Why Maddie Ziegler is not the appropriate star in Sia’s ‘Music’
By Ava Siena Cohen
Music, set to release in the UK in February 2021, has caused controversy, particularly among the disabled community long before its première. There are movements to boycott Sia’s film on social media. The film stars Kate Hudson as newly sober Zu, who is thrown into the position of carer for her half-sister Music. Music is a non-verbal autistic girl, played by Maddie Ziegler. Sia has received backlash for both her portrayal of autism, and the choice to cast a neurotypical actor as a neurodiverse character.
The NHS defines autism spectrum disorder as a developmental disability. Autistic people may find it hard to communicate with other people, and may struggle to process emotions. People with autism may find things such as bright lights and loud noises stressful or overwhelming. At its core, autism is an invisible disability.
Sia presents a blanket stereotype of autism through her protagonist, based on potential outwards signs of the condition. Music is non-verbal and wears ear defenders, and yes while this is some people with autism, autism is a spectrum. Not all autistic people are non-verbal. We must also remember that autism is an invisible condition, therefore as an audience, how can we truly understand autism from this film when Sia has rendered it visible?
With non-verbalism being used as a sign of autism, we must also consider that autism can occur alongside other disabilities such as ADHD. Somebody who has both autism and ADHD is quite unlikely to be completely non-verbal, like Music. Additionally, neurotypical people have non-verbal moments. A large focus of the trailer is Music’s stimming (repetitive or unusual movements or noises) which can sometimes help autistic people manage emotions and overwhelming situations. Autistic people have commented on social media stating that they have been bullied for their stim. Therefore, we have to question why Sia chose to feature it so prominently in her trailer.
Sia presents a blanket stereotype of autism through her protagonist
Some have speculated that Sia has done very limited research on the autistic spectrum, and while defending herself she cited Autism Speaks as her source of information. Autism Speaks, claims to support autistic people, yet they only use 4% of their annual budget to support autistic individuals. The rest goes towards researching a ‘cure’ for autism and finding a prenatal test to detect it. With no autistic people on their board they seem to spread more fear than information.
Much of the criticism that Sia has received is of her choice to Ziegler in the role of Music. Doing so in fact defeats the point of the story she is trying to tell. This is a story about an autistic child, therefore it should be told by an autistic person.
In a world where able bodied and neurotypical actors play 95% of disabled characters, the industry should be trying to present true inclusivity
Sia took to twitter to respond to the claims that she has excluded neurodiverse people from their own narrative, saying “I cast thirteen neurotypical people, three trans folk, and not as f**king prostitutes or drug addicts but as doctors, nurses and singers. F**king sad nobody’s even seen the dang movie. My heart has always been in the right place.”
However, if her heart really was in the right place, why would she cast neurodiverse people as side characters and not the protagonist of their own story? She additionally claimed to have “tried working with a beautiful young girl non-verbal on the spectrum and she found it unpleasant and stressful. So that’s why I cast Maddie”, which has caused many autistic actors to state that they would have been available and willing to step in on short notice.
In trying to defend herself, Sia has simply stated that she believes that a disabled person’s story has value, but they themselves have less value than neurotypical people. In a world where able bodied and neurotypical actors play 95% of disabled characters, the industry should be trying to present true inclusivity. The motion to boycott Music wants Sia to apologise for the mistakes made when producing this film, rather than argue with her critics.
Image: Kirk Stauffer via Wikimedia Commons

