Why Rachael was right – The trial of St. Cuth’s

I hesitate before writing this. I was highly critical of the DSU’s handling of the proposed Israel boycott and was rightly reminded how infuriating it can be for students who get involved in the DSU to be criticised by outsiders like myself who have contributed next to nothing.

I also remember how frustrating it was during my term as President of the Union Society, when time and again I came up against people who had never even been to a DUS event but were happy to perpetuate its largely misconceived negative image.

Nevertheless, I want to commend Rachael Revesz for bringing attention to the shortcomings of our JCR exec in the last edition of Palatinate. Farcical is the only word which I think is applicable to what I have seen of their conduct since I arrived at Durham.

I am aware that many students contribute to the life of the JCR. There was a fantastic atmosphere around the boathouse when I attempted to row last year. The library is an outstanding resource, and it is a credit to the ethos of Cuthbert’s that its running is largely overseen by students. I sing in Cuthberts’ choir, in which the standard of music making is extremely high.

This context, however, serves further to isolate actions of the exec. Vaunting our apparently unique history, they actually fail to realise the aims and ambitions of both our founding members and our current students: that’s why I think the JCR exec is becoming increasingly irrelevant.

Let me give an example. In response to Rachael’s criticism of inappropriate questions at hustings, one member of the exec argued: ”If a candidate for Vice President doesn’t have the confidence to change into the incumbent VC’s trousers (as was the result of one question asked recently), how is he/she going to have the confidence to stand up to Senior Management or St. Cuthbert’s Society Council to defend the students and their causes?”

Trying to justify joke questions as an essential tool of the democratic process is possibly the most ridiculous thing I have heard since starting at this university.

I personally believe that light-heartedness has its purposes. It can help to engage apathetic students with their JCRs, testament to which are the informal hustings at Hatfield College which are much better attended than the formal hustings. But the last time I looked, JCR meetings at Cuthbert’s are still as badly attended as ever.

Taking your trousers off does not show competency to be able to sensibly and constructively work with the Senior Management at St. Cuthbert’s; indeed, the exec may be very good at getting naked but they show a complete lack of ability to show the skills which I would hope to see in the JCR.

I would have hoped that the JCR exec would have made particular effort to start building a relationship with the new Principal of the Society from the beginning of this term. Yet in a meeting with second years, two weeks into the job, Professor Towl was already expressing his irritation with the inability of the exec to arrange a time to meet with him.

Having now met Professor Towl on a few occasions, I can express my gladness that in reality it is he and not the students who actually run our Society. This is not in spite of our history: it is because of it. When I asked Professor Towl why he had applied to become Principal, he told me that it was St. Cuthbert’s historical uniqueness which had attracted him.

JCR exec members are forever stressing that the JCR President is the Society’s President and the merits of having a bar which is open 12 hours a day. But those are not the reasons why our new Principal applied; neither are they the reasons which I would give if questioned myself about Cuthbert’s merits. It is St. Cuthbert’s commitment to diversity, notably encouraging applications from international, local and mature students, of which I am proud.

It is Cuthbert’s tradition of seeking to draw such people into one collegiate and friendly environment which I think should be vaulted and nurtured. These are also the reasons that Professor Towl gave for his wanting to join us.

Since the beginning of this term, I think we have seen the potential of how much more St. Cuthbert’s could be under our new Principal’s energetic direction. This was symbolised by two emails which I received yesterday. The first was from the Senior Management, informing me that they would continue to run formals instead of the JCR exec in the wake of the boycott controversy.

They see this as “part of [their] ongoing work to improve the level of service and opportunities for student engagement”. These formals are cheaper, include more than ever, and will be held on a more regular basis than ever before in the Society’s history.

The second email was from Sean Collins, the Society’s President. It appears the Principal had expressed reservations about people getting naked in the bar in the cause of the democratic process. The husts were therefore taking place in the DSU rather than on Society property. Typically, the email was concluded by noting the size of Riverside’s bar.

The email, followed by a similar message via facebook from our Livers’ Out Representative, outlined the Principal’s actions in an unconstructive and negative fashion. Such a public stance cannot facilitate the necessary partnership that should be in place between the Senior Management and the JCR.

I feel that the Principal is working more positively on my behalf, and everyone else in Cuthbert’s, than the JCR exec: exactly the opposite of the case which the latter have tried to present. The dream scenario would be, however, if both could work together.

My fear is that St. Cuthberts’ student body will lose even more power to the Senior Management before our elected leaders realise that being a society, rather than the college which the university would love us to become, is a responsibility to be exercised maturely and not a right to be abused.