Zelensky ends Russian monopoly over European gas flow

By Waseem Mohamed

8am, New Year’s Day. In Ukraine, the sound of Russian-supplied gas flowing through the Urengoy-Pomary-Uzhgorod pipeline suddenly ceases. The five-year agreement between the two warring nations, allowing Russia to supply their gas via Ukrainian pipelines, has not been renewed. The era of Russian dominance over the EU energy market is now over.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, who long-signaled that he would not be renewing the transit agreement, hailed the move as “one of Moscow’s biggest defeats”. It is hoped the move will deprive Russia of critical revenue it could use to fund its ongoing war effort in the region, with estimates predicting that Russia’s state-owned energy company Gazprom could lose up to â‚¬5 billion per year. 

But it is a decision fraught with risks. Ukraine is predicted to lose around €1 billion a year in transit fees by not renewing the agreement. And aside from financial losses, the move could have a major destabilising effect across Eastern Europe, with several countries already expressing their discontent over Zelensky’s actions. 

For most EU countries, the termination of Russian gas supplies via Ukraine was not a surprise. The share of Russian gas imports in the European market has already plummeted from 35% in February 2022 to just 8% last year. EU countries frantically sought to diversify their energy sources and end the cycle of dependency on Russian gas supplies amid growing unease that Russia was using the EU’s dependency for political leverage. 

However, a few remaining EU countries – namely Austria, Slovakia and Hungary – still relied on Russian gas supplied via Ukraine for their energy needs. With the transit agreement now over, these countries have been forced to find alternative energy sources which they have achieved to varying degrees. Austria’s energy regulator said the country was already well-prepared for the switch, while Hungary will still get its fix of Russian gas through an alternative pipeline in the Black Sea. 

It is hoped the move will deprive Russia of critical revenue it could use to fund its ongoing war effort in the region

Slovakia meanwhile is less than impressed with Ukraine. Speaking after the agreement was terminated, Prime Minister Robert Fico said the decision would have “a drastic impact” on the EU, but not Russia. The PM, who is friendly with Russian President Vladmir Putin, warned he would take “reciprocal measures” against Ukraine if the agreement is not renewed, a marked departure in tone from other EU leaders who see Zelenskyy’s decision more as a “victory”. 

But outside the EU bubble, the fallout has already begun. Transnistria, a Russian-backed separatist region that straddles the Ukrainian border in Moldova, experienced almost immediate energy blackouts when the transit agreement ended. As homes and businesses struggled without heating and power, the regional president assured citizens that a “societal collapse” would not be allowed to happen, amid fears of a humanitarian crisis.

Russia’s seeming unwillingness to support Transnistria with its energy blackouts raises serious questions on its intentions in the region. Following a tight referendum in October when Moldvans voted to change the Constitution to align the country with the West, abandoning Transnistria would be a strange move for Russia who have used the region to exert its influence in its former Soviet territories. 

But while local citizens seem adamant that Russia would never abandon a region dependent on its gas supplies, the Moldovan Prime Minister Dorian Recean accused Russia of using “energy as a political weapon” to “blackmail” the region into succumbing to Russian influence. Whatever Russia’s intentions for Transnistria are, right now the region must somehow survive its acute energy crisis and rely on expensive energy alternatives.

For the rest of Europe, the termination of the Russia-Ukraine transit agreement will have a minimal impact on energy consumption. EU countries have long been prepared for the end of Russian gas imports, and the spiralling energy costs seen in 2022 are unlikely to be repeated. But the move has been met with an immediate energy crisis in Moldova and discontent in the EU’s Russian-friendly members, both threatening to destabilise the continent’s otherwise unwavering commitment to supporting Ukraine. 

Image: The Presidential Office of Ukraine/ Wikimedia commons