Against: Is the gender pay gap in football justified?
By Gabriel Radus
When the dust settles on this year’s Women’s Football World Cup, it will be undeniably seen as a huge success, not only for women’s football, but for women’s sport in general. In spite of a spate of Video Assistant Referee (VAR) inconsistencies that angered and frustrated some on the pitch, FIFA and football fans will be encouraged by the ballooning in global viewing figures, in part due to the professionalism with which the finals have been treated by the French footballing governing body. Nine all-grass, four-stand stadiums, including those of Paris Saint-Germain and Olympique Lyonnais, the two most successful men’s teams in modern French footballing history, for one, is a marked improvement on the much-maligned five artificially-turfed stadia used in the 2015 World Cup in Canada.
Around the grounds, attendances have remained at the high-level set four years ago (57,900 were at the Parc, Olympique Lyonnais to see the USA retain the trophy with a comprehensive 2-0 victory against The Netherlands), and TV figures continually broke records for women’s association football. The quarter-final between USA and France saw 8.24million people tune into Fox Sports, the US network provider for the World Cup. Up 7% from the 2015 quarter-final, the match was the most-watched football match in the USA since the men’s World Cup final last year. England’s Lionesses broke three viewing records during the finals in as many weeks. Even in Italy, a country known for its widely dismissive and archaic attitude towards women’s football, saw a 3,500% increase in their national viewing record when Le Azzurre played their first-round match against Brazil.
It is TV wherein lies a solution to broaching the gender pay gap in football. As of the 2017/18 season, the combined pay of all 1,693 professional female footballers in the top seven global leagues (France, Germany, England, USA, Sweden, Australia and Mexico) only nearly matches that of Neymar Jr’s salary at PSG. It is no better in international football – the 2018 Ballon d’Or winner Ada Hegerberg still refuses to represent Norway after the Norwegian Football Federation failed to adequately remunerate their female players comparative to the men’s team. The wage disparity is perpetuated by the differing economies that exist in the male and female games. Whilst the record transfer fee dealt by an English club is the €142million transfer of Phillipe Coutinho from Liverpool to Barcelona last summer, the women’s British transfer record last is the ÂŁ50,000 Chelsea paid Reading for Fran Kirby in 2015. Most other deals are free transfers or undisclosed.
In the Women’s World Cup too, despite FIFA announcing that they will raise the prize money for the winners in 2023 to $60million from the $30million received last week by the USA, this sum is still dwarfed by the $400million prize that awaited France after their victory against Croatia last year. This enormous gap, though understandable in a way because of the more established commercialised aspect of the men’s game, is no longer acceptable in the modern era. With the Women’s Super League soon to be incorporated into the Premier League governing body as of next season, there will be many changes in the value and status of women’s football. Certainly this change will result in women’s domestic matches being played in Premier League stadia as of next season only further promoting English stars of the World Cup like Steph Houghton and Lucy Bronze, already idolised by budding female fans as much as Harry Kane and Raheem Sterling are by their male counterparts, to a new level of importance. Certainly, the influence of new sponsorship relations within the Premier League should institute greater commercial investment opportunities emblematic of the fact that increasingly we cannot mitigate for the sheer size of the wealth disparity that exists.
But we must face the facts. Men’s football has gone past the monetary point of no return. Since Nottingham Forest bought Trevor Francis, the first million pound player in British football in 1979, the game has reached incredibly lucrative economic levels, with the men’s game currently contributing 3.36bn to our annual national GDP. It is simply impossible to suggest that the women’s game can reach these astronomical levels in the very near future. But with support augmenting at speeds not seen in the men’s format, and the ability now for the BBC and ITV to push for more women’s games to be readily available on free-to-air television, it’s high time that governing bodies start to facilitate bridging the gap.
The WSL needs to move away from the TV deals of BT Sport and formerly ESPN, which, though good sources of income, will incur a plateau in the encouraging viewing figures seen in last month’s World Cup. Showing live games on cable TV will allow for those whose interest has been peaked by the tournament to pursue their interest more readily. The men’s game has to do more too. There has been talk of having men’s-women’s doubleheaders in stadia next season. Talking the talk is good, but the FA now needs to walk the walk too. Play women’s games before the men’s. Spectators come into the stadiums up to 2 hours before a game in any case. Push for rules and regulations that ensure that the men’s teams must apportion some of their revenue to their women’s team. Pumping more money into the women’s game will encourage more people to lend an interest in it.
Realistically, it would take the boom of the men’s game to bust before true parity with the women’s game can be restored to its pre-professional age. However, there needs to be more of a concerted effort to narrow the ever-widening gap.  Certainly just because this gender pay gap already exists does not make it justified. In an era where pay should be equal, irrespective of gender, it is only sport that still lags in the 20th century. Whilst the public can encourage steps to be taken to eradicate this, the onus lies on the footballing governing bodies and clubs who hold the economic power to balance the scales. Women’s football is as impressive, its’ style and skill as unique as men’s football and therefore it is justified that the gender pay gap should be closed.
Actions of other sporting governing bodies such as the All England Lawn Tennis Club’s decision for equal prize money for men and women in 2007, a decision aided by the decisions of the other Grand Slams and governing bodies to ensure pay parity at the sports biggest events, the US Open was the first to offer equal prize money in 1973.  Football and its governing bodies know it could, and should do more to decrease this pay gap and whilst it is a long road towards economic equality, it is one we should have already begun to tread.
Photograph by Liondartois via Wikimedia Commons
