Windows 8: a hands-on review

Windows8

By Jonny Bowers

I recently bought myself a brand spanking new computer. That’s right, I called it a computer. Whilst the rest of the world moves to ever smaller netbooks and tablets, I’ve taken a step back into the nineties and taken advantage of the current prices of the old style desktop along with the two monitors hidden away in the garage to make myself a cheap alternative to a laptop perfect for double screened revision.

The new computer came with Microsoft’s latest offering of operating system; Windows 8. The system claims high levels of user-friendliness along with speed and security. It is based around a completely new start screen being the centrepiece of all that is going on. This start screen is reminiscent of most tablet systems – a background upon which floating icons, or “tiles”, allow access to apps. Windows now also has its own app store, allowing customisation of tiling to such an extent you can practically build a roman villa. I won’t talk about the apps available here, but expect another article soon looking into them.

Despite this change to a start screen Windows 8 also retains the traditional desktop. Those tiles for programmes without dedicated apps simply open on a desktop that any windows user will recognise. This leads to the confusing situation where some functions can be performed both by a standalone “app” and by a programme on your desktop.

For an example I’ll use internet explorer. This can be opened in the standard way via your desktop as an icon. However, it can also be a completely separate app. This means that If I click a link on my email app it opens the internet explorer app as standard, however if I choose a hyperlink from a word document (opened via the desktop) then it opens on the desktop browser; often meaning that I can have several tabs open spread over both the desktop and the app, not ideal.

In addition, it can be hard to remember how you are playing your music – many times I have had to do something such as answer my phone and hence pause my music. This could involve opening the app in which it is playing, opening a desktop programme, or even pausing an in-browser music player on either of the two browsers. I find it’s generally faster simply to mute my speakers. Again, not ideal.

As I mentioned, I use two screens to do my work. Whilst this does make my room somewhat resemble the lair of a bond cybervillan, I find it incredibly improves my productivity. Using two screens is nothing new, but Windows 8 makes it much easier to set up these screens than some previous versions have. However, the system does have some small issues with the use of two screens. Sometimes apps open on the wrong screen, cursors sometimes disappear and scrolling on the start screen is clunky. In addition, it is not possible to split your auxiliary screen into two, though even I admit that having 4 apps visible at ones is somewhat superfluous.

Windows 8 also has some issues opening old pieces of software. For my dissertation I used a variety of image and spectral analysis software packages. These all worked perfectly fine on both Vista and Windows 7, but crash when used on my new machine – there is limited support for these programmes, especially if they are old.

Overall, Windows 8 shows much promise, but to me it has lost out by clinging to its old successes. The change to a new start screen is a great idea, and probably necessary with the move to touch screens. However, by keeping the desktop as such a prevalent feature, Windows seem to be attempting to ease us into it. In my opinion this makes the whole experience clunky and slow. Windows claim that this operating system is the fastest ever; my PC does boot up incredibly fast, and switching between apps is just as quick and easy as changing between desktop windows when you use the alt+tab shortcut on your keyboard. I do feel that by playing it safe, and keeping the desktop feature in to reassure users, Windows have lost a chance to seriously change to face of computing. Even if the users had been put off by the new start screen, Windows’ monopoly on the low end of the computer market means that really, they don’t have much choice.

Photograph: Dell Inc.