Why are we so obsessed with love onscreen?

By Matikudza Chiromo

Love is universal. That’s my cop-out answer to this question given how big it is. I tried to narrow down two lists: ‘Love Movies’ and ‘Love Movies (?)’. The first list includes stories that depend on love. The whole plot is set around the will-they-won’t-they dynamic or, better yet, how our protagonists fall in love from the first glance to the end credits. But the ‘Love Movies (?)’, those are the complicated ones.

Take Fight Club (1999) for example, the story of an anti-capitalist agenda and the manic episode that comes along with it. Yet still Marla walks into Jack’s life and both his personas can’t get enough of her. Even in School Daze (1988) the colourist themes, the anti-Apartheid T-shirts and Gamma Phi propaganda didn’t seem to be enough. Jane had to sing ‘Be Alone Tonight’ for us to really start paying attention. 

It almost starts to seem as though love makes things matter to us

It almost starts to seem as though love makes things matter to us. Take this right now for example; I said ‘colourist themes’ and the only thing you kept your mind on up to this point was love. The subject matter can be very heavy in most of the things we watch, even when it isn’t always explicit. What it definitely is, is real. 

There is reality in pain and the unromantic sides of life. Those are universal too. So maybe throwing love in makes it easier to actually focus and absorb these topics. Jack deals with unemployment and poverty and this is so real. But then he bumps into Marla and for a second things aren’t as bleak as they once were. Spike Lee creates Jane, who has to deal with a modern America that viewed her lighter complexion as better than those of her darker sisters. But as she leads us into her heartbreak through song, the viewer gets heartbroken too.

Maybe we don’t actually need love in these movies. Maybe it’s been happening for so long that it’s almost expected. Maybe all these writers are caught in a whirlpool of production companies that won’t take on their projects without a love story attached to them. If this is the case, I can’t say that I’m angry. When love is represented the right way, it makes sitting through the occasional Joey and Rachel worth it (unfortunately a Friends reference but I cannot think of a worse onscreen couple).  

Let’s look at Django Unchained (2012). A ‘Love Movie (?)’ for the ages. Django, his long, lost love Broomhilda and America’s antebellum south. Quentin Tarantino is known to lace a film in a lot of blood and a lot of violence but the reality is that when it comes to the violence against the African Americans in the film, he didn’t have to make any of it up. If we don’t have Django and Broomhilda to root for, what we receive is the heart-wrenching re-enactment of a very dark period in our world’s history. The love story doesn’t take anything away from the violence, it just creates the possibility of love surviving in the worst conditions. We don’t get forced dialogue or lust dressed up as love. We receive a jarring depiction of co-dependency. A love that exists between two people in a place where love wasn’t allowed to exist. It is these love stories that make sifting through the imposition of romance in a film that could really have done without it, count. 

Love is universal and when it’s done right, we do need it

I am sticking to my cop-out answer. Love is universal and when it’s done right, we do need it. We do need to see the way people anywhere, on different walks of life, still have something in common. I can’t safely say that everyone has experienced love the way it’s depicted in the movies but I can say that we all know how to recognise it. It is in this recognition that universality unfolds. Whether you’re watching Roman Holiday (1953) or Carmen Jones (1954) we can all spot love. I hate to come across like a romantic but I will admit that I am biased. When love is done right, when we can all recognise it and register its depth, we do need it. 

Image: Denise Jans via Unsplash