The European elections: UKIP’s debut?
By Philip Naylor
The next twelve or so months mark an unusually active period of elections in Britain. May will see elections across the continent to represent some 500 million Europeans in the European Parliament. Certainly more significant will be the September referendum on Scottish independence, followed soon by the 2015 General Election.
European Parliament elections are strange beasts, often having outcomes that bear little or no resemblance to the following general election. The previous election in 2009 saw the UK Independence Party (UKIP) edge in to second place, but perhaps the most memorable result of the night was the North West and Yorkshire each returning a successful British National Party (BNP) Member of the European Parliament (MEP). A year later, UKIP slumped back to 3%, and the BNP even less.
The political context following the election, however, seems anything but business as usual. Defying their usual cyclic rise and fall centred on European elections, UKIP regained momentum and has put in strong performances in by-elections and the locals. Enjoying ever increasing publicity, Farage seems certain to improve significantly on their 2009 performance, perhaps even claiming first place, denying Miliband a boost of momentum. Many talk of UKIP as the new third party, supplanting the Liberal Democrats. But to truly establish themselves in Westminster will prove a challenge.
Momentum is everything in politics. While UKIP’s performance in 2014 will be strong, it is in the General Election that UKIP faces its real challenge and a cap on its so-called ‘meteoric’ rise.
First, it should be remembered that European elections are not General elections. While the European Parliament is an increasingly important institution, its elections are second-order, and do not capture the attention of the public. Views on Europe may be intensely polarized among sections of society, but for most it ranks far below other concerns – turnout will most definitely be low. It will not serve as a reliable indicator for 2015.
The proliferation of elections in the UK, coupled with decreasing party loyalty, has voters change their preference from election to election. The electorate know that this vote isn’t about selecting a government. In 2015, Labour and the Conservatives will undoubtedly receive higher proportion of the vote than they will in 2014.
If UKIP break the mould, and it is becoming wise not to underestimate them, and carry a good level of support through to 2015 and score around 15%, they still face one considerable opponent: the British electoral system. Britain’s first-past-the-post, or single member plurality, is an undeniably peculiar system that has been created through evolution, rather than revolution.
Votes do not automatically translate in to seats, and geographical concentration is key to winning votes. Election after election, the Liberal Democrats have been stymied by their diffuse support.
Though the difference between Labour and Lib Dem support in 2010 was only 6%, Labour won 258 seats to the Liberal’s 57. Labour’s concentrated vote in Scotland, Wales, North East England and cities delivers it seats time and time again.
Therein lies UKIPs challenge. Theoretically, it could score near 20% and win not a single seat at Westminster. Such a result would likely face criticism, but it shouldn’t be forgotten that smaller parties including the Lib Dems have had to put up with this system for decades. Also, the decisive rejection of electoral reform in the 2011 AV referendum has likely kicked the issue in to the long grass for some time.
How would UKIP respond to such a result? The problem with fixed-term parliaments is that the following general election would not be held until May 7th 2020. It almost goes without saying that a lot could happen between now and then – either the Conservatives or Labour will have lost 2015 election and will almost certainly select a new leader, which will alter the context of political debate significantly.
The Lib Dems may defy expectations and do better than expected, but it is more likely than not that Nick Clegg will have moved on. The next parliament may see an EU referendum, the results of which would clearly have consequences for UKIP’s existence.
UKIP, if it is to achieve any of its goals, has to manage its expectations for next May. They may win seats, but our election system is not designed to be accommodating to challengers outside the established system. Sustaining momentum beyond such a result is possible, for example mobilising the party around a potential EU referendum. But it will be a real challenge – and much more difficult than success at any election in 2014.
Illustration: European Parliament

