Women are driving the search for life on Venus
By Caitlin Painter
As discussed recently in Palatinate, phosphine gas has been detected in the clouds of Venus, suggesting the possibility of life.
This research was led by Professor Jane Greaves of Cardiff University, who, as an advocate for fairness to women in academia and a prominent figure in astronomical research, has had a hugely successful career. She was awarded the Institute of Physics Fred Hoyle Medal in 2017 for her “significant contribution to our understanding of planet formation and exoplanet habitability”. However, this discovery may not have come to light without the perseverance of Professor Greaves in the face of what is still a male-dominated field of science.
Venus had previously been ignored as a candidate for life in the Solar System
For years, scientists have ruled out Venus as a possible planet to harbour life; NASA described it as “an unlikely place for life as we know it”. With surface temperatures of around 460°C and atmospheric pressure over 90 times that at sea-level on Earth, not to mention clouds of sulfuric acid, it is easy to see why Venus had previously been ignored in this search.
On Earth, phosphine gas can only be produced naturally during anaerobic decay, making it an excellent marker of life. Using the James Clerk Maxwell Telescope (JCMT) in Hawaii, Greaves discovered the presence of phosphine in the atmosphere of Venus by analysing the absorption spectrum and identifying a dip in frequency that could only be caused by phosphine.
Phosphine gas is stable for only a matter of hours in the atmosphere, but Greaves was observing a constant production of it. This is not necessarily indicative of life on Venus, due to the possibility that chemical processes unknown on Earth could be responsible for producing the gas.
In a world where academic science research is dominated by males, the influence of a female-led research project of this scale is hugely important
Further telescope time was needed for Greaves to be sure that it was phosphine being detected, so she requested time with ALMA, a radio telescope array located in Chile. In an interview for the BBC’s The Sky at Night, Greaves describes the difficulty she faced in securing the extra time she needed and that her proposal was perceived as “eccentric”. After four requests, she was able to use ALMA to observe the same result found using the JCMT.
At the National Astronomy Meeting held in 2019, Greaves spoke about prestige bias concerning telescope time allocation. She presented data showing that the lead researchers for projects were more likely to be given time with a high-profile telescope if they were male.
Greaves’ perseverance in securing time with ALMA meant she was able to validate her results.
At Durham, only 22% of physics undergraduates are female
In a world where academic science research is dominated by males, the influence of a female-led research project of this scale is hugely important. Greaves describes her discovery as a “life-changing moment” for herself, yet the potential impact she could have on young female scientists is even greater.
In her biography for her current role as Professor of Astronomy, Greaves says she has “worked extensively for fairness towards women in academic science”. Physics has one of the largest gender gaps out of all STEM subjects, and a report conducted by the American Institute of Physics found that 19% of astronomy faculty members are women.
According to STEM Women, only 23% of A-Level Physics students in 2019 were female, a statistic that is reflected higher up in universities. At Durham, only 22% of physics undergraduates in the last academic year were female.
Greaves has worked extensively for fairness towards women
Not only has Greaves started one of the first plausible searches for extra-terrestrial life, she has also put her name on the map as an inspirational woman in STEM. To determine whether or not she has discovered life on Venus, Greaves states that the next step would be to get funding for a spacecraft mission to fly through Venus’ atmosphere to collect and analyse samples.
It would be extraordinary to find conclusive evidence of life on Venus, and more extraordinary still to find that it had evolved independently from that on Earth. Such a discovery would certainly go down as one of the greatest moments in history – with Professor Jane Greaves’ name forever attached.
Image: The European Southern Observatory via Flickr
