Will the energy crisis go nuclear?
By Madeleine Perry
Nuclear fission is one of the most controversial methods of generating energy. The potential for large-scale, newsworthy disasters has made it an unpopular choice for some. Right now, however, Europe is going through an unprecedented energy crisis. Most of us have already felt the effects of this crisis; the price of energy in the UK has continued to climb throughout the year alongside the rising gas prices in western Europe. Should we rely on nuclear energy more? Are the risks actually substantiated?
Public concerns about plant meltdowns, storage of radioactive waste, and potential use of fissionable materials for weaponry had been growing since the first nuclear plants were built, and were exacerbated by disasters such as Chornobyl in 1986, but despite this, nuclear remained a quickly-growing technology throughout the late 20th century. The disaster in Fukushima in 2011, however, led to a global reduction in nuclear power plant output of almost 300 TWh over the next two years, enough to power the lives of around 45 million average Europeans a year. Global nuclear energy output did not recover fully from this until 2019. Germany took the decision to phase out all nuclear power after this incident, which has since been nearly achieved – the last three nuclear power plants in Germany are due for closure this year. This process, however, may be disrupted since the European Union is experiencing such a high demand for energy.
Energy demand has been rising for decades, but European energy suppliers struggled to meet the sharp increase in demand after we started to come out of the COVID-19 pandemic. The Russian war against Ukraine has worsened the situation considerably since then: Russia cut off gas supplies to many countries in the EU, with natural gas exports by pipeline declining by almost 40% during the first seven months of 2022 alone. The UK was also hit harder by the European fuel insecurity because of the closure of the Rough energy storage facility in 2017, which had provided 70% of the UK’s gas storage for many years.
Europe desperately wants energy security. In a statement to the European Commission centred around Russia’s behaviour, President von der Leyen stated: “In any event, whether it is a partial or a major cut-off of Russian gas, or a total cut-off of Russian gas, Europe needs to be ready.” So how can we be ready? How can we maintain energy security when our fossil fuel infrastructure becomes unreliable?
Despite its potential for disaster, nuclear power is one of the most efficient, and arguably one of the cleanest, energy sources that are currently available. One of the benefits of nuclear fission, apart from the lack of carbon emissions, is that a very large amount of energy can be generated from a small amount of fissionable material. Development and running costs may be high, but the technology has improved immensely over the years and has been steadily providing European countries with power for decades.
According to the data, the public perception that nuclear power is more dangerous than other energy sources is entirely false. Fossil fuels actually account for an extremely large amount of deaths per unit of energy generated than nuclear, hydropower or renewable energy. The Chernobyl and Fukushima disasters were tragic, but the actual death tolls from each disaster have been estimated to be 433 and 2,314 respectively. The death toll of nuclear accidents is actually very low compared to the millions of deaths associated with air pollution each year, even when accounting for how long each method has been around. Nuclear energy results in 99.9% fewer deaths than brown coal; 99.8% fewer than coal; 99.7% fewer than oil; and 97.6% fewer than gas.
The current and future deaths associated with climate change, so directly related to greenhouse gas emissions, are also significant. If greenhouse gas emissions are not reduced quickly enough, then an extraordinary amount of deaths from global warming, natural disasters and other events associated with carbon emissions could be caused in the future as a direct result of our inaction today.
Nuclear power isn’t a quick fix for the European energy crisis, partly because of political factors out of scientists’ control. Neither is it a quick fix for the climate crisis, partly because it can’t be the only solution. According to Markandya and Wilkinson (2007): “Commercial exploitation [of nuclear power] will not be achieved in time to help the crucial near-term reduction in greenhouse-gas emissions.” This unfortunate truth does not negate the fact that the safest, most health-conscious option for a cleaner future is undoubtedly a transition from fossil fuels to a combination of nuclear power, hydropower and renewable energy.

