A serious discussion with Durham Alumnus Alistair Robinson
From creativity in journalistic writing to artistry in creation
By Celeste Yeo
Alistair is a Senior Lecturer in Journalism in the Faculty of Arts, Design and Media at Sunderland University. He studied Modern History at Durham University and became inspired to read and write poetry in Durham. He was a journalist for many years and has written books on the history of theatre and two collections of poetry. While his main academic interest lies in historical research and exploring the way journalism is written (from its historical roots to present day contexts), his passion for the arts is equally strong.
—
What are your thoughts about the relationship between journalism and creative writing? What distinguishes the two?
Creative writing can be, and often is, entirely fictional. Journalism can be creative, it’s often entertaining, it can use techniques of fiction writing and even elements of fiction but ultimately it’s about facts. We can express those facts in a creative way, but the bottom line is facts are sacred. (A famous Guardian Editor C.P. Scott once remarked, “Comment is free, but facts are sacred.”)
However, I am fascinated by the similarities between the two forms of writing. They are both about observing the world in a detailed manner. You need a particular eye and a particular voice to uncover the truth or truths. They are also similar in that there is no roomin either form of writing for redundant words. Every single word has to play a particular function.
Doesn’t that apply to all forms of writing?
While it is important for all forms of writing to be concise, it is more so for journalism and poetry (as compared to academic writing and other forms). This is because in journalism you have to convey the message within a limited space and amount of time. You need to get the message across to the audience in the most efficient manner. In a novel you have a huge amount of words to play with, but you don’t have such freedom in journalistic prose, especially news reports. That is why precision and conciseness are so important in journalism. There are greater practical concerns involved. When it comes to conciseness in poetry, you’re going even further. Poetryis the most distilled form of expression.
Hence, one could say that because journalistic prose has to adhere to a certain form or structure, there is greater demand for clarity and precision in journalism.
It is partly the form, but not just the form. Not all journalistic writing adheres to a certain form or structure. There is freedom for exploration but it depends on the type of journalistic writing. Some forms of journalism can be more artistic than others. Several famous writers have approached journalism using novelistic techniques, like Truman Capote and Tom Wolfe. Journalism can be very imaginative sometimes – with some reportage and magazine articles and feature writing allowing for greater experimentation. But there is very little of this in basic news reporting, for good reason.
And how would you relate poetry to journalism?
Like journalistic writing, poetry demands utmost clarity. On one end of the scale of writing would be general prose while on the other it would be poetry.
Don’t you think that a lot of poems (whether traditional ones or contemporary ones) don’t obey the principle of clarity?
Well I think they should obey the principle of clarity. Poetry is about form, clarity, conciseness. Poetry can sometimes be conversational but shouldn’t be sloppy. We can be undisciplined in the way we use language in daily conversation but we can’t do that in fine writing. But poetry can be puzzling, cryptic, enigmatic – without compromising on clarity of expression.
Whereas a journalist cannot afford to be cryptic.
No, you can’t read journalism twice – it has to be understood immediately. Journalism is a literature of the moment, whereas for poetry sometimes you would need rereading.
One could say that there is a fine line between being cryptic and unclear, in a poem.
Lack of clarity in expression is not good. But being cryptic and enigmatic is different. One is intentional and requires a skill, whereas the other just means a lack of precision, skill, not carefully shaping language. That is different from employing rhythm and stylistic devices.
Basic things such as grammar, sentence construction – linguistic requirements in all languages, clear key components – one has to learn those before one can depart from them. I am always telling my students, to be a professional writer you have to learn and be very adept at the key components of writing. You must know the discipline and what constitutes a sentence. You must write grammatically. With sentence construction you can eventually pull away from certain rules and be more creative but only once you have understood and become adept at the basics.
Can one completely depart from traditional forms?
There is a discipline in sticking to traditional forms in any form of art. But that discipline can actually spur creativity.
Discipline can be very liberating. For instance in one anthology of poetry I was forced to write a poem based on a line in Elizabeth Smart’s prose poem, ‘By Grand Central Station I Sat Down And Wept’. A friend gave every one of us involved in this project a line to write about, at random. I find that very liberating. Fascinating. The discipline was in sticking to the line, and to create out of it. I really enjoyed it.
There is form in both journalism and poetry. Sometimes in using a pre-established form, the poem becomes dead or a cliché – bad verse is sometimes a slave to rhyme, for instance. For all art it is important to know the structure, the form; these forms exist for good reason but it’s good to know where the limits are. If you practise long enough you can depart from these forms. For example, creating music is also about learning forms – patterns, scales, for instance – but in playing jazz, as I do, you can depart from the conscious application of those elements once you become conversant with them.
Were you interested in music before you were involved in writing?
Yes I’ve been playing music since I was a kid. I played for pubs and college events while I was studying in Durham. I play the guitar and piano. But it was only in the 1990s that I began to embark on more serious music projects. My band, The Bicycle Thieves (founded in 1997), released a CD on the Road Goes On Forever label. We’ve played many times in Durham. We had a residency in the café at the Gala Theatre every Saturday for nine years!
Which medium of expression do you most identify yourself with? If you had to choose just one art form, which would it be?
All the arts are equally important to me. At all points in time. However, whenever I am immersed in a specific medium (whether music or writing), I am just concentrating on one aspect, using a particular eye.
How does music and writing overlap for you? Do they inspire each other?
They tend to be separate. Sometimes when I do historical research for academic writing I can see ideas for creative writing. But it is not the case for music. I don’t put my words from creative writing into music. Forms of writing are separate from my musical compositions. But, yes, recently I’ve thought about setting my poetry to music.
That sounds like a wonderful idea. I look forward to appreciating such intriguing, refreshing works of art!
—

Alistair Robinson will be giving a talk in St Chad’s College Chapel at 7.30pm on 27th November.
He will talk about his journey into journalism, writing and academia, and read from his new collection
of poetry. At 7.30pm on 4th December he will be reading at Poetry Jam at Waddington Street Centre,
Durham City.
More about Alistair Robinson:
Alistair is married with three daughters and lives in South Shields. His chapbook South Of Souter
(Sand) was published in 2003. The following year he won a Northern Promise Award from
New Writing North. His collections Stereograms Of The Dead and The Land Before Yoghurt were
published by Red Squirrel Press in 2009 and 2014 respectively. He has a poem in the recently
published anthology Double Bill, which features poetic responses to aspects of popular culture.
He is the author of two books on theatre history and one on the history of Sunderland. He also works as
a musician. His jazz trio, the Bicycle Thieves, plays at venues all over the North East of England and has released Stolen Moments on Road Goes On Forever Records. Alistair’s compositions for that album were published in the USA by Bug Music.
Images courtesy of Alistair Robinson

