Why no platform policies are detrimental to defeating the BNP

One of the major sources of tension between Durham University and the NUS over the recent cancellation of the BNP debate has been the no platform policy.  It is a policy that the NUS showcase, so proud are they of this sparkling piece of union legislation.  At the NUS annual conference last year, executive officers proudly stood up and shouted emotive rhetoric about how the BNP did not recognise all of their members and how refusing to debate with them would destroy their small clutches of power and ensure a victory for freedom for all.

Sadly, it hasn’t quite worked out like that.  The BNP vote is increasing, and I believe these no platform policies are partly responsible.  To clarify, the NUS (amongst other organisations) refuses to allow the BNP to partake in a debate if any of their (NUS) members are also in the debate.  Naturally, therefore, they felt compelled to step in when Durham proposed their contentious debate.  Rather than simply attacking the NUS over this one move, we should examine the general no platform policy itself.

BNP voters are a fairly homogenous bunch; white, low-paid, and live in deprived areas.  I do not deny that some, if not many, possess racist views, and perhaps will never be tempted to vote for another party, but many feel simply neglected by the major parties.  I do not wish to criticise the Labour party here, but since the Blairite move into the centre-ground, Labour have undoubtedly lost their focus on (amongst others) white, low-paid, deprived area voters.  If the party that your family have consistently voted for suddenly start being interested in securing the votes of the professional classes (as happened in 1997) it cannot be surprising that they have felt betrayed.  There are still many supporters of nationalisation, for example, in this country, who, again, feel let down by Blair.

In this atmosphere of political betrayal, voters are likely to turn to outside parties.  The BNP message is simple; immigrants are taking your jobs and money.  It cannot be surprising that is a popular philosophy for a small section of easily persuaded voters.  They feel that the BNP actually are listening to their concerns (which no other party does) and hence, give them their vote.

This could be rectified, but no platform policies are actually making things worse.  If you vote BNP and then are told that the major parties will refuse to debate with your chosen candidate and that you must be an illegitimate, racist, neo-Nazi thug, isn’t that simply going to harden your resolve that mainstream society is not listening to you?  If you are an ‘illegitimate’ voter, then why should you vote for a main party?  Doesn’t that mean that your vote doesn’t really matter?  It leaves you with no choice but to vote BNP; the only party who will actually recognise you.  We need to engage with these voters; we need to explain why anti-immigration policies are a bad idea, why racism is unacceptable and win back their vote.  Most of all, we need to show that we do actually care about their opinions.  If we debate with the BNP, we can achieve these goals.  They have no real legitimate views; they thrive off hatred of other parties.  I know some BNP voters will never change, but perhaps David Cameron wasn’t being so stupid when he proposed that we ‘hug a hoodie’; maybe it’s time we start hugging disgruntled voters.  The NUS is wrong not just to stop the Union debate, but to refuse all contact with the BNP.  As students, we can use our intelligence to show their flaws and backwards views and win over their voters.  The worst thing to do would be to continue ignoring them.