Why the fear of poetry? Sentimentality in poetic substance

By Emma Sansbury

The idea that poetry is overly sentimental and lacking in ‘real substance’ is one I have often found myself succumbing to. As an English student, it seems almost sacrilegious to disregard an entire form of literature, and yet, time and again I have turned my nose up at poetry in favour of some other more ‘serious’ mode. But I’m hardly the first person to take this perspective: the ‘excessive’ emotional expression of poets, with their lyrical cliches about sunsets and gushing declarations of love, has so often been met with contempt by readers. And so, it seems important to deconstruct why so many people feel this way. Is this criticism of poetry valid, or simply a reflection on reader’s discomfort with emotional sincerity today?

Literary critics largely use ‘sentimentality’ as a negative label, denoting an expression of feeling in excess of what a situation calls for. Amongst poets accused of sentimental writing, the popular American poet Mary Oliver takes a prominent role. Oliver’s reliance on vague, natural imagery often tips her work into cliché, in pursuit of profound emotional truths about faith and the human condition.

The idea that poetry is overly sentimental and lacking in ‘real substance’ is one I have often found myself succumbing to

In ‘Green, Green is My Sister’s House’, Oliver narrates the experience of climbing a tree as an adult, personifying the nature of her childhood in the lines ‘the tree is a sister to me, she | lives alone in a green cottage | high in the air’. Here, she arguably relies on a nostalgically simple conception of nature to evoke the desired emotional response in her reader. The familiarly idealised image of nature as universally welcoming and gentle in Oliver’s poetry removes her work from reality and pushes it towards romantic sentiment.

This is likely a factor in the general contempt for sentimental poetry. Readers feel cheated into unearned emotional responses through cheap, overused clichés that claim to reveal truths about all humanity. Instead of finding truth and clarity, poets can miss the mark and provide ideas that avoid depth or complexity, consequently feeling emotionally laboured and empty.

Rather than using emotions to explore profound truths, war poets like Brooke used nostalgia to manipulate reader’s emotions

Looking further back, sentimentality took on a political role in the poetry which came out of the First World War; idealising England as a perfect Eden and romanticising the honour of death in battle. Rupert Brooke’s renowned poem ‘The Soldier’ fed into the idea that the war would be a glorious affair, convincing young men that dying for their country was the ultimate aim. The line ‘A body of England’s, breathing English air, | Washed by the rivers, blest by suns of home’, lends an idyllic pastoral atmosphere to the poem, invoking the nostalgic patriotism of England as a natural haven. The defence of the homeland therefore becomes a matter of noble sacrifice, and not of large-scale unnecessary suffering. The sentiments in this poem feel incredibly narrow and short-sighted, disregarding the brutal reality of war in favour of imperial glory.

Rather than using emotions to explore profound truths, war poets like Brooke used nostalgia to manipulate reader’s emotions, suggesting an ideological function to poetic sentimentality. This portrays the emotional excess of poetry as disingenuous, as a tool to produce the intended impact on an audience. For some readers, disdain for poetry can be attributed to a lack of personal emotional connection within a poem, resulting from manufactured sentiments intended to appear universally profound.

However, it is important to consider the conditions that have led us to view sentimentality in such a negative light. The assumption that sentimental poetry is not ‘literary’ has been championed by elite academic circles and arguably takes a snobbish view that excessively emotional works stray from the rational intellect of academia. In dismissing the popular, simplistic sentiment of Oliver’s poetry, critics fail to recognise the accessibility of her work. Furthermore, the application of emotion over reason is a charge traditionally levied at women in a supposedly rational male dominated society. This suggests that the condemnation of sentimental poetry is a product of scorn from masculine academic circles for feminised language in poetry. The disdain for excess emotion in poetry is perhaps, then, shaped not only by literary concerns but also by assumptions fostered by the exclusionary structures of academia.

As well as this, the rejection of sentimentality in poetry highlights a cultural discomfort with emotional sincerity. Today, excessive emotional expression is often regarded as embarrassing or cringeworthy, with irony and cool detachment preferred over open discussion of personal feelings.  Therefore, instead of resisting poetry for its cliché sentiment, readers are avoiding the emotional openness demanded of them through poetry. The sentimentality of poetry is perhaps then a strength, with poets attempting to explore emotional truths displaying an admirable vulnerability that is increasingly rejected by contemporary culture.

The critique of sentimental poetry should not go without merit: its reliance on shallow cliché as a shortcut to emotional response feels lazy and manipulative. However, the common declaration of ‘I hate poetry’ is arguably more a product of disdain for the emotional sincerity it demands than any literary failing.

Image: Henry Wallis via Wikimedia Commons.