Why gender blind casting still isn’t possible with all theatre

By Sofya Grebenkina
Gender blind casting is not a new-fangled method to attract theatre-goers by any means. However, just because it is a theatrical tradition this does not make it naturally viable for the modern stage. Theatre, with the advent of new creative visions and changing times, would do well to reconsider whether gender blind casting is still a necessary element for any production.
Those who know even a little about Shakespeare’s plays would know that all roles were originally only played by men. So unfamiliar was the concept of the female actor at the time, that when a French company put on a play with female actors in 1629, they were “pippin-pelted” by the English audience. Indeed male-only casting was true for all Renaissance plays in England, and some modern adaptations still choose to preserve the tradition of an all-male cast.
The 2012 RSC production of Twelfth Night was an all-male affair. It earned praise from The Guardian as being a “radical yet perfectly balanced production”. The comedic elements of this play rest on cross-dressing and the concealment of gender identity. Viola pretends to be Duke Orsino’s page, which becomes unfortunate since she quickly falls in love with him. A play which already questions gender identity and the discrepancy between men and women could perhaps only benefit from a gender fluid casting. A gender blind cast would mirror the play’s own experiments with gender roles and perhaps even go so far as to question the audience’s own perceptions of what constitutes the male and female gender.
There are nevertheless a whole series of plays which I personally would loathe to see cast gender blind. Tennessee Williams’ A Streetcar Named Desire falls into this category. Blanche DuBois is a frail and often nervous woman who is aggravated by the loss of her family home, Belle Reve. She comes to stay with her sister, Stella, who has married a gruff, working-class man, Stanley Kowalski. In the microcosm of a New Orleans home, the drama illuminates the tensions between the crumbling old Southern wealth and the rising immigrant working class. Blanche is stereotypically female while Stanley is stereotypically male; they are the antithesis of each other, and a conflict is inevitable. My personal aversion to a gender blind production of this play is not unconscious sexism on my part. It is founded on a belief that having a male actor playing Blanche unnecessarily forces the audience to apply extra effort in the suspension of their disbelief. A female actor playing Blanche would not require this unnecessary effort and would allow the audience to focus more keenly on the more integral issues explored within the play.
I believe this also holds with much other early American drama. Eugene O’Neill’s Long Day’s Journey into Night is a semi-autobiographical play throughout which a disturbing family dynamic is gradually unearthed. No matter how problematic and unusual the family seems to be, they do not altogether deviate from particular gender stereotypes. Indeed the play can be said to be an exploration of how each character’s perception of their gender roles has ultimately led to a tragic development. Gender blind casting in this case detracts from more important issues and serves little to no artistic purpose. It may even make the play comedic, which would ultimately undermine the play’s genre and destroy the audience’s experience of the play.
However, theatre is always progressing. As we leave behind the American drama of the 1950s, gender blind casting may even prove to be key to our understanding and enjoyment of modern drama. New plays which acknowledge that gender is a social construct and choose to incorporate the fact that gender identity constitutes a spectrum may necessitate a production which explores this avenue. In the end, any production’s choice to commit to a gender blind cast necessitates that this artistic decision is integral to the audience’s enjoyment and understanding of a particular creative vision, rather than it simply being a case of attempting to cast roles gender blind so that both genders have equal opportunities. Gender blind casting therefore is not intrinsically bad or good, but as with any other device in a production’s arsenal it cannot be used indiscriminately.
Photo: Isabelle Culkin
