Why the sun is yet to set on racism in English football

By Amelia Hatfield

Five games into the Premier League season, racism has returned to rear its ugly head.

Manchester United’s Marcus Rashford was subject to a tirade of online racist abuse and threats from his club’s own fans after missing a penalty against Crystal Palace in August, following a week in which Twitter had been condemned for its inaction over racist abuse targeted at Paul Pogba and Tammy Abraham.

This is part of a worrying trend: in the 2018/2019 season alone, anti-racism charity Kick It Out received 274 reports of racist incidents at all levels of English football. This includes the incident caught on live television where a Chelsea fan was filmed screaming abuse at Raheem Sterling.

Last weekend, Dover Athletic striker Inih Effiong was subjected to racist abuse from a number of Hartlepool United supporters after cupping his ear to celebrate the penalty he had just scored. Black players Peter Kioso, Gus Mafuta, Nicke Kabamba and Gime Toure were all on the pitch for Hartlepool at the time and were visibly distressed by events. Two arrests have since been made.

It appears that no BAME player can escape the racism that exists within English football. But this is nothing new. For decades, black players at every level of English football have had to contend with racist chanting and behaviours.

Paul Canoville, Chelsea’s first black player, remembers vividly how his own fans threw bananas onto the pitch and made monkey noises at him as he warmed up in the 1980s. He was offered no support from the FA or Chelsea, and no fans were ever penalised for their actions. He was left helpless and undefended as he was battered by vicious threats and insults.

In later life, years of racial trauma proved psychologically damaging and Canoville turned to substance abuse to mitigate the effects of the racism he suffered during his career as a footballer. In 2018, thirty years after Canoville retired, a Tottenham fan was banned for four years for throwing a banana skin at Arsenal forward Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang in a chillingly similar event.

Evidently, racism is an issue embedded in English football, and an historic inadequacy in addressing this can be observed in the recurring frequency of racist incidents.

However, racism in English football extends beyond singular incidents that are overtly abusive, and is embedded in English football’s very structure.

The EFL has been widely criticised for a lack of BAME representation and is disproportionately dominated by white managers. Until 1993, there had not been a single black manager in the football league and currently England’s top four divisons only feature three sides managed by BAME men. Across English football, executorial positions are held exclusively by white men.

And despite the appointment of six BAME individuals (Chris Powell, Michael Johnson, Jason Euell, Marcus Bignot, Omer Riza and Matthew Thorpe) on one-year placements with various England age-groups, the FA has never had a BAME executive and representation at the very top of the game sets the precedent that football is a sport that largely belongs to white men.

However, football is not alone in possessing such disparate representation figures. Much like the lack of diversity in football management, arenas such as politics and business also struggle with BAME representation at their most senior levels. Out of 650 British MPs, only 51 are BAME. English football clearly has an entrenched and structural problem with racism, but this is a mirrored image of society itself.

English football clearly has an entrenched and structural problem with racism, but this is a mirrored image of society itself.

Previous strategies to try and tackle racism within English football have been limited by their focus on football alone, as though it is an isolated sphere with little to no societal impact. As shown by the continuation of racial abuse and inequality, such strategies have thus far failed.

To effectively confront racism in football, the game must be viewed as a microcosm of society, not a separate entity. A comprehensive approach to tackling racism in football would recognise it as a symptom of and contributor to wider racial injustices, not something detached from the rest of society.

This extends to the newly evolved form of racism within English football: verbal abuse via social media. Through harsher sanctions such as lifetime stadium bans for fans exhibiting racist behaviour and fines for teams whose fans do this, incidences of racism in the stands at football matches have decreased over the previous twenty seasons.

However, social media has facilitated a rise in overall number of racist incidents within English football as the anonymity allowed by platforms such as Twitter mean that verbal racist abuse is becoming easier to commit and harder to catch. Consequently, football’s historic problem with racism is being exacerbated by the emergence of social media, and social media companies’ inability and reluctance to investigate these behaviours has reversed much of the progress made against racism over the past two decades.

Again, this is symptomatic of the historic problem football has with countering racism, but is also a feature of wider society. Online racist abuse is not confined to football, and is even more prevalent in politics. After missing their penalties, Marcus Rashford and Paul Pogba experienced the vile, often terrifying, verbal abuse that BAME politicians such as Diane Abbot and David Lammy are subject to on a daily basis.

Social media companies are regularly criticised for their inability to deal with fascist online content and this is a phenomenon that goes beyond football. English football exists within a society that, worsened by social media, allows the circulation and acceptance of openly racist sentiments, and as such no amount of fines or bans from the FA can prevent racist abuse because it is a feature of every day British life.

While racism is unarguably an historic problem that has been too leniently dealt with by English football’s governing bodies, it is not a problem belonging exclusively to football.

It must be acknowledged that for English football to truly tackle racism it should be understood within the context of society as a whole.

Whilst football has monumental problems with a lack of BAME representation in managerial and executorial positions, this mirrors a lack of representation in senior positions of power across society.

Whilst football has a serious issue with online racist abuse, this is a global phenomenon that is not being handled effectively by the companies in charge of these platforms.

Football’s governing bodies are helpless to tackle online racist abuse when even government agencies cannot do so. Viewing it as the responsibility of football alone to confront these issues is akin to putting a sticking plaster over a stab wound – treating the symptom, but not the cause.

English football has an entrenched, historic problem with racism, and so does British society.

Image courtesy of FallingMage via Flickr and Creative Commons