A Tale of Two Lockdowns

By Samuel Lopes

It’s been a long while since anyone in Britain last heard the sound of a real roaring crowd. For New Zealanders, it has hardly been any time at all – just last month, a packed Wellington Stadium hosted a crowd of 31, 000 during a Bledisloe Cup Test draw.

While Europe is languishing in the midst of a second wave, several countries have stood apart as paragons of controlling the spread of the coronavirus, chief among them Japan, New Zealand, Australia and South Korea. Why has the West not taken the same approach?

Public confidence in the UK government’s handling of the pandemic has decreased 10% since the end of the first nationwide lockdown in July.

It is not, as Boris Johnson suggests, because of Britain’s ‘freedom-loving’ status. Instead, the government has consistently misled and confused the British public with oblique restrictions and regulations. Public confidence in the UK government’s handling of the pandemic has decreased 10% since the end of the first nationwide lockdown in July, and it is easy to see why – a push to ‘eat out to help out’ followed almost immediately with the national chastisement of a new tiered set of local restrictions. Mixed messaging, on the government’s part, has resulted in a loss of public faith which may take generations to restore.

Japan – a country with double the population of the UK and only 8% of the UK’s coronavirus cases.

Contrast this state of affairs with that of Japan – a country with double the population of the UK and only 8% of the UK’s coronavirus cases. Much has been made of the Japanese culture helping to control the disease, but local experts point to more concrete factors; a coherent contact-tracing strategy, a timely reaction from the government and early public awareness helping to social distance, wear masks and sanitise hands without government prompting.

Britain and Japan share many similarities; both were industrial island nations that saw the virus spread through neighbouring countries (Italy and China respectively) before reaching their shores.

The difference in responses is stark.

Despite repeated claims of ‘following the science’, less than a quarter of UK researchers feel that the government has adequately followed scientific advice. In New Zealand, the reverse is true; over three quarters of New Zealand scientists agreed that Jacinda Ardern took scientific advice into account when devising her policy to deal with the pandemic.

Scientific advice in the UK has been repeatedly ignored in favour of bland rhetoric and empty gestures which may have achieved more harm than good. Even in May, a relatively unambiguous message to ‘stay home’ was replaced with ‘stay alert’, representing a shift from following expert advice to trusting individuals to possess the discretion to decide what is safe to do.

Of course, science does not take into account economic factors – the UK has recovered more slowly than other comparable European countries and so the government may consider higher case numbers to be a necessary evil to maintain a healthy economy. However, even the government’s interventions may have had negative side effects – the ‘eat out to help out’ scheme is estimated to have been responsible for nearly a sixth of new coronavirus clusters over the summer.

Once again, other countries appear to have got the balance right. Rather than pursuing a strategy of total elimination (such as New Zealand or Australia), Japan has opted for continuous control of the virus to preserve the economy, keeping the R value constant at one. Following scientific advice does not have to come at the expense of the economy.

Brexit and its aftermath have resulted in a government which has repeatedly eschewed expert advice, but now needs it more than ever.

Perhaps the government has, in Michael Gove’s words, ‘had enough of experts’. Brexit and its aftermath have resulted in a government which has repeatedly eschewed expert advice, but now needs it more than ever. Using scientists as a rhetorical rubber stamp will not be enough.

Rather than continuing to pursue failing strategies at containing and mitigating the virus until a vaccine is widely available, the government would do well to follow the example of other countries and put scientific advice front and centre in their efforts to combat the virus.

Image: UK Prime Minister via Creative Commons