Why was there a measles outbreak in Disneyland?
Measles was declared eradicated in the U.S. during the year 2000. Yet last year a record 644 people contracted the disease in 27 states. This year has barely begun, but already looks set to surpass the number with approximately 100 measles cases linked to a single outbreak in Disneyland, California.
The illness is caused by an extremely contagious virus which can be propagated through the air by coughing or sneezing, and will linger on surfaces for several hours.
To make matters worse, people can become contagious days before showing any symptoms. These include a painful rash which has caused many of the affected patients to be hospitalised.
In 2013, measles killed an average of 400 people every day. Although few patients currently die of the disease if they receive medical attention, it can cause life-lasting complications, such as deafness or intellectual disability through encephalitis (swelling of the brain).
The vast majority of people affected in this outbreak were unvaccinated. This includes several infants who were too young to receive the vaccine, but also many who were not.
The MMR (measles, mumps and rubella) vaccine is widely available and works especially well for this virus; it has an effectiveness of 97 percent – compared, say, to 88 percent for mumps. This means that people who have followed their MMR vaccination schedule (two doses) have a 3 in 100 chance of contracting the disease if exposed. Despite this, many people choose not to take it, or not to let their children take it.
Fear of vaccines has been around for as long as vaccines have, but the modern anti-vaccination movement largely stemmed from the publication of a paper in the Lancet in 1998, which detailed the cases of eight children thought to have developed autism following their first MMR shot.
The publication spurred numerous scientific studies which have, to date, found no correlation between vaccines and autism. What was found, however, was manipulation of the truth in the original paper, which lead to the revocation of its lead author’s medical license. In a very rare case in the history of science, the paper was removed from the journal, but its original influence is still felt today.
The MMR vaccine controversy has been called “the most damaging medical hoax of the last 100 years”, a claim which definitely seems supported by the newfound measles prevalence. But why exactly is the anti-vaccination movement so dangerous?
The answer lies in one crucial number of measles epidemiology: R0. In disease modelling, the basic reproduction number, ‘r-nought’, describes the average number of people that a contagious person will infect before recovering.
For measles, this is very high: somewhere between 12 and 18. Compare that to the estimated 1.5 – 2.5 of last year’s Ebola epidemic.
R0 is used to predict the percentage of the population that must be vaccinated in order to prevent an outbreak. The basis of this calculation is that enough vaccinations will lower the effective value of Ro below 1, as more immune people cause the pool of susceptible individuals to dwindle. It explains why highly contagious diseases, like measles, require higher vaccination thresholds to achieve ‘herd immunity’.
Governments can set measles vaccination coverage goals at 95 percent in an attempt to protect the whole population. The problem is that this calculation overlooks people who are not eligible for vaccines, which includes babies, but also individuals at risk from them on medical grounds, such as those with immunodeficiencies or allergies.
It also assumes homogeneous mixing within the population, but the outbreak at Disneyland has demonstrated that in some communities more people refuse vaccination. Two Disney-related cases have been traced back to Colorado, where the vaccination rate is at a national low of 86 percent.
This is where anti-vaxxers come in. Not only do they put their children at risk, they endanger those who are not eligible for vaccination, plus that three percent of vaccinated individuals who will inevitably contract the disease if exposed – all of whom rely on herd immunity for protection.
Ultimately, maximum vaccination coverage is a matter of responsible citizenship; if you can get vaccinated, you should, for yourself and for those who can’t.
Photograph:Â Julien Harneis on flickr

