Witless: Your Next Favourite Band
In the start of a new interview series, Matthew Prudham talks to student band Witless, made up of vocalist Flynn-Faith Crothers (FFC), guitarist Jem Salmon, Alex-Harvey Vyse (AHV) on keys and sax, Erin Cacace on bass, and Cameron Weston (CW) on drums.
You guys popped out of nowhere in February last year – how did the band form and end up grabbing all these battle of the bands by the scruff of the neck?
We were all Mary’s freshers last year – four of us on the same corridor – Alex and Cam started jamming together, and so did Jem and Flynn– and then we eventually found out that Erin played bass, and then by around the end of first term we were practising together. We found an overlap in the same niche of 80s rock. We decided to enter battle of a bands as a kind of joke, we’d had a lot of fun with rehearsals and we thought we might as well. Our first four gigs were actually at Van Mildert, with two formals, the battle of the bands, and a bingo, which was class.
I saw you live for the first time at the Durham for Refugees festival back in June and your mixes of songs were so impressive – how do you go about devising these?
JS: That came out of me being unable to play the end of “Sweet Child of Mine”, I was thinking ‘how do we end this?’ and I was making stuff up, and then Cameron came in with the beat for Billie Jean, which actually works.
CW: This is when the audience switches off, when you have a gap between songs.
JS: It also hasn’t worked in the past… we tried to mash Rockstar (Nickleback), Old Town Road (Lil Nas X) and Boulevard of Broken Dreams (Green Day)…
FFC: Also the fact we were really drunk the only time we did it didn’t especially help.
JS: It came out once and most likely never again.
I’m trying to figure out how that would work…
JS: We came up with it on the day of the gig, but it got no response whatsoever from the crowd… We’ll try anything – some work and some don’t.
What has been the best event you’ve played so far?
JS: We we’re talking about this recently…
CW: I’d say personally it’s been Mary’s Day.
JS: Mary’s day was huge, there were so many people in the audience that we knew.
CW: The best gigs are when people in the crowd know us – we’ve just done two 21sts which were really good – because you can talk absolute rubbish, make loads of mistakes and people still love you all the more. With gigs it takes one or two people to start dancing before everyone joins in – but if you know people there they’ll be more invested – and they start and others join in
Are there any coming up that you’re particularly looking forward to?
JS: We have Mary’s ball, Castle Ladies Night…
FFC: Charging more for gigs…(laughs)
JS: There’s a few potentials there too… anything that comes up really!
CW: We have a potential collaboration on our minds too.
JS: We realised last year at balls etc. that a lot of bands would be playing the same events – us, OddSocks, the Quays – and we’d love to mix it up a bit. There’s exciting things to come.

What vibes should people expect from a Witless set?
JS: Fun, us not taking ourselves too seriously
FFC: We kinda started out as a joke, don’t know what we’re doing.
AHV: There’s a few 80s rock tunes, then a couple of me-me club tunes… then a couple of slower ballads.
CW: Also a couple of harder rock songs.
JS: I’d say it’s Klute on stage – like SNK on stage to some extent…
FFC: We’re gonna rename ourselves as “Klute – the Band” (laughs)
CW: No one’s gonna come to our gigs anymore!
JS: There is a bit of that – usually after we’ve done some more serious songs.
AHV: Open with some rock…
CW: You could say it’s the banter that plays into parts of the set.
JS: A solid mix of rock/pop.
You say on your socials that you are a cover band – are any of you interested in writing your own music?
JS: There are things in the works…
AHV: We’ve tried but coming up with words is often harder than coming up with tunes. We often have stuff that sounds good, work on it a bit and make it its own track, and then not perform it cos the words are too cheesy or we can’t think of any…
Do you think that Durham students want to hear the same songs over and over again? Do you ever feel pressurised into playing songs you don’t particularly want to, just as it’s considered a must?
CW: There are some songs that we’ve dropped due to the crowd reaction – if the crowd doesn’t especially enjoy/know it, then they’ll mill off. To an extent it’s more important if we ourselves enjoy it.
JS: There are ones where we get a good reaction, and then we’ll keep them – we’re constantly adding stuff to the setlist, so there’s going to be a constant mixture of ones that we know the crowd will react well too, and new ones we want to play. Keep it fresh and exciting.
