‘You are not a beautiful or unique snowflake’: best movie antiheroes

We asked our writers to pick the best antiheroes from the world of film. Here are the results, with spoilers…

Photo: Orion
Photo: Orion

Hannibal Lecter – The Silence of the Lambs

Not the calculating, remorseless villain portrayed by Mads Mikkelsen in NBC’s Hannibal TV series, but Antony Hopkins’ big screen depiction of the classic character – a brilliant psychiatrist who happens to have a taste for human flesh. Hopkins only appears for 15 minutes in 1991’s The Silence of the Lambs, but his performance is so captivating that his presence casts a shadow over the entire movie (an effect reflected by the controversial decision to award him an Oscar for Best Actor in a Leading Role). Much of Lecter’s chillingly delivered dialogue has pervaded popular culture, and perhaps his whole character – cultured, intellectually formidable, blackly comic and utterly unnerving – is summed up in the warning to Clarice: ‘A census taker once tried to test me. I ate his liver, with some fava beans and a nice chianti.’

Hannibal Lecter topped AFI’s ‘100 Years 100 Villains’ list. So why is he an antihero? Often the films see him enlisted to help defeat an even greater psychopath. Silence’s Buffalo Bill is even more unhinged and terrifying than Lecter, whilst sequel Hannibal saw him pitted against Gary Oldman’s disfigured child rapist Mason Verger. However terrible Lecter’s crimes (the former film depicts the gruesome murder of several police officers during a daring prison escape), his role of villain is subordinated and complicated by the larger threats that he assists in bringing down.

Lecter’s relationships with Clarice Starling (The Silence of the Lambs, Hannibal) and to an extent Will Graham (Manhunter, Red Dragon) also merit his inclusion on this list. Each partnership is marked by a strange affinity, as if the protagonists, despite the man’s history and their own personal demons, manage to form an emotional connection with Lecter defined by more than just mutual respect. To the testament of the chemistry of the actors involved, these troubled characters are humanised, and the filmmakers expertly keep audiences toeing a fine line between repulsion and a degree of sympathy.

Lecter’s character would descend into silliness with sequels of diminishing quality, where his love for Clarice was made explicit, and camp horror scenes would see him fry and feed victims parts of their own brains. However, the antagonist of Silence of the Lambs remains a sublime, immortal antihero.

By Jonathan Peters

Photo: 20th Century Fox
Photo: 20th Century Fox

Keyser Soze – The Usual Suspects

The 1995 crime thriller The Usual Suspects has long been regarded as an iconic film, and its lead antagonist has been etched into film folklore, as well as the minds of the millions who still remember Keyser Soze.

The most remarkable fact about Keyser Soze is the fact that he is entirely fictional. In reality he was the creation of the somewhat unremarkable con artist Roger “Verbal” Kint, played by Kevin Spacey, who received an Academy Award for his portrayal. Kint, who famously ‘suffered’ from Cerebral Palsy, creates an elaborate story implicating Soze as a ruthless crime lord, as well as the perpetrator of the murder of dozens of gang members in the film’s climactic scenes.

In reality, Kint had fabricated the story using prompts, such as the names of businesses and cards on the bulletin board in the police detective’s office where he was interrogated. He was released, before the police realised his fabrication, and walked out of the police station with his ‘disability’ magically cured, escaping his punishment for the crimes he committed throughout the film.

The simplistic genius of a criminal to completely fool the police, creating a character that was so heinous that it captured the imagination of the gullible police detective, thus taking the heat and scrutiny from Kint, the actual perpetrator, makes The Usual Suspects a classic film and Keyser Soze an infamous antihero.

Spacey’s engrossing portrayal, coupled with the film’s famous final scenes, etched Keyser Soze into iconic film status. As Kint stated, ‘the greatest trick the devil ever pulled was convincing the world he didn’t exist’, and Keyser Soze may go down as the greatest antihero never to have existed.

By Benjamin Lee

Photo: 20th Century Fox
Photo: 20th Century Fox

Tyler Durden – Fight Club

Tyler Durden of Fight Club, or at least in the form of his alter-ego Brad Pitt, is the ultimate antihero for our late capitalist society. While the boring old Edward Norton-Tyler wonders which Ikea furniture will help define him, the Brad Pitt-Tyler is out there destroying the consumer culture which has infiltrated every aspect of our lives (Fun fact: According to director David Fincher, there is a Starbucks cup present in every shot in the film). His philosophy is simple, damning ‘the man’ who has us ‘working jobs we hate so we can buy s**t we don’t need’.  But don’t go thinking Tyler is a do-gooder out to rescue us from this mindless consumption; Tyler has unknowingly created ‘Project Mayhem’, a group committed to an equally mindless anarchy, placing him firmly on the darker side of heroism.

All the usual features of the anti-hero are present: the egoism, the charisma and a complete amorality. Yes, he may be the product of a schizophrenic with a multiple personality disorder, but he earns his place as a classic antihero by his rejection of consumer values which we all adhere to without quite knowing why. Destroying the credit card companies’ records and setting the debt to zero is one of the more altruistic crimes one can imagine, even if you wouldn’t exactly want to be his best friend. If nothing else, Tyler Durden helps us to question what we automatically accept, by being the embodiment of what the everyman subconsciously desires to be. The fight club of Fight Club allows the characters to really feel something; it may not help them in any way, but it is this aggressive if fruitless attitude which really connects with the audience. Tyler is undoubtedly the Monday morning of anti-heroes, a poster-boy for the reaction against the nine-to-five job. Not to mention the cult film brought us Brad Pitt in that pink dressing gown.

By Caroline France