2023: the return of atrocities against Afghan women and the Hazara community?

By Rachal Limbu

Since the Taliban’s takeover on 15 August 2021, they have continued to pass draconian laws against women and are doing little to address claims of genocide against the Hazara community by the Islamic State Khorasan Province (IS-K). 

When the Taliban took over Afghanistan, they claimed to have a more moderate stance on women’s rights. However, on 20 December 2022, they issued an indefinite ban on women from entering University, which came as a shock to many female students who were about to sit their final exam. With primary education now the highest level of qualification available to them, girls and women are now going to see a further loss of their rights and freedoms. 

These bans have been met with protests from both men and women in Afghanistan. An eighteen-year-old Afghan woman stood with a sign in front of Kabul University with a single word, iqra, meaning ‘read’. This Arabic word is believed to be the first word God revealed to the Prophet Muhammad. Furthermore, fifty university professors have resigned since the ban, and one male professor even tore up his diploma on live TV. These protests have been met with violence from the Taliban, as growing claims of torture and mistreatment of detainees’ families surface. 

Women have also been banned from working for NGOs which comes as a terrible blow for their families who depend on them as primary breadwinners and Afghan women and girls who might not feel comfortable speaking about their problems to men. NGOs like the UN and several other aid groups have temporarily halted some of their operations in Afghanistan to put pressure on the Taliban to revoke their ban. This will have disastrous consequences for Afghans in immediate need of humanitarian relief, as estimates from the UN show that 95% of Afghans are struggling from hunger and around 3.5 million children are severely malnourished.

Afghanistan is dangerously close to mass famine and economic collapse, especially as the country is expecting another dry season. Another year of crop failure will be a tipping point for Afghanistan’s hunger crisis. With more than 90% of the population already living in poverty from food scarcity and economic disaster, if the Taliban do not allow women to return to work for the NGOs, drought and mass starvation will lead to unprecedented death tolls. 

Therefore in 2023, Afghanistan’s global ranking as the worst place for women will remain much the same. Without education and a right to work, conditions for women will worsen. Without a future for female doctors, teachers, and nurses, 2023 will see the beginning of the complete killing off of Afghanistan’s health, education, and public sectors. 

The Hazara community is another group facing a resurgence of attacks. Australian national university forecasts Afghanistan as one of the five countries most at risk of genocide. Mounting reports on targeted attacks committed by the Taliban should be of serious concern given the crimes against humanity and genocide the Taliban committed in the 1990s. The Taliban are responsible for mass Hazara graves in Bamiyan, which is also where they carried out the destruction of the 1,400-year-old status of Bamiyan Buddha in 2001. Mazara-I sharif Massacre in 1998, where an estimated 2000 to 5000 civilians were systematically and brutally executed, was a watershed moment that continues to traumatise the collective consciousness of the Hazara community. 

An eighteen-year-old Afghan woman stood with a sign in front of Kabul University with a single word, iqra, meaning ‘read’.

IS-K, are taking reasonability for most of these attacks, but the Taliban massacred 9 Hazara men in the Malistan district (most if not all of its population is Hazara) in July 2021 just a month before their takeover in Kabul. In July 2022, the Taliban displaced more than 25,000 Hazaras from their homes in provinces like Helmand (where British forces operated in the mid-2000s) and pushed them into intolerable mountainous terrains, making it more difficult for aid organizations to reach them. These events are starting to look more and more like the 1990s when the Taliban massacred and created a refugee crisis. 

The Hazara are Shia Muslims and roughly make up around 10 to 20% of the population, this makes them the public enemy of the Taliban and other Sunni extremist groups like the IS-K. Another reason for this resurgence of attacks is that Hazara champions women’s education and democracy, two things that go directly against the Taliban’s extreme ideology. Despite their historical marginalisation, in the last decade, they were able to make some political and economic gains by using education as a tool to improve their status in a country where they have been subordinated for generations. 

This year, we may see the Taliban aiming to push the Hazara back to their previous lower status and enact retribution on those Hazaras who helped international groups, including British troops between 2003 and 2014. The Taliban’s current decentralised network and its temperamental relationship with IS-K (the most extreme and violent of all the jihadist groups in Afghanistan) mean the likely return of the persecution of the 1990s. 

Looking at the current political and social trajectory of the Taliban, there is little to suggest that 2023 will bring any relief to women and the Hazara community in Afghanistan. The situation looks bleaker by the day as the Taliban continue to crack down on the rights and freedoms of Afghanistan’s two most vulnerable groups. 

However, there is something different about Afghanistan now than it was under the Taliban in the 1990s. There is a whole generation of Afghans, who have experienced freedom and moderate social change, and feel they are now in a better position to fight. The wind blowing from Iran, and their own fight against a religious militia, also gives many Afghans hope that they too can act against the brutal regime of the Taliban. If 2022 has taught us anything, it is that we cannot take for granted the power of civilian protest, 2023 will be a testament to this. 

Image: United Nations Photo via Flickr