A friend for those on death row
Whether one believes in the morality of the death penalty or not, all defendants share the right to fair criminal proceeding and decent legal representation – especially when the punishment could be irreversible. Yet it is a terrible truth that public legal representation provided to defendants in capital punishment cases in the USA is often overworked and under-experienced, which can easily lead to errors. Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg perhaps summed it up best when she noted that “people who are well represented at trial do not get the death penalty”.
All defendants in criminal proceedings in the US are legally entitled to a public defender or court-appointed lawyer, but there is no guarantee as to the quality of their assigned legal representation. Public defenders are often underpaid and under-resourced, making their job extremely difficult. No matter how well-intentioned, court-appointed lawyers often lack trial experience and sometimes have never defended a capital case before. Sometimes, the situations is even more problematic; in the state of Washington one-fifth of those who faced execution over the past twenty years had lawyers who had been, or were later, disbarred, suspended or arrested. In the wider justice system, one in four capital defendants have been represented by lawyers who have been disciplined for professional misconduct. The mistakes that these lawyers can make range from elementary to egregious. Larry Griffin was executed on the basis of witness testimony that stated he had extended his right hand out of a car window and shot 19 year old Quintin Moss. His overworked and under-trained lawyer never challenged this testimony despite the fact that Griffin was left-handed. Capital defendant Judy Haney’s experience was even more farcical; her court-appointed lawyer was jailed himself for showing up drunk to her capital trial proceedings.
It is within this context that the legal charity Amicus operates. Founded in memory of Andrew Lee Jones, who was executed by the state of Louisiana in 1991, Amicus aims to improve the training of legal professionals to deal with capital cases, and in doing so help balance out the problem of poor representation for poor and vulnerable people in the American justice system. Amicus are based in the UK and send over twenty to thirty interns trained in capital defence to the USA each year to provide legal services to capital defendants. Amicus argue that the poor quality of representation afforded to those who must opt for public defenders often leads to violating their right to due process. The injustice of this system is compounded by one simple fact; only those who cannot afford to pay for a lawyer are assigned public defenders, and therefore those from economically disadvantaged backgrounds are vastly more likely to be sentenced to death for their crimes.
Amicus’s job is made harder by the fact that the structure of the US legal system effectively encourages the delegation of capital representation to under-resourced lawyers. Some jurisdictions give capital cases to the attorney who makes the lowest bid, effectively guaranteeing that a defendant will not have expert witnesses called on their behalf. It is this inequality between the defense and prosecution resources that produces such a gulf of injustice: prosecutors are often free to spend vast sums on thorough investigations, expert witnesses and other necessary out-of-court expenses. Capital defendants usually have no such luxury: in some states, public defenders are actually legally capped on the amount they can spend defending a capital case. Alabama, for example, capped out-of-court expenses to a paltry one thousand dollars. In contrast, a well-organised prosecution can be expected to spend over ten times that amount. The racial prejudice that overshadows the American legal system also has a part to play. A North Carolina study found that the odds of receiving a death sentence were three and a half times higher for defendants whose victims were white.
Perhaps the defining feature of a fair democracy is that all citizens are equal under the law, but how can that be true when the poorest in society are deprived of adequate legal representation—sometimes at the cost of their lives. Mistakes made by inexperienced and under-funded lawyers can lead to innocent people facing a death sentence, which is arguably the ultimate subversion of the ideals of a fair society. If a society chooses to hand down the ultimate punishment to their worst offenders, then it has a duty to ensure that, at the very least, those it chooses to execute are actually guilty of the crimes they are charged with committing. Legal wrongs and mistakes cannot be remedied from beyond the grave. By helping to ensure that only those truly guilty of capital crimes face the ultimate punishment, Amicus and other legal representation charities continue to battle for a small piece of justice in an overwhelmingly problematic justice system.
If you are interested in joining the Amicus Society or finding out more about their work, email Natalie Chan at n.y.y.chan@durham.ac.uk
Photograph: Amicus Society