CW: 90% of our group chat is songs being suggested – ‘oh we should do this…’ then they get shot down quickly.
CW: So, after days of that, we do narrow it down. We’ll all chuck out songs that we like – it comes down to is it realistic for our set up to perform them, and can we perform them well. Sometimes it is difficult as we all listen to slightly different genres JS: And there’s always jam content in rehearsals that will never make it on stage.
OddSocks did something few Durham bands do and put on their own independent gig in The Library. Would you consider doing something similar now you have a rather large following?
JS: Absolutely. I think we’d get the support and then see. We’ve invested in our own PA and we’re building that up so we can actually have enough equipment ourselves to perform live and do our own setups. It’s coming.
CW: The difficulty is in knowing how many people actually know who you are – everyone knows who OddSocks are…
JS: It has happened quickly too – our first gig was in what, February and now it’s November – and there was that lot summer break when we’re not together – 20 weeks we’ve been playing together and we’ve done 21 gigs – that’s more than a gig a week.
CW: The venues are quite limited in terms of where you can perform. You’ve got the Library, you’ve got Fabio’s, I know the Funkhaus Collective did a gig at Cafedral…
JS: We just need to reach out really – we can definitely do it, it’s just about finding the time to sort it out.
AHV: Then at our own gigs, we can do the tracks we really love rather than crowdpleasers.
Flynn’s voice is so alluring, reminiscent of Lorde or Lana Del Rey in its tone – do you find it particularly refreshing giving a female vocal remake to some of your songs?
AHV: I know Flynn loves the Chilli Peppers.
JS: I am confident that whatever we give Flynn she’ll have a good go at it.
FFC: I mean anything’s fine, a song’s a song.
JS: We just throw anything at you, if I make a suggestion I generally don’t take into consideration whether its male or female.
FFC: I guess bands with guys who sing rock songs aren’t that good at it sometimes – it’s nice to do something different.
JS: Flynn’s got a punchy voice. Songs with high male registers suit Flynn’s voice more than one of ours – we don’t sing that well… The OddSocks’ singer is a lad with a very high range and he can get that stuff.
FFC: Whereas I have quite a low voice so it doesn’t really matter.
JS: I mean it’s like AC/DC, Guns n Roses, that kinda stuff that works well – maybe not quite as screechy but she can hit the notes.
We’re still, unfortunately, in the age where men make up the majority of bands and band members, and I’m glad to see this isn’t the case here – what would you say to girls unsure about starting a band?
FFC: Yeah, I mean there’s a lot of girls that like that kind of music, it’s not an exclusively male thing. For me – is rock music my favourite genre? No, but I’m good at singing it – so why not? What is there to loose? There’s so many boys who sing it, who are shit and think they’re good, it’s nice if you are girl and you can sing it well – just do it.
You’re all only in second year, so what do you think the future holds for the band?
JS: More gigs hopefully. Setting out our own sort of stuff, putting out our own music, we’ve looked at recording places too – record some stuff and get it out there. Band gap year after uni…
CW: Definitely as a band, in the close future we love play colleges and student events, but we are quite keen to move a little bit out of the sphere…
I know Autoflourensce did a gig in Newcastle last year, finally getting themselves up to that level where they were known enough to say that “we’re from Durham”, and not get poo-pooed.
JS: I think part of it is to not care if we’re only playing to 5 people. It’s not a terrible place to start. Just to get that practice and if those 5 people go away and think we’re really good, they’ll go and tell their other mates. We’ve been in contact with Hotel Indigo, there’s some scope for us playing NYE there.
That’d be swanky… lots of people in suits…
CW: Don’t know how well Nirvana would go down.
JS: I mean, a lot of the music is their generation…
Finally, what is your favourite song to play live?
JS: Probably different for all of us. “Blow”, the new Ed Sheeran one, that’s good.
FFC: For me, “Versace on the Dancefloor” cos it’s just a banger.
CW: I quite like Florence’s “You’ve Got the Love” – I quite like that as you can mess around it a lot.
Witless play a variety of gigs, balls and events throughout the year.
www.facebook.com/witlessfive
@witlessofficial.
Image by Izzy Simpson
