A very Westminster side-hustle: the secret earnings of our MPs

By Caleb Tutt

When I saw Theresa Villiers’ name on Palatinate’s content call, I knew I had seen it somewhere before. Villiers had briefly gone out with my brother’s godfather during her time at Bristol University, so she has that strange quasi-fame within my family that other minor public figures have in other families for all sorts of random reasons. Unfortunately, amongst the wider public, her name now carries with it an unwanted association with misconduct. 

Villiers was recently found to have had over £70,000 worth of shares in the energy giant Shell whilst acting as Environment Secretary under Boris Johnson. These shares, which must be declared if over £70,000, weren’t declared for over five years. Whilst Villiers, through her spokesman, has put this down to an accidental oversight and has since apologised, this revelation raises questions about whether MPs are as diligent in sticking to parliamentary standards as they ought to be, and whether this subversion of ethics is now the done thing in the corridors of power.

This revelation raises questions about whether MPs are as diligent in sticking to parliamentary standards as they ought to be, and whether this subversion of ethics is now the done thing in the corridors of power

The implication from Villiers’ spokesman is that these codes of parliamentary conduct are byzantine and complex, and I would have to agree. Interests must be registered, approved by ethics advisors, run past the Treasury, and assessed for any indication of vested interests. But this seems like an absolutely necessary bore to ensure we aren’t faced with the alternative; a kleptocracy in democratic clothing. 

Although this may seem like an overreaction, there are plenty of examples of MPs dexterously bending the rules to squeeze a little more into their pay packets. Lee Anderson MP was awarded around £100,000 for filming a promotional video for GB News in which he lamented his son’s university-inflicted vegetarianism, and reports suggest that Conservative MPs have earned £15.2 million in second jobs since the 2019 General Election. This profit-mongering is best shown by Nadine Dorries MP, who announced she would resign in June due to Rishi Sunak allegedly snubbing her a peerage from an outgoing Johnson. Despite her announcement, she, rather conveniently, failed to quit before the summer recess and will consequentially receive a further £22,000 payment of taxpayers’ money. This is all the more unpalatable considering Dorries has not spoken in the commons for over a year, has not attended a bill or select committee in the same timeframe, and has not held a constituency surgery since March 2020, a timeframe that comfortably dwarfs my undergraduate study at Durham.

The crossbench peer who heads the ethics watchdog, Lord Evans, has even conceded it “hard to argue” that all politicians are putting Parliament first. I, for one, find it uncomfortable to hear stories of how our elected officials answer primarily to lobbyists and the markets as opposed to their constituents. So, how can we foster a new post-sleaze era? From Villiers’ bookkeeping mishap to Dorries’ flashy new TalkTV gig, there exists a reality that not all MPs will work and represent purely for the raw democratic thrill of it. They, like their professional counterparts in the private sector, want remuneration, and preferably a lot of it. 

I find myself with an unfashionable opinion. I believe many call it a ‘hot take’, although personally I hate that phrase with a passion. But my opinion is this: politicians should earn more. This is normally where the record scratches and people look at me with visible, sometimes physical disgust. I admit, this sounds like one of those spoof political manifesto policies like legalising smoking in hospitals or electrifying the English Channel. But hear me out. 

Increasing MPs’ salaries could remove these underhanded attempts at extra earnings and attract smarter and less dogmatic politicians in one fell swoop

Current parliamentary salaries clearly attract those who care about politics but perhaps care about money that slight bit more. The Commons is full of those idiosyncratic individuals who used to revel and excel in their school debate clubs, but perhaps not in the classrooms. That’s why those intellectually challenging jobs like doctor, lawyer, or investment analyst (arguably an exception) come with such high salaries. They attract the brightest and most ambitious this country has to offer, leaving politics for the militant activists and wannabe celebrities. Increasing MPs’ salaries could remove these underhanded attempts at extra earnings and attract smarter and less dogmatic politicians in one fell swoop. 

It’s not a fashionable argument to finish on, but with MPs now being exposed for morally questionable conduct surrounding extra earnings, innovative new ways to curtail this inclination towards money may have to challenge our existing attitudes towards politicians. 

Image credits: Nikki Powell via Wikimedia Commons