reviewing our college residence charges, we consult extensively, including with student representatives.”
Last year, students protested a 10.3% rise in accommodation fees, which was the third highest increase in the Russell Group, according to The Telegraph. In response to the frustration last year, Durham University said: “As you will be aware, the University is experiencing rises in our operating costs in the current economic climate.
“We have tried to keep increases to our accommodation and catering charges as low as possible and to make sure that college-managed accommodation remains competitively priced in relation to private accommodation in Durham City.
“The University has an agreement with the Students’ Union that accommodation and catering charges will increase by no more than inflation (RPI) each year. This year, mindful of the exceptionally high rates of inflation, we have worked hard to keep the increases in accommodation and catering charges to 3.1% below the latest RPI figure. The increases to our accommodation and catering charges will not cover the rises in our operating costs.”
In 2015/16 accommodation costs rose by 8.4% despite the ONS’ calculation of inflation only being 1.5%
Durham uses RPI as their inflation measure. However according to the ONS’s website, “The Retail Prices Index (RPI) and its derivatives have been assessed against the Code of Practice for Official Statistics and found not to meet the required standard for designation as National Statistics; the RPI, its subcomponents and the RPIX continue to be published as they are tied to long-term contracts.”
Analysis carried out by Palatinate last year found that rent prices have risen above the rate of inflation (as calculated by the Office for National Statistics’s Consumer Prices Index including housing costs) every time Durham has hiked the rent in the last decade. The worst disparity was in 2015/2016 where accommodation rose by 8.4% despite the ONS’ calculation of inflation only being 1.5%.
In 2015, Durham University sent out an email breaking down college accommodation costs for 2015-16, after increasing costs by 8 per cent.
The email, from 28 November 2015, said that living in college “represents value for money,” but also showed that one third of rent payments went on capital and borrowing expenditure. The email stated that around 23% of income went on operations and administration staff, 13% on utilities, 18% on repair and maintenance, 22% on capital, 11% on borrowing, and 7% on capital and borrowing expenditure. Such breakdowns have not been sent to students since.
While in 2015 Durham said that the 8% increase in rent was necessary due to the rising cost of gas, electricity and food, an FOI seen by Palatinate shows that expenditure on utilities actually dropped by 13.7% that year – from £2,900,000 in the 2014/2015 academic year to £2,500,000 in 2015/2016 – and catering costs only rose by 2.5% from £7,900,000 to £8,100,000. Overall costs only rose by 2.8%.
The University went on to increase their rent prices by 3.5% for the next academic year. But in 2016/2017, the costs of running accommodation were actually lower than in 2014/2015: despite students experiencing a 12% increase in rent over that period.
Capital expenditure had, however, more than doubled; with the University spending £4,900,000 in 2016/2017, compared to £2,000,000 in 2014/2015.
Palatinate asked Durham to comment on what their own financial reports indicate to be a large surplus generated by their student accommodation in recent years.
“As a University we are proud of our Collegiate structure, and it is a top priority for us to ensure its financial stability into the long-term future.”
durham university
While operating costs have increased over the past 6 years, Durham’s expenditure on staff has actually decreased by 8.6%. The University said, “The University’s new colleges – John Snow and South – are operated by a third party on the University’s behalf, and as such will not have increased the College Operations staffing costs.”
While Durham University admitted that they do have an operating surplus from their residences, they say it is much smaller than indicated by their own financial reports.
“As a University we are proud of our Collegiate structure, and it is a top priority for us to ensure its financial stability into the long-term future. As a charitable trust, the University does not make a ‘profit’ but rather an operating surplus, which can only be reinvested into its activities and estate.
“For our Annual Report, we are obliged by HESA national accounting rules to report our finances according to a set of categories which do not map straightforwardly onto our internal structures.
“For example, the indirect costs associated with college, such as utilities, maintenance and grounds maintenance, are not captured within the category you refer to. In addition, the costs
associated with our ongoing residential refurbishment programme and capital expenditure are likewise recorded separately.
“While the University does internally measure its financial contribution derived from college accommodation, catering and conferencing operations, this figure is not contained within nor
able to be derived from the Annual Report and is sensitive to numerous assumptions related to the allocation of institutional overheads.
“The effective operating surplus is therefore significantly reduced by the inclusion of these overhead and capital costs reflecting utilities usage and investment in the estate.”
“It should be noted that this operating surplus is also required to contribute to a proportion of other central costs within the university, such as IT services (to provide wifi and other IT services), HR services (to manage the 650 staff), and so on.”
Durham did not provide Palatinate with the figures for this contribution “to avoid confusion” but claims that this contribution “effectively removes most of the remaining surplus”.
Durham’s accommodation prices continue to be well above other universities, with their rent increase this year being the third largest in the Russell Group, according to the Telegraph. Durham also has fewer price brackets than other Universities, with students being limited by their college to what accommodation they can choose.
Only 7 of Durham’s 17 colleges offer self-catered accommodation. Self-catered college accommodation with a shared bathroom costs £164 per week for this year: some self-catered colleges are only ensuite leaving students with £179 per week for a non-catered room as their only accommodation option.
If students in catered accommodation want to live in university-owned accommodation they must pay £234.77 a week.
Recently the University has increased the value of the Durham Grant Scheme by over 13% in light of the cost of living crisis. Durham was one of only two Russell Group Universities to significantly increase bursaries in the last three years.
Image: Mark Norton

