With Chad’s JCR emboiled in scandal, Palatinate asks “Is Pool a real sport?”
The highlight of the Durham University Cue Sports season, the BUCS UPC 8 ball Championships, takes place on 24-27th February in Great Yarmouth, Norfolk. Durham University has a rich history in this tournament. Indeed so much so it makes pool arguably the most successful BUCS sport played at our university! Since 2005, Durham University have won multiple trophies, have had 8 players representing England, and in one year 10 players contributed 4% of the entire BUCS points won by Durham University. That’s insane, but unsurprising. Our unique collegiate system provides the potential for the substantial competitive leagues and competitions that most other universities could only dream of. These leagues and competitions are provided by the DUPL (Durham University Pool League), and as ex-Durham University captain Danny Williamson, who also represented England, says, “What sets Durham apart is that we consistently remain at the top of the national game, even when exceptionally gifted players leave. The type of game and general level that DUPL provides to the grassroots consistently provides players to form teams that compete at the highest standard.”
So why is it that so many at Durham refuse to see pool as a proper sport, despite its BUCS status, and our university’s proud tradition in this discipline? Furthermore, why do Chad’s JCR treat pool with such utter disdain that they refuse to regulate it like their other sports, even though, as is well documented above, playing collegiate pool is how most players learn their craft for the university team?
Let’s start by assessing the sole argument for pool not being a proper sport. That is, that it requires limited aerobic activity, and is played in a bar by players with a pint of beer in one hand, and their cue in the other. I recognise why the latter part of the argument is made. Despite its early origins being surprisingly grand – it was played by Louis XIV, Mary Queen of Scots and Mozart – the image conjured up of the game is one of smoke-filled rooms and illicit gambling. Pool is also incredibly popular and accessible, and the results obtained appear almost random to the beginner, like a coin toss. However, the fact that most people’s first exposure to pool is in a bar or a pub after a few drinks belies the technical and tactical complexity of the game, and most who play barely scratch the surface of what can actually be achieved. More than that, even those with awesome potting ability often have such scant knowledge of fundamental tactics and cue ball control that they can be easily beaten by just about anyone with basic knowledge of the game. Pool at a higher level is often referred to as “chess with balls”, but it also requires immense technical ability that won’t crack under pressure. Good co-ordination is needed for maintaining optimal alignment of stance, wrist, arm and cue throughout the cue-action, and without this basic foundation in their technique players will find it very difficult to execute the kind of cue-ball control needed to excel in shots requiring drag, reverse side, check side and stun run through especially.
Unfortunately, despite the immense technical and tactical abilities required, as explained above, the game of pool does not require much in the way of aerobic activity. But then again, luminary figures in the world of cricket, which is respected as a sport, have excelled without inducing much in the way of breathlessness; for example the rotund Mike Gatting, and Phil Tufnell, who had an aversion to almost everything that didn’t require drinking or smoking, turned in highly respectable performances for England. The BBC Sports Personality of the Year runner-up for 2010 was Phil “The Power” Taylor, a beer-chugging darts player, so maybe times are changing. The eminent sociologist Jay Coakley defines sports as “institutionalized competitive activities that involve vigorous physical exertion OR the use of relatively complex physical skills by individuals whose participation is motivated by a combination of personal enjoyment and external rewards” (Sport in Society, 6th Edition, 1998, p.19). Pool may lack the “vigorous physical exertion”, but it more than makes up for it by requiring “complex physical skills”. Perhaps not all of us pool players have the physiques to be beddable, but that doesn’t mean we don’t play a proper sport!
As for the Chad’s JCR, and unlike every other college in Durham, they have refused to enforce trials for their pool teams, despite a promise of this being sent round on October 27th. With Chad’s pool, membership is NOT based on merit. Instead, a tradition of invitation, which is usually based on drinking, friendship groups and not being female, holds firm. Apart from being inherently sexist, I think it is outrageous that there are many in Chad’s College who are unable to fulfil their potential, and potentially represent the university team, because of it. Indeed, as a current member of Chad’s College myself, but unable to represent them in the pool league due to the reasons above, I was told in no uncertain terms by the Durham University Cue Sports Captain, Si Alderton, that, as Chad’s was no longer a possibility, I had to represent a different college (Grey College, a previous college of mine) in the DUPL, in order to represent the university. (In the year 2009/10, I represented the Div1 winners Grey A and Durham University.) This was then backed up by the current DUPL President and university player, Alex Wort, who said “Si was absolutely correct that for your game to progress in a one frame format [the same format as used at university level] there was no real substitute for playing college pool, and correctly advised you to play for Grey”. I empathise with this virtual echo of Danny Williamson’s point. The DUPL really does provide the sole opportunity for us to develop the temperament required for the pressure situations that arise in single frame competitive pool.
Therefore, in order to highlight the injustice of the situation that exists at Chad’s, and after all diplomatic channels were exhausted, I set out to prove my point. Against my ardent desire to play for Chad’s, and on 8th December, I began playing for Grey, in order to confirm my place on the university team. On 23rd January, I was sent an email by Si, confirming my place as captain of the Durham University 3rd team. On 26th January, I deliberately sabotaged a match involving Grey A and Collingwood A. I’m not proud of the lengths I went to, but I did manage to get myself banned from the Grey A team. As a result of this action, I was banned, as expected, from the Durham University team also. I went down this route because not everyone is fortunate enough to be parachuted into a different college team, and to emphasise the point: by refusing to enforce Chad’s to pick a team on merit, the DUPL are excluding Chad’s members from university pool.
Back in October, Team Durham told me that they didn’t want to get involved in DUPL issues, but I hope that the above has proved the point I have always made: the DUPL and the Durham University Cue Sports team are inextricably linked. I have always represented my university with dignity and pride, and yet I have been banned from the Team Durham university side for DUPL issues – misbehaving in a college match, because I was unable to represent my college Chad’s, and not playing for Chad’s. This is not just about me. It is about future Chadsians, and restriction of opportunity. There is no doubt that I have ruined previous friendships to make my point, but I want to do my bit to ensure that, in the future, opportunities in pool are open to all, irrespective of college. I know I have the support of Dr Cassidy (Chad’s College Principal) and Dr Masson (Chad’s College Senior Tutor) that pool should be based on merit. If the DUPL President believes, as he did on the 27th January, that it is “not a feasible option” for Chad’s to have a college team based on merit in the DUPL, then I hope that the non-student bodies at Team Durham and Chad’s College will act to ensure it is, in order to restore and safeguard the reputation of sport at Chad’s College and Durham University as a whole. Due to my passionate campaigning, I may be disliked and portrayed as a firebrand by many, but the ad hominem attacks won’t wash. This is not a popularity contest; it is a point of principle. It’s now time for change. The talking must stop and the action must start.

