A not so new world of politics: The importance of the Native American vote
By Mia Tillyard
A political blind side, an overlooked percentile: the Native American vote.
Almost exactly a year away from the 2024 presidential elections and it looks like the U.S. might be faced with another Biden-Trump run-off, but before the maps become a matrix of blue and red, what can be said of the Native American vote?
Come election day, Native American ballots will be counted and likely dismissed once more into a statistical ‘other’ or as CNN blundered, “something else.” However, in this glossed-over corner of the voter demographic, there lies a potentially powerful political asset.
Of the 6.79mn Native American people, 4.7mn are above voting age. The gravity of this figure mushrooms when we consider where the population is concentrated. Dispersed over some of the most notorious swing states, where voting margins are hairline-thin, the Native American ballot could be the force needed to edge the results one way or another.
Take Michigan for example. Though typically a state that runs blue, in 2016 Trump won by a slight 0.3% – one of the closest in election history – meaning at approximately 100,000, the Native voting population amounted to over four times the size of the difference. When wins can be as negligible as Biden’s in 2020, these seemingly small numbers could be paving the way to victory.
Midterm data collections in 2018 signified that for the most part, Native Americans were voting Democratic, and the 2020 results did not dispute this. With a population of around 90,000 Amerindians, Wisconsin saw Biden win by some 20,000 votes; the county with the highest vote share was Menominee which, overlapping with the Menominee Tribe’s reservation, also happens to be the most indigenously dense region of the state. In the states of Utah, New Mexico, and Colorado, where the Navajo Nation spans over, some precincts averaged around 84% of votes for Biden compared to a humbling 14% for Trump. Is this just a coincidence, or is this an insight into the gravity of the minority ballot?
“American Indian voters have arguably been the deciding factor in recent elections” commented Alexander Castillo-Nunez, from the Intertribal Council of Arizona. By the figures, this is a credible possibility. However, if such is the case, it is all the more important to increase the number of active Native American voters. Just 66% of the Native Americans eligible to vote are registered. Albeit a disinterest in democracy is surely not the reason. For many indigenous tribes, this is no ‘new world’ of politics; tribes like those of the Iroquois and Powhatan Confederacies pioneered the federalism we see in today’s America.
In reality, America’s duel-sovereign system allows for states to implement voting suppression strategies meaning for many Native Americans the battle for a vote prevails. In 2004, Arizona passed its Voter ID laws and inadvertently stifled thousands of voices. Living in rural areas, many Native Americans possess Tribal IDs with no specific residential address, rendering them incompatible with the system data stored at the polling stations. Just like that: no vote. Shortly before the 2018 midterms, North Dakota did the same thing but stipulated that PO boxes were not viable addresses, making postal voting near impossible for tribal members.
Whilst the data historically proposes that American Indians favour the Democrats, the data is by no means consistent and cannot be considered a harbinger for future elections. The Democrats should not get too comfortable, and the Republicans should take a better look at their hand.
Trump understood this back in 2020 and tapped into what could quite possibly be the milk and honey of election success – a political gold mine. Residing in Robeson County, North Carolina, the Lumbee tribe makes up a notable 40% of the electorate. Trump found his gateway to gaining some kudos with the Native Americans: the Lumbee people are not officially recognised as a tribe by the federal government. When hosting a rally in this region, Trump promised the tribe recognition if he was to win. This tactic won him close to 60% of Robeson County’s votes and ultimately the State of North Carolina.
In previous years the region has corroborated almost directly inverse results: in 2012, 58% of voters bolstered blue and sided with Obama. Trump’s expedient allying flipped the trend on its head and turned Democratic votes Republican.
Attempting to predict an election result based on previous tendencies is like herding cats, but what we can conclude is that the Native American vote has more sway than given credit for. Before Biden and Trump lock horns once more, perhaps they should recognise the importance of Native American voters more than they do now.
Artwork: Thomas Nast

