A Lesson from Canada: Can Mark Carney teach the Old Lady new tricks?

by Marley Miller
B


Maple leaf flags will be flown over the Bank of England this summer as Mark Carney takes the helm as its first ever foreign Governor. Canadian born Carney, who currently heads the Bank of Canada, has been brought in to show the Old Lady of Threadneedle Street how it’s done on the other side of the Atlantic and revamp some of the Bank’s stagnant policies.

But the 47-year old is playing his cards close to his chest. Facing a grilling by the Treasury Select Committee this week, he indicated a wish for a more transparent approach and an increased role in boosting the economy. Yet, what his leadership means for monetary policy and the pound is still unclear.

The former Goldman Sachs employee built his reputation as a central banker by steering Canada out of the financial crisis faster than any of its G7 peers. A combination of near-zero interest rates and clear communication meant that the Canadian economy practically dodged the global economic meltdown and his appointment as Chairman of the Basel-based Financial Stability Board (FSB) is testament to the respect he has garnered as a regulator.

Arriving from a nation with a much stricter line on banks and chairing an organization at the forefront of the crackdown on the “too big to fail” mentality, it will be interesting to see what alterations are to come for British banking regulation. Even more so now that the Bank of England is seizing back its regulatory powers from the short-lived New Labour experiment, the FSA. Canadian banks came away from the crisis unscathed due to rulings against big domestic banks merging, where as the British solution was to merge them (Lloyds TSB and HBOS) – and we’re still picking up the bill!

Maybe it was because of his sterling reputation (no pun intended) that his career ambitions came under the gun in Parliament this week? Or possibly, it was due to the fact that he only agreed to take up the job if the term was shortened to 5 years (rather than the usual 8) inciting rumours of a plan to run for leadership of the Canadian Liberal Party. Either way, Carney clarified that the choice wasn’t part of a long-term career strategy:

“I’m surprised it has been suggested that taking one of the most challenging jobs in central banking in another country would be politically advantageous in my home country. If I had political ambitions, I would have pursued them in Canada and so I think this is revealed preference. I do not have political ambitions.”

The questioning from MPs did, however, reveal some hints as to what could be some of the key differences between Carney and the outgoing Governor, Sir Mervyn King.

Perhaps most important is the Canadian’s view on the role of a central bank in stimulating the economy. Unlike his predecessor, Carney believes that the Bank could play more of a part in boosting demand and should focus on both GDP growth rates and inflation rates rather than just inflation. Moreover, in times of crisis, the inflation target, the backbone of British central banking, may have to be chucked.

And I know you’re wondering what they’ll name the Target 2.0 competition without a strict 2.0 target, but “flexible inflation targeting” could be a step toward more dynamic policies.  In times of waning economic growth, the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) could provide solace by assuring investors that interest rates will remain low. Inflation could be unchained to boost growth.

Even so, don’t hold your breath for a more radical approach. When it comes to delivering on his goals, Carney stated at the World Economic Forum in Davos that traditional monetary policy measures were not “maxed out”. He agrees with King that the solution isn’t printing money to fund government spending or fuel demand. There will be no “helicopter money”.

The second difference lies in the incoming Governor’s views on leadership. Andrew Tyrie, Chairman of the Treasury Select Committee, deemed the “centralised and hierarchical” governance structure of the Bank under Mervyn King a barrier to its effectiveness. Noting a desire to step away from such a model (and gain a more pleasant nickname than “Sun King”), Carney told the Committee that for his ideal managing style “It can’t be an emperor, it’s more a managing partner.”

Thirdly, Carney’s faith in the quantitative easing (QE) programmes that were designed to cure the British economy of its recession blues might not be as unwavering as his predecessor. He has admitted that the returns from the asset purchasing schemes are diminishing (following a Bank of Canada report into the subject) and has said that, if more monetary stimulus were required, he would be willing to “explore alternatives”.

But perhaps the greatest difference between the two bankers is found by judging the book by its cover. And no, I’m not referring to the fact that King lags behind in the looks department in comparison to his “young, good looking and charismatic” counterpart (his words not mine!) but in how they want to communicate their policies. Carney has expressed an interest in following in the Fed’s footsteps and clearly explaining the relationship between output and inflation and what the Bank’s expectations are. He hopes that it will be this kind of honesty (along with a vast improvement in the Bank’s economic forecasts), which will reestablish the Bank’s credibility and confidence in the economy.

He also talked of plans to “engage widely, using speeches and media interviews” and increase the Bank’s use of social media outlets in order to keep the public in the loop on decisions (and save a pound or $1million in the case of Canada on advertising).

The arrival of Mark Carney is a sign of hope for a bank in need of a facelift (if not a policy overhaul). His openness to a debate on the inflation target is refreshing compared to Sir Mervyn’s by-the-book nature and an experienced regulator and well-respected international voice might be just what the Bank needs to get back on track. Sadly, as just one vote on a Monetary Policy Committee of nine people, it might be an uphill battle to make any significant changes to the world’s second oldest central bank.