Wine bar theory: a winning business formula

David Gilbertson’s rule 28 on thriving in the business world is to Enjoy
David Gilbertson’s rule 28 on thriving in the business world is to enjoy

By Richard Morgan

With the end of exams come two distinct forms of freedom for Durham students.

There is that first freedom of being able to watch as many movies as we want without consequence, eat what we want and party all night long.

But after the first week, a different kind of freedom sets upon Durham students; a three-month period before we all come back to University for another year of learning.

In this time, we can intern, get jobs, travel the world or we could take the road less travelled, and become entrepreneurs.

David Gilbertson’s new book, Wine Bar Theory aims to encourage students to do just that. Using his over 30 years of experience in the top flight business world, he provides simple rules to open our eyes to the business world so that we do not have to learn the hard way.

After an insightful interview with the man himself, a key piece of advice offered was, “Not to try and avoid making mistakes” but to make sure you never make the same mistake twice.

Very true and often forgotten. According to Mr Gilbertson, the reason why we should take risks is that, “the world is a moving game, we always have another day to put things right.”

However, if being an entrepreneur is not your destiny, Mr Gilbertson also divulged some excellent advice on how to shine in a company’s team.

He stressed, “making sure you ask questions so you understand how you fit in to the overall picture.” This allows you to go beyond your role in the company and it shows that you are willing to go the extra mile.

Rule 26 and 27 of the book are centered on manners being crucial in business. Mr Gilbertson again stress how, “basic politeness, funnily enough, makes you stand out.” This works regardless of whether it is a supplier you are bargaining with or co-workers.

Mr Gilbertson recognises that the best employers are the ones that require evidence of success from their recruits. If it is a business that buys a persuasive sales pitch from a recruit then they are taking risks to the future success of their company.

The same is true for managers who fear hiring people who are as good or better than them. That is why a mantra of allowing homegrown talent to move up the company when ready is important for motivation and the business has better understanding of the person rather than hiring externally.

Perhaps the most important tool in the arsenal of any good entrepreneur is found in Rule 2: ‘Keep it simple.’ This is achieved through understanding. Whether it is your market, your customers or a complex idea. Understanding allows you to convey a message in a condensed way that appeals to the world.

Mr Gilbertson also emphasises the importance of ‘belief’ in Rule 4. In the book he makes it clear that, “belief and judgment can prove to be wrong of course, but they are much more likely to succeed than hope and luck.”

The way to tell whether you have genuine belief in a product or idea is to answer some honest questions to yourself. All of this, of course, is explained in the book.

Perhaps this key personal ingredient of belief can be found through the key business ingredient: distinction.

According to Mr Gilbertson, this distinction does not have to be some grand new invention, but something that simply separates your product from the competition. President Kennedy is quoted in the book as saying; “conformity is the jailer of freedom and the enemy of growth.”

Clearly, the message Mr Gilbertson hopes to express is that being unique is the only way that you can take on the big boys and their established markets share in any industry.

One simple way to do this is to beat them in customer service.

This is area most large companies neglect and is an area newcomers are primed to distinguish themselves on. Whatever distinction you choose, Mr Gilbertson says it’s got to be, “something your customers don’t have which would be valuable to them”.

At the same time, there is often general scepticism towards starting a business. However, Mr Gilbertson states that there has never been a better time for starting a business because of technology. It gives anyone the potential to create international business almost overnight thanks to the Internet and social media.

These devices mean there is more opportunity than ever before and that the brand association can often be defeated. It is not as risky as it once was because huge amounts of money do not have to be spent on marketing. He also advises that the focus should be on increasing revenue as this produces the most profit in the long run, over cutting costs for greater profit now.

Mr Gilbertson’s message is not just one about how to make it in business. It is about how to stay there. And this is done by constantly moving forwards, pursuing innovative ways to stay ahead of the curve and constantly, do this questioning what can be done to improve.

He acknowledges, “You can use the inspiring things other people are doing as a launchpad”. However, there must be a distinction between what you do and what they do because otherwise you will always be one step behind.

“If you make the mistake of standing still, in a constantly changing world you get left behind.” How you discover whether something is working or will work falls under Rule 12: ‘Don’t guess.’  This means rigorous market testing to find out how customers feel about a product and what they feel could be improved upon.

Overall,  ‘Wine Bar Theory’’ has some sage advice that even the big companies often forget: work smarter not harder. Mr. Gilbertson says,  “There are some businesses that confuse busy with effective.”

Businesses working around the clock simply have too few resources and so as a consequence are being used ineffectively. Mr Gilbertson believes people need to push themselves, but in an efficient way and stop when it is time to stop.

The companies that work best according to Mr Gilbertson are those that make people responsible and do not simply allow people to make a contribution and go home. Therefore, as we enter the summer break we should keep our minds open.

Maybe we do not start that new business up this holiday.  Hopefully we will read Mr Gilbertson’s book and have the entrepreneurial way of thinking on our minds, so that when we do get the hunger to begin an entrepreneurial adventure, we do so with fire in our bellies and not with fear in our hearts.

Illustration: Bill Butcher

‘Wine Bar Theory’ by David Gilbertson is available on Amazon and iTunes, and in Waterstones