Winding Words: The Cathedral Part 13

by Katie Lumsden

When I hear crying, I rush into the tent, and there sits Isabelle, in floods of tears. This is rather terrifying for me. I hardly know what to do. She is crying. I barely know how to comfort and control myself when I cry, and so to help someone else in such a state is bewildering. I stand in the entrance of the tent for a long time, and then I amaze myself by sitting down beside her, and hugging her.

I feel her shake in my arms.

I ask, “Are you alright?”

And she says, in a shaking voice, “My foot really, really hurts.”

I do not know much about people. I do not know much about anything. But I certainly know enough to know that her foot must have been hurting for two weeks solidly, and that she was reading the post, and that there are tears flooding down her cheeks. So I ask, “Was it the letters?”

She says nothing, but raises her hands to cling to my arms around her shoulders.

It is a long time before she finally speaks, and when she does, she says, her voice still shuddering and uneven, “I got a letter from Jack.”

Of course I have no idea who Jack is. I hardly know whether or not I ought to ask. But she says nothing more so, at last, I ask, “Who is Jack?”

“My… boyfriend.” She sighs. “Oh God.”

This situation is not only confusing me, but frightening me too. I do not like being in charge of comforting anyone. I feel uneasy. “What did he say?” I ask. “Do you… want to talk about it?”

She sighs, and moves her hands from mine to wipe her eyes. She looks at me. “Will you help me outside?”

I suppose there is nothing else to do, and so I help lift her and, with her arm around my waist, she manages to limp outside. I help her sit down on the stones, and she sighs again. She wipes her eyes once more, and then looks up at me. I sit down beside her.

“Sorry about this,” she mutters.

“Are you alright?”

“I… well, you see, Jack and I, we’re not exactly – well, our relationship isn’t exactly ideal.”

She stops speaking, and I frown. “Does he know you are here?”

“He thinks I’m researching, which I am, and that he hasn’t heard from me because I’m annoyed and don’t want to speak to him, which is also true.” She has stopped crying now, and another sigh escapes her. “I just didn’t expect a letter and I was forgetting and now… oh, I don’t know what to do.”

“You can’t do anything anyway,” I say. When she looks at me, confused, I panic. “The post box is miles away,” I say, my heartbeat increasing. “I cannot go out there again. Really, I do not think I can do it. Of course, if you really had to, then – but still, I would rather not. It was bad enough yesterday–”

“Oh I don’t want to send a letter back.” She has interrupted me, and I breathe easier at her words. “I only meant that I don’t know what to do when my foot heals and I leave this place. Jack and I don’t exactly get on well together. His letter’s awful. He’s upset with me, but then, he always is.”

I look at her. I have no experience of relationships, of love. I have no idea what it means, how it works. It confuses me, and so I ask, “Why?”

“Because I’m pretty horrible to him, really.”

She sighs, and I stare. Her presence may be annoying, at times, and she may be strange and determined, and, true, she once pointed a gun at me, but I cannot imagine this odd ghostly friend of mine being horrible to anybody. “What do you mean?”

“I study and research a lot,” she says, “and that takes up a lot of my time. I travel a lot, looking at cathedrals, monasteries, ruins, libraries… I don’t exactly have much time for Jack and I don’t make any for him either, which is bad, but – and then he doesn’t understand, you see. He doesn’t have a passion for anything like I do. I could spend all my life sitting in old ruins.” She throws her hands up in the air with a short laugh. “Jack wants to sit at home. And he wants kids.” She covers her face with her hands.

I am vaguely grasping the meaning of her words. This is all alien to me, but I am just about managing to follow the conversation. “And you… don’t?”

“I used to when I was younger, but now I don’t. Now I just want to write papers on monasteries. Jack thinks it’s pretentious, and… well, he wants children, and I just shrug off the conversation whenever he talks about it, and avoid it, like I avoid everything, but I know it makes him upset and angry and… then everything gets even worse.”

I ask, softly, “Do you love him?”

She looks at me directly, and frowns, as though surprised by the question. “I used to,” she says. “I don’t know now. I mean, sometimes I do, but it’s… it’s like that I sometimes believe in God. Sometimes I love Jack. But most of the time, I just don’t know. A lot of the time I think I feel nothing at all.”

“Then–” I hesitate, and I think. I know nothing, of course, but I know enough, or at least I have vague memories from my past life, images of love that I got from films or books long before my thirteen years of solitude. “Then, surely you should… separate…?” Again Isabelle looks at me in surprise, and I panic and worry that I have been rude, so add, stumbling over my words, “I know nothing about these things, but…”

“You’re probably right,” she says, and then she sighs and looks away. “The thing is that we’ve been together since we were fifteen, for eleven years. That’s a long time – a very long time.”

“Almost as long as I have been here.”

“Exactly. So you see, Hugh, I can’t imagine being with anybody else… I can’t imagine leaving Jack even though, most days, I can’t imagine marrying him or having children with him either. I want to forget about the future and just live, but… well, life doesn’t work like that. You can’t just ignore time.”

“I’ve managed to do it,” I say, “almost.”

She sighs. “To leave Jack would be too frightening. We’ve grown up together. The problem is that while we were growing up we grew apart too, but we’ve stayed together because we’re used to each other, and because we love each other – or at least we did. When I went on this research project he got angry, and I thought maybe he’d end it, he’d leave, but in his letter he’s asking me to come home, so clearly he hasn’t…When my foot’s healed I’ll go back to London, back to Jack. I don’t really have another choice. I don’t know what to do. My injury is almost convenient – I mean because I’ve been hiding here, in a way.”

“Cathedrals are good for hiding,” I say, with a dim smile.

“I know. But I also know I have to decide, to face up to the facts and confront everything, but–”

I ask, “Why?”

Once more Isabelle stares. “What do you mean?”

“Why not just hide?”

This seems to amaze her. “But… that’s cowardly.”

“Would you rather be a happy coward or a miserable hero?”

She laughs, and I am glad to see her laugh. Frowns and tears do not suit her. I begin to laugh as well. “Which are you then?” she asks. “The happy coward or the miserable hero?”

The question chokes my laughter. “Both,” I murmur. “I have been both. I was a hero once and it made me miserable. I am a coward now, and I am happy.”

She stares, and seems to think, and there is a long silence between us. I look back. “What about you then, Hugh?” she says. “You know my problems now. What about you? If you’re a coward too, what are you hiding from?”

“People and time,” he says, “like you.”

“Yes, but… well, why?”

I break the gaze, and look away. I frown hard, and I say nothing. To answer such a question would be too much. Besides, her misery seems a little cleared now, and her eyes, though red, are dry. She will cope. I stand up and walk away.

New chapter every Monday and Thursday!