Women in writing: A man’s world
By Oluwamodupe Daramola
Whitney Reynolds recently asked the women of Twitter to write themselves as a male writer would describe them. The results were akin to characterisations of celebrities in fanfiction, and although they were hilarious, they were echoes of centuries of badly written female characters.
The general characterisation of women in male-authored novels is weak, needy and requiring protection. The most popular book in the world with such blatant portrayal of this is the Bible- and yes, written by men. Successful novelists and playwrights who have accurately penned down a female character are, for example: Jon Robin Baitz and Richard Greenberg. So do men really have an built-in defect writing women? If the few can do it, why is it the majority who fail to even glimpse into the female psyche time and time again?
echoes of centuries of badly written female characters.
Some reports have shown readers believing that ‘all male writers get female characters wrong’. There is often no realistic depiction of a woman in several classics: Anna Karenina, Tess of D’Urbervilles, to name but a few. Consideration of the fact that writing across gender can be difficult, but why is it that women manage to write male characters accurately with much more frequency?
Although some men, in this case through screenwriting, have successfully given audiences a true representation of a woman: Joss Whedon with Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Her character is in many ways, the ordinary and commonly portrayed girl who cares about her hair and likes to go shopping. Unusually, she has the physical capabilities that are not commonly associated with women- she kills vampires. There is also more to her than being the “stereotypical girl” we see portrayed so often; she struggles with schoolwork, dating, an absent father, has to figure out how to pay for electricity and she sometimes hates her own life. Which is something very close to what the everyday average female goes through.
why is it that women manage to write male characters accurately with much more frequency?
Joss Whedon was realistic with her character, he made her a simple ordinary person, a person made up of different emotions and strengths including weaknesses. This is often what is so important with writing female characters, the inclusion of weaknesses, but showing they have other, more important characteristics, like a normal human being. His infusion of reality is the main reason why Buffy is one of the well written female characters ever.
Does the initial issue however, come from a lifetime of female disempowerment?
Women do not have to be good or moral or pure. They don’t have to be the one who brings logic back into the room. A good character in a novel will be more than society’s conception of that particular gender. She will have both weaknesses and strengths, have the freedom to be sexually liberated without some ‘doomed consequence’ waiting for her, like we see in Leo Tolstoy’s Anna Karenina.
‘male anxiety wrapped in a vagina’
Sometimes this is done for comical purposes, but there are deeper issues and complications in the portrayal of women as needy and weak. Many young women learn to succumb to these writer’s judgements without having a thought of their own. Anna Szymanski, Feminist Finance Writer, posted in her article reading Tolstoy, Twain, Dickens and the likes she found ‘male anxiety wrapped in a vagina’. She summarises that it is unfair for a woman to learn what it is to be a woman by reading men who didn’t appreciate or like women that much. Her suggested solution to the issue was ‘leaving a few Dickens novels off the syllabus in favour of some Virginia Woolf’.
Literary Critic Sarah Seltzer stated that although writing across gender is difficult, but attempts should be made at understanding, empathizing and inhabiting the soul of someone whose life experience is not ours. This should make men become better novelists, she argues. Although this is true, it’s tiring to see a male in the mainstream media taking a voice away from a woman. Men writing women’s voices would not be an issue, only if women had not been prevented from doing so for so long.
Photograph: Gage Skidmore via Wikimedia Commons
