Why cheating is good for the cheated

CARDS

By Jessica Medhurst 

Not being the chatty type when I was younger, I ended up spending a lot of time playing card games with my family. An all-round favourite was trumps, where one had to collect all four cards of the same number, with each person passing a card to the person on their left.

My uncle, however, would always sit to the right of his son, and pass “helpful” cards his way. In retrospect, given that his son was the youngest of us, and therefore struggled even to understand the game, this was probably justified. However, at the time, I could barely control my rage (especially as I was usually beaten by my parents in every round). This instilled in me a lifelong instinct that cheating is wrong.

In certain circumstances, however, cheating is very rational and helpful to more parties than just the cheaters themselves. More light has been shed on the use of ‘bots’ – invasive computer programs which can distort ticket selling. For example, if, say, Leeds Festival release tickets come out, the program will automatically purchase thousands of tickets, creating a shortage of supply and wielding undue oligopolistic power over the secondary market, estimated at £1bn per year.

This is no insignificant phenomenon, on busy days, around 90 per cent of TicketMaster’s traffic can be generated by bots re-selling tickets. Naturally, this makes customers irate, much like the frustration I felt when I found out about the trumps-cheater. Surely it is in the interests of the ticket sellers to regulate, given that they lose consumer loyalty as a result?

However, even if we assume that the market is competitive enough that consumers are able to turn to other festivals for tickets, unlike normal circumstances of ‘cheating’, this actually suits the ticket sellers. Bots could provide Leeds Festival with an instant chunk of cash, which they could then invest to reap greater rewards. It could allow them to project numbers more definitively, so they can make earlier, cheaper contracts with suppliers. In this way, the incentives of the cheaters and the company are aligned, although this is not to say that ticket sellers actually encourage bots

This can be found in instances outside of economic exchanges. An article in the Economist hypothesised that drug inspected will likely work for the National Federation of the sport in question, an organisation which has some vested interest in keeping the sport alive. The Prisoner’s dilemma ensures that most athletes are overwhelmingly likely to choose the ‘cheating solution’ (taking drugs), as they do not trust their other competitors not to. Wishing to promote the sport (and therefore keep their jobs), but also to deter athletes from taking performance enhancing drugs, drug inspectors only name and shame a select few athletes. The article states that  “near-universal cheating” could be revealed in some sports by “anecdotal evidence”.

This can also be found in the labour market: in 2012 Yahoo’s CEO Scott Thompson was found out to have a fabricated Computer Science degree on his CV. This is likely because people understand that careers can be made on opportunities, and to a large degree the amount and quality of opportunities one arrives at is down to luck, or better explained as path dependency. Students wishing to get into decent universities often turn joining a netball club into ‘co-founded and presided over Netball Society’.

This is not to say that the exaggerators, or the ‘cheaters’ do not deserve to get the job or university place in question, but rather, they ‘cheat’ because they have to in order to get something that they know they deserve. In the case of exaggerating on one’s CV, this is relatively common, and so we arrive at the Prisoner’s dilemma again: if everyone is exaggerating their achievements on paper, it would take a saint to be so self-sacrificial to refrain from doing so, just for the purpose of reaching a non-cheating Nash Equilibrium for society’s sake.

Was my frustration over cheating justified? My latest findings indicate that the answer to this may not be so black and white as I had previously thought. Although Eleanor Roosevelt once said that “well behaved women rarely make history”, I think a wise friend (my dad) once told me that it’s better to play uncontroversial games, like hopscotch. Having said that, the possibilities of cheating in hopscotch are endless.

Photograph:  sylvainchalifoux