A hung parliament could be good for the UK

The financial markets have been wobbling recently. No, I am not referring to the meteoric vibrations which shook the globe following the collapse of Lehman Brothers. I instead reference the somewhat more modest fluctuations of markets anxious about the prospect of a hung parliament in the UK.

For most voters in the UK, the last hung parliament, following the February election of 1974, is a distant and dusty memory of eight months of indecision and inter-party squabbling which led to a second snap election in October of the same year. The second set of results were barely any more conclusive than the first, with Labour having a three-seat majority. Their tiny lead was eroded by by-election defeats, resulting in a weak minority government trampled by the rise of the Tories under Margaret Thatcher. Here endeth the history lesson.

The country may have little recollection of the political waverings of the mid-1970s; however, the financial markets memorize times of turmoil with far greater accuracy than any disillusioned voter.

The Cabinet Office has published a draft ‘rule book’ in an attempt to avoid controversy should a hung parliament arise. It works on the principle that the old government would act in a ‘caretaker capacity’ until it becomes apparent who in the new Parliament commands the confidence and authority to form a new government. In these circumstances, the Prime Minister would not be allowed to make any important decision which could hinder any future government.

This strategy would seem nothing short of sensible to the average voter, if not a little dull. The markets, however, are somewhat more dubious about the prospect of a government which is politically and constitutionally impotent and as such is unable to dispense some much-needed fiscal Viagra, in the form of strong financial policy.

In a country still constitutionally bound to the monarchy, some have suggested that in the event of a hung parliament, the Queen should abandon her traditional non-political stance and personally select the Prime Minister from the candidates put forward by the coalition parties. This is absurd. I wholeheartedly embrace the advantages of a non-political head of state; to undermine this would be to undermine the established role of the monarchy as it has developed since the beheading of Charles I.

The Cabinet Secretary, Sir Gus O’Donnell, has said that if a hung parliament arose in the present political climate, it would be Gordon Brown’s duty to stay in office until a stable government was reached. Regarding the political role of the Queen, O’Donnell stated that it is “the responsibility of the Prime Minister to ensure that the monarch remains above politics and that when the Prime Minister resigns it is very apparent who the Queen should be calling to produce the next hopefully stable government”.
The international credit ratings agencies have the power to downgrade the colossal debt carried by our government if they see evidence of successful implementation of austerity measures. All three parties are currently promising to introduce a variety of methods of budget austerity in order to reduce the mammoth deficit the country is begrudgingly facing.

Darling’s December pre-Budget report proposed a ‘Four Year Plan’ which states the proportion of spending cuts and tax increases, yet fails to address where cuts will be made or a more long-term strategy of economic repair.

Indeed, there is some rationality in markets’ fears; there is a strong correlation between a high Labour poll rating and Stirling falling in value against the Euro. Correlation, however, does not imply causation and the whole situation could be attributed to jittery, recession-bruised markets trying to dictate political policy.

Yet, it could be argued that the markets have a right to be a little uneasy. Decisions need to be taken over a long-term plan for economic recovery soon after the next general election and whilst all parties are united in an austerity policy, they are also united in a crisis of indecision.

The markets fear that with a hung parliament, the parties would adopt polarised positions, resulting in financial dithering over whether to tax or spend. From this analysis, it is not the continuation of a Labour government which the markets baulk at most but instead, an indecisive, oscillatory economic strategy.

The one factor that is being overlooked is the amount the world has changed since 1974. In 2010, there is no reason why a coalition government should not be forced to function. Indeed, it may be a positive development in a country which lacks a codified constitution and whimpers at the prospect of constitutional reform.

Germany has one of the strongest economies in the European Union and it exists in a state of perpetual governmental coalition. Greece, by contrast, has floundered under what was perceived as a ‘strong’ one-party leadership. Moreover, since 1970, ten of the largest fiscal consolidations in member states of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development have occurred under coalition governments.

Britain has been force-fed the idea that so-called hung parliaments spell doom for the nation. Indeed, the very word ‘hung’ engenders images of political stagnancy, death and paralysis. Furthermore, as we are repeatedly told that, historically, hung parliaments are a disaster, I would point doubters to the fact that the Second World War was won under a coalition government. Additionally, this country has functioned with a minority or coalition government for 34 of the last 100 years.

Regardless of an individual’s political bias, in the current political landscape it is the Liberal Democrats who hold the key to unlock the potential of a hung parliament. Nick Clegg requires 75% of his MPs, including all of his major prospective ministers, to be in agreement before he could lead his party into a coalition. He has already stated that he does not want to enter into coalition but, in the event of minority government, Clegg would have to discuss the situation with the party commanding the largest political mandate. Despite present polls, the Conservatives seem the more likely party; moreover, it would be madness for the Liberal Democrats to enter a coalition with a Labour minority government made possible by the unfair ‘first-past-the-post’ voting system which is traditionally abhorred by the Lib Dems.

A single-party government elected on ‘first-past-the-post’ grounds is totally unrepresentative of the total vote. Labour presently holds 57% of the seats but only 36.4% of the vote. If a coalition government was sensibly formed upon a sound model of proportional representation, Parliament itself could be made stronger due to the executive’s reliance on the benevolence of the legislature. This would produce a powerful, yet suitably tethered government; free to make sensible reform with neither the legislative nor executive power to bury civil liberties, human rights and, ultimately, common sense under an avalanche of bureaucracy and red tape.

In a country famed for its ‘no-nonsense’ attitude, common sense seems to be somewhat lacking in our antiquated governmental system. Already, civil servants are beavering away to produce guidelines which would effectively strangle all of the attractive possibilities created by a coalition government.

In 2010, both the media and the markets move a great deal faster than their 1974 counterparts. The UK is unique in its desire to form a government almost within hours of a confirmed election result. Perhaps, in the lack of a clear majority, the best course of action would be to allow political parties time to negotiate a workable compromise.
In a nation fuelled by the relaxation and clarity brought about by a cup of tea, we should perchance avoid the furore following an uncertain election result by encouraging our elected representatives to boil their kettles, sit down and discuss the opportunities presented by coalition calmly and sensibly.

I would welcome a few days of debate if it resulted in the formation of a coalition government injected with gumption and impetus, rather than political inertia and inaction until the next election is called.

It seems the country, however, would rather ‘hang’ around in anticipation of a snap election, rather than grasp the rare opportunity to break from tradition and embrace the chance for real political change.