A woman’s reality a year after Kabul’s fall to the Taliban

By Ellie Boyden

Last week, the Taliban banned women from entering parks and funfairs within the Afghan capital, Kabul, in the latest of a series of developments encroaching upon women’s autonomy and rights. 

A Taliban spokesman claimed that they had made efforts to allow women’s continued access to parks, but that in too many cases the ‘hijab was not being observed’. However, many people have protested that the rules were being respected. This demonstrates yet another of the Taliban’s attempts to justify oppressive measures, by scapegoating their population for not following their interpretation of shari’a law. 

Arguably these excuses are performative to present the Taliban government as more ‘moderate’ than their prior regime, which persisted from 1995 until 2001, presumably to try and gain international recognition. However, the Taliban’s current policies are increasingly converging with their previous extreme gender-based discrimination. 

Retracting Afghan women’s educational rights is one facet of comprehensive discriminatory policies that aim to exclude them from participating in society

For example, the Taliban claim that girls’ secondary education is only temporarily suspended whilst they establish the correct ‘Islamic environment’ within schools. However, there has been no discussion of it being reinstated over a year later, making Afghanistan the only country where girls cannot attend secondary school. Women ostensibly still have access to higher education, but this is vastly compromised if they cannot graduate from school. The Taliban have also recently restricted women’s ability to study certain degrees, citing a low intake of candidates, although this is almost certainly a product of female oppression and gender segregation. 

Retracting Afghan women’s educational rights is one facet of comprehensive discriminatory policies that aim to exclude them from participating in society. Their formal political power has been effectively eliminated, and no women are present in the government cabinet. Furthermore, the Ministry of Women’s Affairs was replaced by the Ministry of Propagation of Virtue and Prevention of Vice, not only discarding women’s representation, but institutionalising a body responsible for enforcing oppressive legislation, through brutal and often violent means.

In conjunction with this, established legal mechanisms defending women’s basic rights have collapsed with the abolition of human rights commissions and NGOs. The restructured judicial system frequently rejects cases such as divorce and domestic abuse that disproportionately affect women, further undermining their security.

This was not always the case; the past two decades in Afghanistan have seen much progress in women’s rights, with many pursuing education and careers. UN Women collated accounts from Afghan women who have lived through this initial year of Taliban rule, many describing the pain they felt watching their rights and opportunities disappear almost overnight. One woman states that ‘something died inside me on 15 August 2021, or at least that is how I felt: my hopes crushed, my education irrelevant, my investment in Afghanistan gone.’

Ironically, by reducing women’s social and economic capabilities, the Taliban compromises their own power

The contributions to society that women were once free to make are curbed by severe restrictions on employment opportunities, travel, leaving the home and bodily autonomy. Ironically, by reducing women’s social and economic capabilities, the Taliban compromises their own power through losing a large amount of the skilled workforce, further damaging Afghanistan’s already weak economy.

However, economic crisis also facilitates greater oppression of women, as hardship and mass unemployment has seen increased violence within the home, as well as a prevalence of early and forced marriages. The Group of Friends of Women in Afghanistan estimates that by 2024, Afghanistan will have suffered a $1.5 billion loss in economic output, exacerbating political instability. In these conditions, gender-based violence and discrimination against women are likely to worsen.

So, what is the most effective way for the international community to assist Afghan women in this context?

Many experts argue improving the education system is essential to salvage Afghanistan’s stability, especially considering its disproportionately young population. The education of girls is arguably the only way that women can hope for sustained societal participation in the future. A current concern is also that an unbalanced curriculum may help entrench the Taliban’s extreme patriarchal norms within the younger male generation, making it harder for women to gain a foothold to fight for equality. 

The international community must think of creative and flexible ways to support the needs of Afghanistan’s population

Most of the international community have imposed sanctions on the Taliban and refused their government official recognition, and many have cited their treatment of women and girls as a key reason for this. This may prove to be valuable leverage in forcing the Taliban to mitigate their discriminatory policies against women, in areas like education, and establish a more rounded curriculum. However, I believe that it is also essential to quickly implement protective measures for Afghan women in the current humanitarian crisis. 

For example, targeted funding of programmes could safely assist activists fighting against the system inside Afghanistan, as well as supporting those who have left but want to help their country from the outside. Sima Bahous, the UN Women Executive Director, has also highlighted the importance of establishing safe houses to protect victims of gender-based violence. Others have pointed to the online courses created by universities as a form of continuing effective education. Undeniably, the international community must think of creative and flexible ways to support the needs of Afghanistan’s population, whilst they hold out for their sanction to drive top-down changes for gender equality.

Image: Arif ID via Pexels