A cry to the right: Suella Braverman’s immigration statement
By Mia Tillyard
On a recent trip to Washington, Suella Braverman dared to “broach a taboo” and accused asylum seekers of being fake homosexuals in an attempt to “game the system”.
Home Secretary Braverman made an appearance at US Centre-Right think tank, American Enterprise Institute, eager to discuss her “critical” concern regarding “the global asylum framework”.
Attacking principles set out by the post-war Geneva Convention in 1951, Braverman declared that the principles intended to protect refugees are outdated and in desperate need of a reform. The global asylum framework instructs that if an individual “cannot safely reside in the country of their nationality” due to “fear of persecution”, sanctuary should be granted. However, the senior Cabinet minister alleged that such a treaty has evolved into a “promissory note that the West cannot fulfil […] incentivising millions of people to try their luck”.
Braverman had not just one bone to pick but a whole skeleton of them. She asserted that, as a country, we welcome refugees under a “misguided dogma of multiculturalism”; she also boldly stated that migrants “pick and choose their preferred country to take asylum in”, labelling them “economic migrants”.
Her disregard for the legislative homophobia and genderism that continues to prevail in many nations was only amplified when she cautioned that “simply being gay” or “fearful of being a woman” is not sufficient to be granted asylum.
Though at the heart of her criticism, she expressed that there has been “an interpretive shift away from persecution in favour of something more akin to a definition of discrimination”. Braverman used this notion to foreground her controversial accusation; she sweepingly declared that asylum seekers fake homosexuality in order to “game our system” and “get special treatment”.
It is not ground-breaking to mention that immigration law has continuously divided British politics, however the Home Secretary hasfurther divided the nation with her bold claims. Her disregard for the legislative homophobia and genderism that continues to prevail in many countries was only amplified when she cautioned that “simply being gay” or “fearful of being a woman” is not sufficient to be granted asylum.
Her statements have hit the UK like a hurricane, unsurprisingly causing uproar between Labour and the Conservatives, but also amongst the Tories themselves. The terms “dog whistle politics” and “scapegoating” have been used and some party members outrightly disputed Braverman’s sentiments.
In a display of intra-party outrage, Andrew Boff – a senior patron of the LGBTQ+ Conservative group – rebuked Braverman, saying that “talking about the victims of persecution as if they are the problem is incredibly unhelpful and really paints us as an uncaring party.” Meanwhile, some members of the queer community have sat firmly in favour of the other hand. Tory Michael Fabricant, who is a benefactor for the LGBTQ+ group alongside Boff, denounced that being gay “should not provide the key to entry to our country”.
Perhaps the controversy lies with Braverman’s failure to justify. She is quick to differentiate that persecution and discrimination are not of the same threat, but fails to distinguish why. Within many cases, discrimination is considered to have been a predecessor to legislative persecution. In conjunction with the government’s plans to send illegal immigrants to Rwanda, this week’s events remind us that UNHCR has cautioned that if the UK fails to offer protection to those in need, they would be in “clear breach” of the Refugee Convention.
Using data from the Home Office, the Daily Mail has pointed out that 2021 figures show that sexual orientation only footed 1% of all applications claiming asylum.
There have been whisperings that Braverman leapt into her speech with the prospect of our government departing from the convention. When asked if this was a possibility, she commented that following explicit directions from the Prime Minister, they would do “whatever it takes” to stick to their agenda. However, in a different statement she did clarify that, unlike some of her predecessors, she is “merely advocating for reform” – or at least for the time being. If “whatever it takes” is the limit, how far will Tories go to tighten UK borders?
According to Jon Featonbury, they are willing to overlook facts in favour of allegations “not grounded in credible evidence”. Using data from the Home Office, the Daily Mail has pointed out that 2021 figures show that sexual orientation only footed 1% of all applications claiming asylum. These figures force us to question the Home Secretary’s incendiary claims. Is this all a tactical diversion from the party’s slipping grasp on other promises?
Former Home Secretary, Priti Patel, commented that “speeches do not substitute for delivery” and it “might just have been for attention”.
As speculated by many, Braverman could be using controversy as a rhetorical amplifier, as a ploy to rally attention in advance of the Conservative Party Conference that took place a few days later. After all, it is likely that Braverman will present herself as candidate for the next Conservative leader, following her failed attempt running against Rishi Sunak last year. With the 2024 general elections right around the corner, it is imperative she considers her political prevalence; although when inviting neo-Nazi approval, she must tread with caution.
Mark Collet, a Patriotic Alternative member, praised Braverman saying that “what she said is a good thing for nationalism”.
This type of attention has the potential to backfire when the general election eventually does roll around; the Conservatives are making themselves vulnerable to possible tactical voting away from incendiary culture war positioning.
Image: House of Lords via Flickr
