A game of two halves: were the Paris Olympics an overall success for Team GB?

By Joseph Saunders and Ben Pawlowski

In a new feature included in every print edition, two writers take part in a head-to-head debate surrounding a key issue in the world of sport. This week, we gave our Sport Editors Joseph Saunders and Ben Pawlowski the following prompt: The Paris Olympics were an overall success for Team GB.

Yes (Joseph Saunders, Sport Editor):

Across the last four summer Olympics, Team GB has consistently garnered between 64 and 67 medals. Admittedly, Paris 2024’s total was distributed more on silver and bronze, leaving only fourteen gold medals coming back to these shores. The consistent medal count indicates the potential for winners – those split-second or fractional point differences that sport is all about simply fell against us more often.

In fact, Team GB won medals in eighteen different sports, including Toby Roberts’ sport climbing gold and Kate Shortman and Isabelle Thorpe’s silver in artistic swimming, each the first medal of any colour in their respective sports for the country. In an era of elevated global athletic performance, diversification of medals represents a maximised potential for medals.

Away from precious metals, Athletics GB’s achievements were a massive step forward from Tokyo and Rio. Keely Hodgkinson’s 800m gold pushes GB back to the forefront of middle distance running, as does Josh Kerr’s statement silver in a personal best time. We were the only nation to medal in all five relays.

We should be immensely proud of our little island’s performance

Matt Hudson-Smith and Katerina Johnson-Thompson were two more individual medallists posting elite times. Outside the golden 2012 trio of Mo Farah, Jess Ennis-Hill, and Greg Rutherford, only Kerr had won an individual medal on the track until 2024. GB’s struggles seem to be over.

In the regatta, order was restored. Poor performances left Team GB with only two medals in 2020, but renewed investment and changes amongst the board brought great success. Three gold medals and eight in total in Paris rendered rowing our most successful sport at the Games.

The first half of the Games brought abundant optimism as we looked on course to set medal records left right and centre. A quieter second week saw those hopes quashed, but a new generation of Olympic greats has emerged. Emma Finucane won three medals, Alex Yee and Tom Pidcock’s Herculean golds secured their status amongst Britain’s greats, and Duncan Scott became the most decorated Scot in the history of the Games.

We must look at each Olympic Games with a wider lens; since 2012 we have been treated to by far the greatest Olympic dynasty this country has ever seen. Stability is hugely impressive – it is only getting harder to earn medals. We should be immensely proud of our little island’s performance.

No (Ben Pawlowski, Sport Editor):

This summer’s Olympics were a marvellous spectacle. Set against a beautiful Parisian backdrop, the Games were a magnificent bonanza of sporting achievement, endeavour and perseverance. On a British note, who could forget Alex Yee’s remarkable late surge towards triathlon glory, young Toby Roberts’ thrilling final climb, Tom Pidcock’s scarcely believable recovery following a puncture or Keely Hodgkinson storming to 800m gold.

Yet, so often, Team GB’s fortnight in Paris felt like a story of so near but so far. Adam Peaty, Matt Richards, Duncan Scott and Ben Proud all fell by the wayside by mere milliseconds in the pool. Matt Hudson-Smith and Josh Kerr posted PBs on the track yet were still pipped to gold. Beth Shriver appeared unbeatable on her BMX bike until the final where she inexplicably finished last.

In the final week, one could be forgiven for thinking it was Groundhog Day. Expectations rose of a gold, boisterous pre-recorded videotapes were played on the BBC, only for hopes to then be quickly dashed as our athletes were beaten, seemingly always by an American or a Dutchman by an agonisingly small margin.

£17 million of the taxpayer’s money per gold, particularly in the current economic climate, does not scream value for money

The result? 8 fewer golds than Tokyo 2020. Team GBs lowest position on the medal table in two decades, behind countries including Japan, Australia, France and the Netherlands, the latter a nation of just 17 million people. Only 21% of our medals converted into precious gold. Sailing, boxing, taekwondo and hockey – all former gold mines – were notable failures. We only won one gold apiece in the pool, on the track and in the velodrome.

Yes, we posted 65 medals in total. But we are not the United States, who take pride in manipulating the medal table to suit their strengths. Golds are the ultimate Olympic currency, and given that Team GB’s chef de mission admitted a year ago that “the wheels would have to fall off” to fall outside the top 5, something has clearly gone wrong. The normal gold rush became a trickle.

Team GB’s athletes benefitted from £245 million of government funding in the three-year cycle prior to the Games. £17 million of the taxpayer’s money per gold, particularly in the current economic climate, does not scream value for money. Some will argue we were unlucky. We may well have been, but that is the nature of sport. Let’s hope Los Angeles 2028 represents an improvement.

Image: Bo Zhang via Unsplash