“What sort of world have we come to?” A response to comments on river safety
By Ellen Orange
A statement from Chief Police constable Mike Barton was released today responding to calls from students to have increased police patrols along the river. While I myself agree that such calls are ridiculous, there was a much bigger problem with the chief constable’s response.
We all know that students and locals in Durham have a very difficult relationship. As someone who identifies with both (I’m a student, but I am from the North East and I live and work in Durham all year round) I feel like I may be straddling the fence a bit, but seeing the issue from both sides may, perhaps, lend a bit more perspective.
The Chief Constable suggested that it is students drinking that is leading to this issue. While I cannot dispute that this is very likely to have played a part in the unfortunate incidents that have occurred in the last year or so there is a suggestion here that the police should not be responsible for student safety. While student drinking may be excessive and an issue that needs to be dealt with, I would venture to suggest that it is no worse than the drinking culture of local residents at weekends. Working in a bar I have seen many locals as “paralytically drunk” as students get. And while many people may have their theories and reasons for why it has not occurred yet, I can’t help but feel the response from the police may have been different and moreover, more sensitive, if it had been a local who was involved in one of these incidents.
I am not wholly defending the student community here; I know there are those who can be stupid, as well as insensitive and even rude. But they are certain members of a large group, and equally there are certain local residents who fit the same descriptions, as do members of any group. Calls from students to have police officers patrol the riverside may be misplaced, perhaps innocently by people who have not thought of what this might entail, but this did not incite the response from the Chief Constable which almost negated police responsibility for student safety.
His suggestion that “It’s ludicrous that society is asking me to put police officers on the riverbank to stop bright young things from falling in’ is correct but incredibly insensitive. What should have been said is that this would take resources the police don’t have and that other methods will be looked into. However, this comment is less than professional, an angry response with reference to ‘bright young things’ which can only be seen as sarcastic when he goes on to ask “What sort of world have we come to?”
Whatever your opinion on the issues of either river safety or the tension between students and locals it is clear that this attitude is not conducive to improving the situation at all. The police have a responsibility to protect students as much as non-students and while they did an amazing job in the rescue that occurred by Hild Bede last week, the comments from Mike Barton will only fuel more tension between students and locals.
Students do live here, they bring money to the city, and some of us work or volunteer here. Instead of stating that students should be responsible for their own safety, as some kind of separate entity, the Chief Constable should be working with the university to engage students as part of the community.
Photograph by Ellen Orange

