Working hard or hardly working?

Picture for working hard or hardly working

By Hannah Sims

It’s not fresh news that Italy’s economy has overstepped the red line of stability and is quietly collapsing. Indeed, international financial contagion, unemployment, relative poverty and rising debt are just a few of Italy’s sniffles.

Now I’m no economist – far from it – and to be quite honest, I don’t really understand the financial crisis at all. Does anybody? But what I do know is that the most direct road to economic growth is the road of productivity. Efficiently produce lots, sell lots, make lots of profit and then use the profit to advance. It’s that simple, right?

Maybe not. Since arriving in Siena, it’s become clear to me that Italy’s road to productivity is obstructed by a nasty speed bump – their seemingly unindustrious and reluctant attitude towards work. Fun and games are very much starters on the menu for an Italian day, with pleasure as an indulgent main course option and the idea of work remaining a sweet afterthought, hidden on a separate menu only for those who specifically ask for it.

So is it any surprise that Italy is experiencing such a bumpy ride?

“The traditional Italian mentality not of working hard, but of hardly working”

Of course you cannot ignore irresponsible ruling, corrupt fiscal systems and illicit underground activity as contributing factors, adding further complexity to the problem or extra height to the speed bump if you like. However, what firmly remains, cementing the ramp to the tarmac, is the traditional Italian mentality not of working hard, but of hardly working.

And this dragon of indolence rears its ugly head at every level of Italian society. Indeed, their lax education system seems to breed idleness. Supposedly two hour-long lectures often start late, following a mass migration of the always unexpectedly and alarmingly enormous class to a different classroom. An hour and a half later they finish, with a crucial ‘five minute’ break half way through, allowing everyone, including the lecturer, to take fifteen minutes or so to boost their nicotine and caffeine levels.

The Italian service industries are no better either. The shopkeepers open and close when they please, leaving an English girl accustomed to the reliability of a nine-to-five schedule completely lost! The only thing you can be sure of is that everywhere will shut at any sign of adverse weather – heaven forbid someone might walk onto their white tiled floor with wet shoes.

This idleness even extends to family life, as my friend explained to me yesterday. A long-standing element of Italian culture is the apparent inability of young men, or ‘bamboccioni’ as they have recently been dubbed (literally ‘overgrown male babies’), to fly the nest and leave the home comforts of mamma mia, preferring instead to sponge from their parents until their late 30s.

But, as a student, I have to hand it to them…the Italians know how to let their hair down. Their hedonistic and relaxed lifestyle of smoking weed by day and drinking (and smoking more weed) by night, certainly represents their free-spirited and liberal attitudes.

However, if you want to live such a flamboyant lifestyle you must be able to pay for it. That requires a job (un lavoro), employment (impiego), and hard work (no direct translation). If you cannot pay for it, you must find someone else who is willing to do so. Borrow, borrow, borrow. And that is the problem.

Perhaps it could take a Mussolini-style dictatorship to give them the kick up the backside they need? Or have I just been spending too much time with my extremist roommate? Whatever the case, something in the Italian culture has to change in order for the country to re-establish its economic potential and haul itself out of the hole in which it is trapped. Something drastic.

Photographs: Hannah Sims