A case against there being a ‘People’s Vote’

Patrick Williamson

The British government is at risk of collapse. Both major parties are in disarray. Economic forecasts grow darker, yet we march ever faster toward leaving the European Union. But no – another referendum on our EU membership is neither desirable nor likely.

Given the high-profile individuals that have come out in support of a so-called ‘People’s Vote’, one might be excused for assuming the campaign is gaining momentum. Such assumptions are misguided.

Neither Theresa May nor Jeremy Corbyn are willing to face the electoral oblivion that would inevitably be inflicted by betrayed-feeling Leave voters at the ballot box if another vote happened

Soft Tories like Anna Soubry have joined the Liberal Democrats in calling for another ballot. Despite evoking an image of the Prime Minister under pressure, we must remember they must compete with the just-as-organised Brexiteer Jacob Rees Moggs and David Davies’ in the Conservative Party.

A notable trend is that the only politicians calling for another referendum are those that can politically afford to do so. Neither Theresa May nor Jeremy Corbyn are willing to face the electoral oblivion that would inevitably be inflicted by betrayed-feeling Leave voters at the ballot box if another vote happened. The vague, uncommitted, ‘all options on the table’ approach adopted at the Labour Party conference exemplifies this.

Brexit needs to bridge the gulf between Leave and Remain voters, not exacerbate it. Another vote would do the opposite.

The Liberal Democrats, with their twelve MPs, are still backing a People’s Vote, a seemingly low-risk strategy given that they expect to never actually have to implement this in government.

Remember tuition fees, anyone?

A second referendum is, therefore, unlikely. But should there be one? ‘Democracy doesn’t end at the ballot box’, we are told. After all, how would holding a referendum possibly be undemocratic?

We must remember, though, that there has not just been one vote on our EU membership – the public have repeatedly affirmed their desire to leave the EU.

In 2015, the Conservatives won a general election with a mandate to hold an in-out referendum. Parliament voted to hold that referendum by a landslide. Leave won. Another general election was held in which the two main parties promised to implement the referendum result, and saw their vote shares rise.

Is this not democratic enough?

Voters really did prioritise sovereignty over prosperity, for better or for worse. That must be respected

Allegedly not. ‘Voters didn’t understand the risks’, is their next line of argument. Such an argument is difficult to sustain. David Cameron repeatedly affirmed that we would be ‘better off’ remaining in the EU. George Osborne even warned that there might have to be an emergency budget if Leave won. The public knew the risks, and they still voted Leave. Voters really did prioritise sovereignty over prosperity, for better or for worse. That must be respected.

Even if another vote were to be held, there is considerable debate concerning its practicalities. Should no deal, with all its economic risk, be on the table? And should the public be given another chance to Remain?

The likes of Conservative MP Justine Greening, who endorses a ‘three-way’ vote, including options to Leave with or without a deal or Remain, think so. Such a referendum would not only gamble away our future through putting a no deal Brexit a vote away, but would likely see the winning option gain less than 50% of the vote. For such a monumental constitutional decision, this is wholly unacceptable.  

Populations, feeling ignored by a disconnected ‘liberal elite’ express their dissatisfaction, whether it be through Trump, Le Pen, or in our case, Brexit.

When pondering the question of another vote, we must remember why people voted Leave in the first place. The rising tide of populism has not only struck us, but the Americas, Asia and the rest of Europe, too. Populations, feeling ignored by a disconnected ‘liberal elite’ express their dissatisfaction, whether it be through Trump, Le Pen, or in our case, Brexit.

Populism, with all its irrationality and false promises, should be combated with reason, debate and, importantly, listening. Ignoring the referendum result would not disprove those who claim the political establishment to be arrogant and ignorant, but vindicate them. A second vote may kill off one symptom of populism, but will fuel it as a whole.

Britain’s parties must unite in looking for a sensible, pragmatic deal with the European Union. A deal which minimises economic harm, but which takes account of the concerns of Leave voters over our borders, sovereignty and trade. Importantly, Brexit needs to bridge the gulf between Leave and Remain voters, not exacerbate it. Another vote would do the opposite.

Photo Credit: Ilovetheeu via Wikimedia Commons